Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands, Greece and Austria, all EU member states, announced on Monday the creation of a migrant deportation center in Rwanda where they will send foreigners whose asylum applications have been rejected and who cannot be returned to their countries of origin. The initiative, which the sponsoring governments plan to implement in 2027, comes as Brussels seeks a way to resolve one of the main stumbling blocks in its migration policy: the huge gap between the removal orders issued by the 27 and the returns they actually manage to carry out.The figures illustrate the scale of the logjam: in 2025, EU member states issued 491,950 return orders for non-EU nationals, but there were only 135,460 deportations, 28% — in fact the highest rate in the past 10 years, according to Eurostat. Reasons include the absence of readmission agreements, difficulties identifying people and obtaining travel documents, and lack of cooperation from some countries of origin that refuse to recognize nationality or readmit their citizens, the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) concluded in an analysis of return systems published in March 2025.To improve these outcomes, Europe is looking for solutions beyond its borders, and this is not the first time it has done so: over the past decade the EU has signed a series of migration cooperation agreements of varying kinds with countries such as Libya, Tunisia, Morocco and Mauritania to bolster surveillance, curb irregular departures, fight people‑smuggling networks and improve cooperation on returns. The Rwanda project introduces a substantial difference: it is no longer about preventing migrants from entering Europe or sending them back to their countries of origin, but about relocating to a third country people who have already entered EU territory, who have no right to remain and whose expulsions could not be executed.Estrella Galán, a Member of the European Parliament for The Left and general director of the Spanish Commission for Refugee Aid (CEAR) from 2011 to 2024, questions that the effectiveness of European migration policy “should be measured by the number of expulsions,” calling it “a true failure.” In her view, outsourcing responds to a strategy that moves both people and states’ responsibilities outside Europe.The initiative follows the pattern of other European attempts to outsource migration policies, such as the Italy‑Albania agreement, but it proposes a different model: relocating people with pending return orders to a country with which they do not necessarily have any ties.The United Kingdom signed an agreement with Rwanda in 2022 to send asylum seekers to the African country, but the project never materialized because the Supreme Court declared it unlawful a year later, finding there were substantiated reasons to believe those transferred faced a real risk of being returned to their countries of origin where they could suffer persecution or ill‑treatment. The government tried to revive it with amendments, but the Labour government of Keir Starmer cancelled it definitively in 2024, judging it an ineffective mechanism whose results did not justify the cost.Today, however, this option is easier to pursue because of a change in the legal framework that facilitates such expulsions since October 1, 2025, when the EU Council approved the new Returns Regulation. It provides for the possibility of establishing return centers in non‑EU countries and transferring people who do not have the right to remain in the EU and are subject to an expulsion order, even if they have no connection to that third country or have never been there before.Under the rule, there must be a prior cooperation instrument with the receiving country, and that country must also respect international human rights standards and the principles of international law, including the principle of non‑refoulement — the prohibition on transferring a person to a territory where their life or freedom could be at risk.Governments supporting the initiative argue the centers will increase the effectiveness of returns and have a deterrent effect on irregular migration, as Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said on Monday: “I believe this is a game changer. We will regain control and remove the incentive for illegal migration,” she said while announcing the agreement in Vienna.Opponents of the measure question the agreement’s effectiveness and its consequences for the rights of those affected, and they ask whether relocating these migrants to a third country will actually overcome the obstacles that prevent their removal from Europe, whether this outsourcing mechanism will guarantee their fundamental rights, and how compliance will be monitored in the receiving country. UNHCR also agrees that such centers cannot be considered a solution on their own, as Paula Barrachina, the agency’s spokesperson in Spain, acknowledges. “They must not replace efforts aimed at achieving safe, dignified and affordable returns,” she warns in an interview.Judith Sunderland, associate director of the Europe and Central Asia division at Human Rights Watch (HRW), considers it premature to speak of concrete guarantees. “We do not know what they will be and we do not know how they are going to monitor the situation of people who might be deported,” she says by phone. According to this spokeswoman, Rwandan authorities denied entry to an HRW researcher in 2024, the fourth member of the organization to be refused access.Suitability of RwandaLocated in the heart of Africa, Rwanda has undergone a profound economic transformation since the 1994 genocide against the Tutsis and the end of the civil war. Its real GDP per capita has increased by 245% since 2000, according to the World Bank, and its economy grew by 9.4% in 2025, according to Rwanda’s National Institute of Statistics.However, with regard to respect for fundamental rights and civil liberties, it still has a long way to go, according to organizations such as Amnesty International. The government of Paul Kagame, president since 2000 and at the head of a government dominated by the Rwandan Patriotic Front since 1994, has been criticized for repressing political opposition and restricting freedom of expression. The report Freedom in the World 2026, produced by Freedom House, gives the country 21 out of 100 points and classifies it as “not free” after finding evidence of intimidation, arbitrary detentions, torture and disappearances or alleged killings of opponents.The United Nations also provides elements for assessing Rwanda’s suitability. In November 2025 the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights published a document noting persistent problems of prison overcrowding and limited access to health care and sanitation. Likewise, Rwanda’s National Commission for Human Rights reports that detention centers are over capacity: in its 2023‑2024 annual report it put occupancy at 134.3% of available capacity.Beyond Rwanda’s suitability, criticisms focus on the difficulty of guaranteeing and monitoring that the fundamental rights of foreigners deported there will be respected, and they also question whether, by delegating reception and control of these people to a third country, European governments may end up shirking their responsibilities. “What these centers do is move people outside European territorial jurisdiction and away from protection mechanisms,” Galán says.“What [the initiative] will do is make oversight and access to justice much more difficult,” she adds, and for that reason Sutherland calls for any agreement to clarify legal and judicial responsibilities and to guarantee those transferred mechanisms to report possible rights violations.Reservations also arise within the EU. The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) warned in February 2025 that return centers cannot become spaces detached from Europe’s legal obligations and, in a paper on such facilities, demanded that each transfer be supported by an individually appealable decision, that there be a legally binding agreement with the receiving country, that risks to fundamental rights be assessed in advance and that independent monitoring mechanisms be established.UNHCR, for its part, considers the centers could be a complementary tool to organize returns but recommends limiting them to cases in which the application for international protection has been definitively rejected after a fair procedure and the person has no other legal basis to remain in the EU. Paula Barrachina, the agency’s spokesperson in Spain, insists that the facilities be temporary and that no transfer take place if there is a risk of persecution or ill‑treatment. “People must not be detained or deprived of their liberty in these centers,” she stresses.Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition
The EU seeks a solution beyond its borders to the failure of its deportations
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at English →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.