AdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENTGuest EssayNov. 16, 2026, 5:01 a.m. ETCredit...Benny DouetJohn C. Coffee Jr.Mr. Coffee is a professor of law at Columbia University Law School and director of its Center on Corporate Governance.Major law firms in the United States seem to be enjoying a golden age. Partners’ individual compensation is well into the millions — star partners may make $20 to $30 million annually — and even first-year lawyers earn $250,000 at top New York City firms.Then, in October, the well-known firm of Weil, Gotshal & Manges announced that it would dissolve, an implosion that shocked the bar. Unlike other firms that have collapsed, Weil was large (about 1,200 lawyers), highly respected and scandal free. Yet its own leadership surrendered, and stopped trying to save this 95-year old firm. Why? Let’s begin with the fact that law firms are composed of often contentious persons (called lawyers) who are inclined to argue their positions aggressively. These disputes — typically about compensation or control issues — can produce rivalries and bitterness, but they have virtually never been the primary reason a major firm voluntarily dissolved itself.The Weil implosion highlights the new internal stresses destabilizing large law firms today, making them look more like collections of free agents — many of whom are waiting for a better offer to lure them away. Firms not only have to compete zealously at practicing law, but also at holding a highly mobile team together — much as if every player on the Dodgers or Yankees were a free agent who could leave tomorrow. Increasingly, compensation packages for partners reflect the principle of eat what you kill, and the once-respected ideals such as firm culture, the community of the partnership and a commitment to pro bono work and public service are recognized more in rhetoric then in practice. Particularly for young lawyers, the future looks foreboding as artificial intelligence reduces the need for humans in the handling of routine legal work.In the past, big law firms maintained stability by offering all partners with the same seniority equal compensation. It was inefficient but broadcast the message that the partnership was a band of equals, each committed to the firm’s advancement.Similarly, the best firms normally did not recruit partners from the outside, preferring to promote their own associates. Loyalty to the firm was the paramount value, on par with family loyalty.Until it wasn’t. The culture of big law began to change with the rise of corporate takeovers in the 1980s, which led to an exponential growth in the profitability of law firms that had expertise in mergers and acquisitions. Not only did new firms enter the game and increase competition, but as the names of the star partners became well known, job mobility quickly followed. For large firms, the logic of paying big money to acquire star lawyers was a no-brainer that mirrored the deals they were working on: It offered a high return on investment.Just as a free agent baseball slugger can become the subject of an auction, so too has the star partner become a very valuable acquisition target. The Dodgers won back-to-back World Series by hiring extraordinary and expensive free agent players.Correspondingly, major law firms greatly improved their position and profitability by raiding rival firms. In 2016, Paul, Weiss hired the star M&A specialist Scott Barshay from Cravath, Swaine & Moore. If Cravath, for a century the iconic model for the large law firm, could be raided, no firm was safe.Today, the firm leading the free agent pursuit is Kirkland & Ellis. So far this year it has reportedly added 119 new partners from outside the firm, but seen 224 depart. This is a head-spinning turnover rate that, as in baseball, means you can’t tell the partners without a scorecard.The analogy between baseball and law has its limits. If a firm experiences multiple departures, a panic can ensue. Weil, Gotshal may have been in just such an exposed position. When a team of six Weil partners departed for (ironically) Cravath in September, the race was on for the others to find new homes. As in a bank run, getting out first is the best strategy.In the world of law, the risks are far higher than in baseball. Dewey & LeBoeuf was a better known firm than Weil. In 2012, it filed for bankruptcy after more than half the firm’s partners resigned when they learned that their managing partners had borrowed some $245 million, in part to grant guaranteed multi-million-dollar contracts to lure or retain more than 100 free agents and existing partners.In the wake of the 2008 financial crisis, the firm was unable to honor these contracts. The Manhattan district attorney indicted three Dewey executives for defrauding their partners and lenders. Dewey’s demise signaled that even law firms like Weil can come apart at the seams under competitive pressure.While A.I. doesn’t seem to have played a role in the dissolution of Weil, Gotshal, it could force a major industry restructuring. A.I. may enable firms to reduce the number of young lawyers they hire, because A.I. can easily perform the more perfunctory legal tasks that are assigned to associates. The legal profession has long had a lengthy seven- or eight-year apprenticeship before deciding which associates make partner. As young lawyers become less valuable, the investment in such development programs may decline.Another loss hasn’t made headlines: the civic engagement that was part of the culture of many big firms. The big law partnership may be moving in the direction of a harsher, less equal environment in which less tolerance is shown for those who want to combine idealism and legal practice. That would be a societal loss, as there is a long history of constitutional law being shaped by lawyers in private practice motivated by idealism and a sense of justice.We are watching competition at work, and the legal industry can benefit from that, just as any other industry does. But it might be better served if firms do more conscious planning about firm culture. So go ahead and hire superstars at an inflated salary. Then assure other partners who are interested that they can do pro bono and test case work. Keep in mind that a number of partners have recently left Paul, Weiss and a common denominator in their departures appears to have been a sense that the firm’s culture had changed.There is no chance that law firms will go back to lock step compensation policy; they will continue to eat what they kill. The bidding for free agents will continue because it has increased profits at the firms that have used it most. With their leverage increased, the free agent partners may demand both greater compensation and a more dominant voice within their firms.Still, one factor may constrain these developments: Firms that persist in encouraging public service and civil liberties litigation may earn the reputational credit that attracts the best young lawyers to them. We must recognize that law firm partnerships are something like marriages: Each is a little different. Any attempt to make them all alike is ill-advised, but each partnership must plan its future carefully — or risk a Weil, Gotshal-like debacle.Related ContentAdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENT
The Eat-What-You-Kill System That Rules Big Law
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Nytimes →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.