The CowCarthy Affair and the Longest Outs of the Statcast Era

The CowCarthy Affair and the Longest Outs of the Statcast Era

Isaiah J. Downing-Imagn Images Last year, Major League Baseball started handing out something called the Premier Play of the Year. It’s an award for the best defensive play of the season, and instead of a trophy, you receive a framed picture of yourself making the play. It’s sponsored by a credit card company and given out at a banquet sponsored by a casino. Denzel Clarke won the inaugural award last year (which made it the premiere of the Premier Play of the Year) when he robbed this home run: It was a spectacular play. It deserved several awards. The 2026 Premier Play of the Year also went to a gravity-defying home run robbery. On August 31, with two outs in the bottom of the ninth, Colton Cowser robbed Jake McCarthy of a would-be game-winning homer. It was also a deserving play. Whoever has been tasked with assessing premiership is doing a bang-up job so far: I’ve actually been meaning to write about Cowser’s catch for awhile now, so I guess I may as well harness the corporate synergy between the credit card company, the casino, and us, the website for baseball nerds. We’re going to be so rich. We’re going to be the Verizon Chipotle Exxon of home run robberies. As such, on behalf of FanGraphs, please allow me to award Cowser a picture of himself receiving the framed picture of himself (in front of the same picture, with David Wright wandering offstage in the background). I sincerely hope he’ll consider framing it, and if he does, I further hope he’ll send us a picture of himself with it so that we can keep this ouroboros going: I was interested in Cowser’s catch for a few reasons. First, I wanted to mention that not enough people have been saying the phrase, “Wowser, Colton Cowser!” We should probably remedy that. Go ahead and say it to someone today at work: “Wowser, Colton Cowser!” You’ll make their day and your own (or you’ll thoroughly confuse them, which might be even more satisfying). Second, poor Jake McCarthy hit that ball a projected 423 feet. It would have been the eighth-longest ball of his entire career! The seven in front of it all went for home runs, as did seven of the eight after it; the eighth ended up as a triple. In fact, over the course of the Statcast era, over 94% of balls hit exactly 423 feet have ended up being home runs, while just 0.8% ended up being outs. Knowing all that, you may not be surprised to learn that when Cowser robbed McCarthy, he also put the Rockies outfielder in line for a less prestigious superlative: The Longest Out of the 2026 Season. Nobody gives you a framed picture for that, which is good, because McCarthy’s victory isn’t as open-and-shut as you might expect. The play that officially stands as the second-longest out of the season happened on May 2. Do you smell anything fishy about it? It’s not just the Ray tank: Heliot Ramos crushed this ball 107.9 mph. The umpires ended up initiating a review, because it sure looked like the ball was headed over the fence before its progress was suddenly slowed by one of the rings in the Tropicana Field ceiling, which would have made it an automatic home run. Center fielder Cedric Mullins was preparing to scale the wall, but slow motion replays clearly showed him exclaiming, “Oh sh*t,” before he ran back in to catch it at the front of the warning track. Ramos also seemed to have an opinion: To make the case air-tight, Statcast projected the distance at 422 feet, which meant the ball should have traveled well beyond the 404-foot wall. Unfortunately for Ramos, only one camera was trained on the ball, but it was so far away that the white sphere completely disappeared against the white background of the ceiling. The umpires had no choice but to let the play stand. Personally, I would argue that there is proof that the ball hit the catwalk, because I zoomed all the way in, and although the ball disappears for much of its flight time, you can still see it when it crosses in front of the brown top of the scoreboard, above the catwalk, and then again when it starts falling past the blue wall. If you look closely, you’ll see that its angle changes in between. At the top of the frame, it’s falling with a right-to-left angle. But by the time it reaches the bottom, it’s falling with a slight left-to-right angle, and it’s been pushed a little bit farther to the right. That probably still isn’t enough for the replay room to reverse the call, but it’s real: Ramos got robbed, and not just by Mullins. He got robbed by the umpires, by the replay room, by the available camera angles, and by the color white. What’s really weird is that the Rays broadcast announced Statcast’s projected distance right after the ball was hit. That instant readout projected the ball not at 422 feet, but at 424, longer than McCarthy’s ball! To be clear, it’s not at all unusual for Statcast numbers to shift slightly as the data gets refined, but for at least a few seconds, the computers thought this was the longest out of the year. What’s undoubtedly true is that, regardless of the projected distance of Ramos’ ball, McCarthy’s fly ball actually traveled farther than any other out this season. All this made me curious about where these long outs stacked up historically. Statcast has projected distances going back to 2015, and it turns out that the McCarthy-Cowser robbery (or, as we’ll be truncating it going forward, the CowCarthy Affair) sits just outside the top 10. It’s tied for 11th place with five other 423-foot outs. My big question was whether the top 10 would consist only of exciting home run robberies, or whether some would just be, you know, really deep outs. A ball that necessitates a robbery at one park might land on the warning track of another, and wouldn’t you know it, seven of the top 10 were hit to either the extremely deep outfield of Coors Field or the (formerly) extremely deep outfield of Comerica Park. Three balls are tied at 424. The first should help explain why I was wondering about the excitement levels of these plays. It may or may not be a home run robbery, but it’s not so much a Wowser, Colton Cowser! as it is a Wow! (Oh right, before you watch the video, I should probably explain that we’re going to be grading the top 10 using the Wowser, Colton Cowser! scale. The better the play, the longer the exclamation. So a play as great as the CowCarthy Affair will earn a full, 18-letter Wowser, Colton Cowser! But a play like the one below will earn merely three letters: Wow!): That’s Jake Cave in 2020, not quite robbing Cameron Maybin of a home run, at least according to Statcast, which said the ball would have been gone in all 29 other parks except Comerica. The two other 424-foot outs are even less exciting. Nick Senzel earns a Wo! for catching a Trevor Story fly ball that would’ve gone out of every park except Coors and Comerica in 2019. He gets two letters because he had to leave his feet and hit the wall. Mikie Mahtook also earns a Wo! for catching this Alex Gordon blast, also a homer in 28 parks, in 2017: I know you’re probably shouting at your computer right now that there’s no way that the ball Gordon hit deserved even two letters when it resulted in such an easy, flat-footed catch on the warning track. You’re not wrong, but you’re forgetting to give the play a bonus letter because it featured some of the best names in baseball. Not only did it feature Mikie Mahtook, whose name sounds like it belongs to the drummer in a band fronted by the Geico caveman, but the pitcher was Warwick Saupold, whose name sounds like it belongs both to a horrible wasting disease and to the Victorian-era doctor who discovered said disease, tried to treat it with leeches, and eventually died of it himself. The Statcast era has only seen one 425-foot out, and it was truly a great play. In 2019, Lewis Brinson hit what should have been a classic Coors Field home run. It wasn’t even hit 100 mph, but it sliced through the thin air and appeared destined to lodge itself in the white fir just beyond the fence. Then Raimel Tapia cut it down (the fly ball, not the fir): Between the leap, the crash into the wall, the hat flying off, and the way he ended up seated on the warning track, that play easily earned Tapia a Wowser, Colton! But the 426-foot outs are truly impressive. First, Mikie Mahtook is back, and this time he doesn’t need any bonuses. This isn’t a home run robbery, but it’s still a full-speed, leaping, over-the-shoulder grab that ends with Mahtook crashing into the wall hard enough to bounce off it into a reverse somersault. It’s a Wowser, Colton Cows! This play took place in 2017, a year in which Defensive Runs Saved would say Mahtook cost the Tigers 18 runs on defense. He posted -18 DRS, which made him the fifth-worst defender in baseball! Somehow, Mahtook ended his career with negative defensive numbers according to all three of the advanced defensive metrics even though he was capable of making plays like that one. Depending on your perspective, the next 426-foot out may be even more impressive, as it involved Sam Fuld scaling Tal’s Hill in Houston before catching the ball and falling into the wall. This play took place in 2015, the year before the hill was removed: It’s hard to blame the announcer for momentarily renaming it “Sam’s Hill” after that grab. I’m sure that some will argue that climbing up that hill makes the catch even more impressive than Mahtook’s, but I’m going to give it a Wowser, Colton Cow!, just one letter short. I’m going to give the same score to JaCoby Jones for this 2019 grab: This is a spectacular play by any metric, but what really puts it over the top is the way that Jones crashes into the wall. As you may know, I have a professional interest in wall smushes, plays where the outfielder smushes themselves deep into the wall while trying to make a catch. This description is from the first (hopefully of many) rundown last year: “The primary criterion is simple: How smushed into the wall do you get?… That’s what matters. We want you to be so flat against the wall and so deep into the padding that if somebody came over and applied a quick coat of green paint, you’d disappear entirely.” Knowing all that, look at Jones here and note that he gets bonus points for leaving a big indentation in the wall at roughly face height: The last 426-foot out was caught by Cameron Maybin, who you might recall would go on to have his own 424-foot fly ball caught in 2020 in a bit of cosmic justice. This was an excellent catch by Maybin, but it only earned a Wowser! The main reason this play didn’t garner more letters is that Maybin wasn’t even the most impressive part of it. Not to take anything away from the catch, but watch Giancarlo Stanton go down and get this ball. That’s a 3-2 pitch on the outer third at the very bottom of the strike zone. He has to bend way over to get it, and in so doing, give up a whole bunch of bat speed. His weight is already way out over his front foot. His legs and his torso aren’t in sync at all. This is not what normal human beings look like when they’re about to hit a ball 426 feet: Somehow, Stanton did just that, requiring a snow cone from Maybin just to haul it in. Stanton is one strong man. In case you’re keeping score, that leaves us with just two more plays, and they’re both bangers, but in very different ways. The first is this 427-foot blast off the bat of Kyle Seager in 2021. Derek Hill bangs in to the wall awfully hard to haul it in, and I’m going to award this yet another Wowser, Colton Cows! Hill truly sacrificed his body for this ball. The trick to avoiding injury when you’re making a leaping catch is to hit the wall at the peak of your jump or when you’re on your way down; at that point your momentum has slowed considerably. Hill didn’t have that luxury. He had to get there fast, so he hit the wall on his way up and paid the price, smashing his head and shoulder right into the wall. It was a real Spider-Man move, and one lucky, masked reliever out in the bullpen got to admire it right up close: I promised you that the last two catches were bangers, but as we turn to the longest catch of the entire Statcast era, a ball projected at 428 feet, I have to admit that I lied. It’s less of a bang and more of a thud. Chris Davis ripped an Ian Krol slider 428 feet with an exit velocity of 106.7 mph, and it is, by a mile, the most boring play of the lot: Over the course of the Statcast era, we’ve seen 508 balls hit 428 feet, and 498 of them have gone for home runs. That’s 98%. Nine of them went for doubles or triples. Let me save you some time so you don’t have to do the math in your head. Davis’ ball was the only 428-foot out in baseball over the past 12 seasons. And not only was it an out, it was a boring out. Anthony Gose caught it easily and tossed it back into the infield with a heaping helping of nonchalance. It’s possible that Statcast was mistaken here. You can see in the video that the wall behind Gose says 420, so maybe this was just a slight miscalculation. But it’s in the books at 428, so I hereby award the longest out of the Statcast era a V!, by which I mean I award it half a W!

Original Source

Read the full article at Blogs →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.