The Clearest Indicator for Who Will Win the Democratic Leadership Showdown

The Clearest Indicator for Who Will Win the Democratic Leadership Showdown

The Surge is your weekly political sanity check: what matters, what might, and what’s just political theater. Sign up here to get it in your inbox. Welcome to this week’s edition of the Surge, Slate’s weekly politics newsletter. You want to know how granularly realistic Grand Theft Auto VI is?? All of the nonplayable characters read the Surge on their phones on Saturday morning. This week, there was more than one “dirty bomb” that didn’t go off in Washington, as the rebellion against Hakeem Jeffries fell flat. We consider J.D. Vance’s future, and whether he’ll forgo a presidential bid to spend more time with his posts—we mean, kids. Plus: Cindy Hyde-Smith makes jokes? Before we jump in, a public service announcement: There will be no Surge next week due to the Thanksgiving holiday. (For some holiday hosting tips, here is Slate guest advice columnist Michelle Obama.) Onward, to the latest Democratic infighting! What matters now: There is now a shutdown debate in the middle of Senate Democrats’ leadership fight. Amid a rare contest to determine who their leader will be in the next Congress, Senate Democrats met privately on Tuesday to discuss the biggest tactical decision they’ll have to make before the holidays. There’s a government funding deadline on Dec. 11, and the question before Democrats is whether they should filibuster any funding bill unless it cuts off funds for the Iran war. The push to use this moment to block war funding is being led primarily by four Democratic senators: Michael Bennet, Tammy Duckworth, Chris Van Hollen, and Bernie Sanders. Bennet wrote a letter to his colleagues shortly after the election, on Nov. 7, encouraging them to “refuse to invoke cloture on any package that includes another cent for his war”; he released the text of his proposed bill this week. Van Hollen has been pushing the argument as a difference between himself and Chuck Schumer, whom Van Hollen is challenging to be the next Senate majority leader. “This should not be a finger-in-the-wind issue,” Van Hollen told MS NOW’s Jen Psaki last week. “This should not be sort of frittering around. This should not be a question of timidity. We need to answer the call of the American people, end the war, bring down prices, do it now, not a penny, not a penny to fuel this war.” Schumer, meanwhile, has said that he does want to use the “power of the purse” to “end the war”—he just hasn’t committed to forcing the issue in December. The sequence of events here is key, and a good example of why Schumer—as publicly unpopular as he is—remains the overwhelming favorite in the face-off with Van Hollen. It’s much more than Senate Democrats feeling like Schumer deserves another two years after picking up nine Senate seats in the midterms (though, sure), or fearing repercussions if they vote against him (also sure). It’s about how each would approach the job. Van Hollen pushed his tactical argument before Senate Democrats met privately to discuss how they wanted to proceed. And they were meeting because they hadn’t reached consensus on a path forward (they still haven’t). There are an awful lot of Democratic senators (and House Democrats) who feel that going to the mat right now and sending the government into shutdown ahead of the holidays—especially at a moment when air traffic systems are breaking down every two seconds—would be a bad idea. That it would be better, instead, to fund the government for a few months, allow incoming Democratic majorities to pass their first showcase bills, and then have this fight over Iran funding with Donald Trump when their numbers are much greater. Or to reach an interim deal with Republicans in December to put some restrictions on war spending in exchange for funding other defense priorities, like replacing munitions. A lot of Senate Democrats—who are the electorate in this race—want a leader who will gather them all to hash it out before landing on a plan. They don’t want someone who launches a strategy in public before sounding out the caucus. And if the consensus strategy among senators is one they believe to be sound, but which might strike the progressive base as weak, they want a leader who is willing to take the heat for it. So far, we haven’t seen a lot of evidence either that the government will shut down in December or that Van Hollen’s bid for majority leader is more than a protest vote. What we’re keeping an eye on: Is J.D. Vance going to do this, or what? Perhaps you’ll remember when, mere seconds after the final ballot was cast in the midterms, Vice President J.D. Vance rushed to put some distance between himself and his boss over the Iran war. “The reason we lost is the war,” Vance posted. Trump’s first response when asked about this was to say Vance’s assessment was “largely true.” But as he thought about it a bit more, and as it fully sank in that his subordinate was trying to run away from him, Trump has reportedly gotten extremely pissed at Vance. Per the New York Times this week, Trump has been “complaining to aides and allies that Mr. Vance should have made a point of saying the president made the right decision in going to war with Iran.” The president has been much nicer, publicly, to Secretary of State Marco Rubio of late while pulling Vance from certain duties. All of this has created uncertainty about whether Vance—the heir apparent to Trump for the past two years—will follow through with a presidential run. We can see the issue: He’d be running in a political environment requiring him to separate himself from the president, while working for a president who would not allow such separation. Also, the coalition that Trump and Vance won with two years ago was smashed to bits in the midterms. He has four young kids. Were Republicans in a strong position to win the presidency in 2028, well, maybe the whole “wanting to be a good parent” thing could be put on the back burner. Child rearing might matter a whole lot more if the Republican nominee in 2028 looks like he’ll be a sacrificial lamb. For all the focus on Democrats over the past two years as the party in the wilderness that needs to figure out what it stands for, it’s important to recognize how quickly Republicans are catching up in lostness. The Trump era is ending, and Trump has spent the kids’ inheritance. Were Vance to run, he’d try to restore a purer form of the isolationist, right-wing populism behind MAGA. Meanwhile, Ted Cruz would try to restore pre-Trump conservative principles. Ron DeSantis would run on competence in the service of realizing online-brained right-wing goals. Marco Rubio would stick his finger in the wind and work accordingly. How it sorts out is anyone’s guess. Vance said this week that he will “figure it out sometime next year.” As will we all. What you can safely ignore for the next two years: Any further House hostage-taking efforts from the new democratic socialists. Hakeem Jeffries had to work hard during his Tuesday press conference to suppress his own laughter. The first question he got was about the “resistance” he was facing from “progressives” ahead of a scheduled Democratic caucus vote to nominate a speaker candidate. “You’ll have to ask those individuals that you believe are resistant to voting for me in caucus tomorrow,” he said. He added that he took nothing for granted, and that he would have meetings the rest of the afternoon with various caucuses ahead of the vote. What was so funny? There had been stories leading up to the vote about how Democratic members’ offices were being bombarded with phone calls demanding that they vote against Jeffries. Some on the left pushed for a veteran leftist, Massachusetts Rep. Ayanna Pressley, to challenge him. There were online petitions. Online petitions! This was never going to happen. To show how weak the opposition ultimately was, Jeffries himself called for a recorded vote—and oh, how weak the opposition was. Jeffries won by a vote of 251 to 11. The bulk of those 11 votes opposing Jeffries were incoming leftists aligned with the DSA, and they said in a statement that they voted no as their efforts to secure commitments from Jeffries were “ongoing.” Who wants to tell them that those efforts are not, in fact, ongoing? Check the scoreboard. Jeffries already has 33 more votes than he will need to be elected speaker on the House floor on Jan. 3. We’re done here. These members could have truly made life hell for Jeffries (and the rest of their Democratic colleagues) had Democrats won only a narrow majority. Unfortunately for them, Democrats had a historically successful election. For the left to make demands on Jeffries now, it’s going to require the bulk of the Progressive Caucus to be willing to hold the line on a demand, and that means the demand itself will have to be watered down. This inability to easily secure hostages to push policies against the broad will of the caucus—the bane of Speaker Mike Johnson’s narrow majorities—will make the most fervent members of both the left and the Blue Dogs irrelevant. That’s great news for everyone else. Pick another protein? We’d rather pick another risible quote … ● Eh, governance is for the birds. Let’s look ahead at the 2028 Senate map. The most obvious target for Democrats made the following observation this week: “At this point, there’s really no way to fix Social Security. It’s a Ponzi scheme. You can’t fix it, you just shut it down and hope that you can recover some of your money.” Remember those words from Wisconsin Sen. Ron Johnson—or don’t, because you’ll be reminded of them when the attack ad of him saying them is running wall-to-wall for the entirety of October 2028. ● Elon Musk has spent the GDP of a small nation in the past two cycles funding Donald Trump and MAGA Republicans’ elections (to mixed success). But now that Democrats will be in charge in Washington and his adopted state of Texas, he had this to say in an interview on Thursday: “I mean, I’m not MAGA. I’m not sure what MAGA means, but I, I don’t think I’m, like, if, if that means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don’t have that. I think there are, there, there are positives and negatives in both parties.” Aww. You’re getting subpoenaed, bud. ● If a confirmation hearing for the secretary of the navy is generating big headlines, the secretary of the navy nominee might be in a spot of bother. In his hearing for the permanent position this week, acting Secretary Hung Cao—a former naval officer who has lost both a House and a Senate race in Virginia this decade—had this to say when asked about the eight suicide attempts aboard the U.S.S. Abraham Lincoln during its long deployment: “You see it as eight suicide attempts, I see it as eight suicide mitigations.” When asked about how one parent said their son lost 45 pounds in six months due to a lack of food aboard the ship, Cao said some sailors are just picky eaters, “like my kids opening up the refrigerator door and saying there’s nothing to eat in here.” Sailors, in short, are doing just fine. They’re fine. Everything’s fine. They just need to stock more Bagel Bites. ● So: Mississippi Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith. She goes 8½ years in the Senate not saying a single word to any reporter in the Capitol, leading everyone to think she’s no fun. She loses reelection. Then, a few days later, when asked by a reporter what Senate Republicans would be eating at their Tuesday luncheon, she responds, “I have no idea. Probably Sean Duffy.” Sheeee-it. Has she been a secret Southern wit this whole time? Just a few lines like this over the course of her Senate tenure could have made up her margin of defeat. Chuck Schumer Democrats Donald Trump Republicans The Surge 2026 Midterms

Original Source

Read the full article at Slate →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.