The Childcare Pied-à-Terre Some families are finding that renting or even buying an apartment for the grandparents is still cheaper than daycare. Photo-Illustration: Curbed; Photos: Getty Photo-Illustration: Curbed; Photos: Getty Less than a year after their first daughter, Margot, was born in 2021, Sam Fetters and his wife crunched the numbers and came to the realization that childcare was going to cost them a “second rent.” The couple, both of whom work in the city’s public-school system, had researched the local options before eventually putting down a one-month deposit of $2,200 — significantly more than what they paid each month on their rent-stabilized one-bedroom in Ditmas Park — to secure a spot at a nearby daycare. When Sam told his parents in Cincinnati, Rob and Susan, what their plan would cost, his father proposed that his son just pay an actual second rent instead. “My dad, who’s always trying to spend more time here, said, ‘What if you rented us an apartment instead,’” Fetters recalls, “‘and we stayed and watched Margot full-time?’” We think of housing as everyone’s single most punishing expense in New York City, and it usually is. For some families, though, it’s come to this: Childcare is now so costly that a rental pied-à-terre for grandparents is a cheaper option (and easier to live with than squeezing them into your apartment’s office nook). In 2024, families paid as much as $26,000 per year to send their kids to daycare, with annual childcare costs across the board having jumped at least $4,000 since 2019, according to a comptroller’s report. (Those figures are for the basics; families with full-time nannies in Brooklyn Heights and on the Upper East Side tell me they’re paying double or nearly triple that much.) Not only is it eye-wateringly expensive, but also there’s the mental and emotional calculus of leaving your child’s well-being in the care of strangers. Your own mom and dad at the helm might look a lot more appealing. If the grandparents are affluent, they may consider buying an apartment here. But for those who aren’t quite in that financial tier, like Rob and Susan Fetters, a trade is a more manageable option for everyone: The new parents cover their own parents’ city rent; the grandparents handle the diapers and Goldfish crackers for a few years. Fetters and his wife, Sarah, were unsurprisingly pretty receptive to his dad’s proposal and started scouring listings and Park Slope Parents for a deal. They landed on a $2,000-a-month one-bedroom in prime Prospect Heights. “We wanted somewhere clean and nice and safe and quiet,” Fetters says. It was in a three-floor walk-up on St. Marks Avenue, close enough that Rob and Susan could hop on the Q train and be in Ditmas for a morning handoff in 30 minutes, but also near Vanderbilt Avenue’s restaurant row and the Brooklyn Museum for when they were off the clock. The grandnannies divided toddler duty into solo morning and afternoon shifts, since the combination of spending all day together on childcare duties and then coming home to a tiny one-bedroom was a “pressure cooker” for the older couple, who were used to living in a full-size Victorian house. “We were on top of each other, and we had to work that out,” Rob tells me. On weekdays, they played with Margot at her home, took her on trips to Prospect Park and the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and changed many, many diapers. “We had twins at one point, so I know what it’s like to have poop on elbows,” Rob says. “My main thing was, ‘I want to be around this baby girl.’” At their son’s apartment, they also cooked and tidied the daily mess wrought by a toddler. On Friday nights, all three generations gathered for seafood and upside-down pizzas from Lo Duca; weekends meant trips to Brighton Beach in the warmer months or down to Chinatown for Sunday dim sum. “I never really thought I was going to be so intertwined with my parents as an adult, especially living 600 miles from them,” Fetters says. “It was an adjustment, but also realizing that I think the grandparents probably are providing the best care for a 1-year-old.” Susan and Rob Fetters taking their granddaughter Margot for a walk. Photo: Courtesy of the subjects A similar arrangement worked out for Anne McPherson, who was preparing to return to her communications job in March after giving birth to her son. She and her husband set up her mother-in-law, Sheila, in a roughly $3,250-a-month studio in downtown Brooklyn. “She’s from a really rural part of Jamaica, so there were some considerations,” McPherson says, like a doorman and in-building amenities to ease her transition to urban life. Sheila also had to get comfortable riding the F train two stops to pick up her grandson, Langston, and McPherson had to show her which coffee shops were amenable to bathroom visits whenever the two went out. Things were pretty seamless after that, though: Sheila and Langston were off on their own adventures, attending music classes or hanging out in Carroll Park with other babies and nannies after his morning naps. Logistically, things were easier, too, if McPherson and her husband were running late from work or wanted to grab dinner with a friend. “We went away one night and she stayed at our place with him, and so all of that just made it so easy,” she says. Six months later, Sheila, who missed her husband and friends in Jamaica, is back home, and Langston is in daycare with a bit more structure and socializing. The vibe has changed, and not only because there’s an inflexible pick-up time. “In daycare, you get photos every half hour, which is cute, but it’s so different,” she says. “I never heard from Sheila, nor did I check in. There’s a trust there.” Sheila, left, with her son, Milton Speid; grandson, Langston; and daughter-in-law, Anne McPherson. Photo: Courtesy of the subjects The convenience of having a local grandparent provide childcare can also speed up other life-changing decisions. One 39-year-old who works in tech marketing says she and her husband started trying to have their second child earlier than they’d anticipated because her newly retired mother-in-law moved to the city temporarily in 2021. “I didn’t need to worry about my son at all, because I totally trusted her judgment,” the tech marketer says. Still, she adds, “I knew that she wasn’t going to be willing to do this for us forever.” Her intuition was right: After three years, her mother-in-law announced it was time for her to head back home to Columbus, Ohio. Caring for two kids was physically taxing for the septuagenarian, and when the older child moved to a twos program, he kept bringing home germs and getting his grandmother sick. “It was really clear it was too much,” the mother says. But while it lasted, the finances had worked out splendidly, because Grandma had somehow found herself a rent-stabilized one-bedroom near Gowanus. The couple ended up paying $2,600 a month plus $300 for parking, or roughly a third of what their full-time nanny costs them now. “I still don’t understand how she found it,” the mother of two says. For some families, this childcare setup even becomes permanent. “We had two pitches,” one mother, who works as a marketing professional, says about discussing what to do with her mother. “‘Do you see yourself coming up to start,’ and then two years later, ‘do you see yourself staying?’” In almost a decade since her mother moved up to New York from suburban Philadelphia, she’s gone from helping to look after one kid to tending to three. The entire family’s housing setup has changed, too: At first they were in two units in the same Midtown building, with the family in a one-bedroom they owned and the grandmother in a $2,300-a-month rental seven floors away; a few years later, the parents and children moved 20 blocks north to a three-bedroom they purchased on the Upper East Side, while the grandmother moved into their one-bedroom that today costs about $3800 for the mortgage and utilities. “It’s still more economical to have two mortgages than childcare for three kids,” the marketing professional claims. The grandmother comes over every day to watch the kids after school, and on Tuesdays and Saturdays, they go over to her house, where they get to play video games and have unlimited access to lollipops. That said, the grandmother has been at this long enough that she dictates her own schedule. “She refuses to wake up before 12 p.m. On the weekend, she’s like, ‘Do not call me; I don’t exist to you,’” the mother says. “The power dynamic is totally on her side, because she’s made this work.” That might be because the grandmother’s been covering a lot of other domestic roles lately: remembering whether her grandchildren’s first-grade friends like Legos and buying the birthday gifts, texting her daughter reminders that she has to leave work early to take her middle child to soccer practice. “That shit saves you from having a mental breakdown, from having a midlife crisis,” the mother says. Anne McPherson and her husband rented an apartment in downtown Brooklyn for her mother-in-law, Sheila (pictured, with grandson Langston), in exchange for full-time childcare. Photo: Courtesy of the subjects The perks of having a grandnanny like Sheila nearby included easier logistics when McPherson or her husband was running late for pickup. Photo: Courtesy of the subjects There are challenges, of course. If a staffer at daycare gets sick, there are backup providers, but “I can’t force my sick mom to come take care of my child,” Fetters says. Others pointed out that grandparents, unsurprisingly, have a tendency to go easier on the kids than a parent or even a professional provider might. One Brooklyn Heights lawyer renting a $4,000 studio for her mother across the street got a text that she had let her grandson go to bed without brushing his teeth. “We’re like, ‘What do you mean he didn’t feel like it?’” the lawyer recalls. “He doesn’t need to feel like it. This is a rule.” On the other hand, there’s the delicate dance of not treating a grandparent too much like the help, as the Upper East Side mom has learned. “It’ll be like their third ice cream of the night, and I’ll be like, ‘Mom, you can’t do this,’ and she’s like, ‘I’m not a nanny. I’m a grandmother.’” Even if it all goes as perfectly as it can, nothing works forever — in this case, for an extremely familiar reason. The Fetterses had a second daughter almost a year ago, and Sam says the math simply doesn’t work out for a repeat tour. Childcare costs have gone up, sure, but rent has outpaced them. That $2,000 one-bedroom has gone up to $2,600. His parents are four years older, too, and two kids are harder than one. “It didn’t make sense for us in the same way,” Fetters says. Of course, that isn’t deterring Rob and Susan from seeing the grandkids pretty regularly — for free. “My parents come probably every other month,” he says. “They’ll spend a week with us, and really lean in and help.” The Childcare Pied-à-Terre Your product is saved! You’ll receive emails when your saved products go on sale. Manage preferences.
The Childcare Pied-à-Terre
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Curbed →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.