The Chancellor has just been given a huge Neets headache

The Chancellor has just been given a huge Neets headache

Alan Milburn has handed the Chancellor John Healey a big problem on a slow fuse. In his 267-page review, with around 100,000 words on how to deal with the crisis of Britain’s Neets – young people not in employment, education or training, Milburn suggested a reduction in the tax employers pay on young workers’ wage through National Insurance contributions (NIC). However the changes would be phased in over five years “when economic conditions allow”. It is both a bold and timid suggestion. Bold because it gets to the heart of one of the biggest, and perhaps effective, criticisms against the Labour government – that the NICs rise Rachel Reeves landed on employers in 2025 to raise £40bn has made employing people more expensive. Timid because it offers no concrete timescale to carry out the measure. This has led to some speculation that Milburn may have wanted to go harder, but was urged to soften his language instead after discussions with the Government, which it was reported wanted to adopt all his recommendations. This was not denied by Downing Street when it was put to them by The i Paper. Asked whether Milburn had discussed his NICs proposals with the Government before publishing his report – and whether he had originally pushed for more immediate cuts only to be told they were unaffordable – the Prime Minister’s spokesman confirmed there had been discussions with government departments “as a matter of routine”. But he declined to give details of those discussions. The central risk for Neets planEither way, as the Institute for Fiscal Studies has warned, the Chancellor will face difficult choices at the Spending Review, with the reforms competing against other demands on public services. The IFS says the package will be challenging to deliver and that the projected employment gains are far from guaranteed. The central risk for ministers is that they commit billions to the new system but fail to deliver the extra jobs – and therefore the welfare savings – on which its long-term financial case depends. Alan Milburn launching his final report into young people not in employment, education or training (Neets) (Photo: Stefan Rousseau/Press Association) Milburn has recommended that the threshold for when employers start paying NIC for workers aged 21 to 24 should be doubled from £5,000 to £10,000 over five years, in a bid to make it cheaper for businesses to hire young people. The change would initially apply to the retail and hospitality sectors, which together account for 37 per cent of jobs held by 16 to 24-year-olds. Milburn says the increases should be phased in when the public finances allow, with the pace reviewed at each fiscal event. The proposal comes amid growing pressure from businesses for relief from the employer NICs burden. Craig Beaumont, of the Federation of Small Businesses, said firms would be looking at the range of commitments in Milburn’s review, including “easing the chilling burden of National Insurance hikes”, as well as new incentives for small businesses and greater recognition of entrepreneurship as a route for young people. Why businesses ‘may pull out’ But a Government insider warned that businesses could be reluctant to back the wider package if the NICs cuts were not introduced immediately, telling The i Paper: “NICs are going to be the thing that business pulls out of it.” Downing Street, meanwhile, argued that untargeted cuts would not solve the problem. Milburn has described immediate, across-the-board NICs cuts as “not a silver bullet” for the NEET crisis, arguing instead for targeted relief and a gradual reduction in the tax burden. He argues that an immediate extension of the existing employer NICs exemption for under-21s to also include under 25s would be too expensive. The report cites Resolution Foundation estimates that such a move would cost £5.1bn and create around 38,000 additional jobs. Instead, he proposes a more gradual approach, which he says would help businesses employing young people, particularly those on lower wages or working fewer hours. Once the threshold reached £10,000, a 21-year-old working 15 hours a week at current minimum wage rates could be employed without their employer paying NICs, according to the report. The recommendations come as business leaders call for the Government to reduce the cost of hiring young people. Matthew Percival, the Confederation of British Industry’s director of future of work and skills, told The i Paper: “Businesses want to create more jobs for young people. It is an economic priority as well as a social one. But rising costs are squeezing employers’ capacity to invest, recruit and create opportunities.” He described restoring the NICs threshold for under-25s as “a welcome first step towards making it affordable to hire again”. But Percival warned that wider cost pressures were preventing businesses from offering work for younger people. Britain’s Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden makes a ministerial statement on the Milburn Review (Photo: House of Commons/AFP via Getty) The CBI’s Employment Trends Survey, published earlier this autumn, found that 53 per cent of businesses said wider cost pressures meant they were offering fewer apprenticeships than they would like to. “Most businesses want to offer more apprenticeships than they do today,” Percival added. “But constant changes to the rules undermine confidence and make it harder for employers to commit to the long-term investment needed to create more opportunities.” Warning signs over Labour MP revolt Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said it would be for the Chancellor to consider Milburn’s recommendations relating to NICs. The Prime Minister’s spokesman also pointed out that employers already pay no NICs on earnings up to £50,270 for workers under 21 and eligible apprentices under 25. The Government was continuing to work with businesses to reduce costs and make hiring easier, they added. Welfare reform remains a major political test for the Government, after the row over benefit cuts became a key issue that helped bring down Sir Keir Starmer. The response to Milburn’s proposals will test whether ministers can pursue a radical overhaul without provoking another revolt among Labour MPs. Warning signs were already visible in the Commons today, where MPs who opposed last year’s welfare changes raised questions about the impact on disabled young people. Labour MP Richard Burgon warned that removing PIP and the Universal Credit health element risked pushing sick and disabled claimants into poverty, while his colleague Rachel Maskell questioned whether employers would accommodate young people with mental health conditions. Marie Tidball welcomed the shift away from “crude cuts to benefits”, but pressed ministers on how they would close the disability employment gap. The interventions underline the scale of the political challenge facing ministers. They must convince Labour MPs that the reforms will protect disabled young people and those unable to work, while persuading the public and businesses that a costly programme, which will take years to roll out, can deliver enough people into jobs to make a meaningful difference to the spiralling welfare bill.

Original Source

Read the full article at Inews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.