The Brexit gang is back – and they’ve brought their back-of-a-fag-packet maths too

The Brexit gang is back – and they’ve brought their back-of-a-fag-packet maths too

The real meaning of a lie is the truth it tries to hide. It’s therefore completely beside the point to demonstrate that the figures put out by Brexit supporters this week are absolute tosh. What really matters is the truth they are trying to suppress. And that truth is quite simple. It is that Brexit is a disaster, that all of their promises have turned to ash, and that they will invent anything in order to conceal their own ineptitude and irresponsibility. We know the list of characters well: Michael Gove, Nigel Farage, Boris Johnson and all the rest. The old gang came crawling out of their hole, demanding that no-one even thinks of repairing the damage they’ve caused. Over the last couple of weeks, the old Brexit organisations have begun to re-form. Vote Leave has rebranded as Stay Out, with Gove as the de-facto front man. Farage’s old outfit, Leave.EU, has rebranded as the laughably named Enough. Notice how tired they sound. “Enough” is just a Daily Express headline in organisational form and will appeal only to its dwindling alienated elderly demographic. Stay Out has none of the sense of potential or possibility of the old Brexit campaign in 2016. It is a tired, lamentful appeal for a ruined status quo. The moment the Brexit campaign started up again, the second they came back online, the lies returned. It’s as if no time had passed. As if we were all right back there, 10 years younger, and no wiser than we were before.Back in 2016, Vote Leave told us that we send the EU £350m a week. That was what Britain would have paid for EU membership, without our rebate and without accounting for the EU funds which were directed to the UK. To call it a back-of-a-fag packet calculation is to do a disservice to fag packets everywhere. Now they’re at it again. This week, Stay Out insisted that rejoining the EU would cost £750m a week. They reached this figure by taking the European Commission’s proposed long-term EU budget of £1.66trn between 2028-34, increasing it due to presumed British participation, and then assessing a British contribution on the basis of its relative economic size. The only vaguely justifiable element of this calculation is the exclusion of the UK’s old rebate. It is genuinely unlikely we would get this back, and old EU figures like Michel Barnier have been keen to stress that no UK government should expect it. The overall budget figure has been maximised to within an inch of its life. It assumes the highest possible proposed level, despite a live debate in the EU for how to bring it down, and even that Britain would end up paying for pandemic recovery loans which took place when it was no longer a member. But the main trick they’ve pulled is the same one they used in 2016: excluding all the money we’d get back. The group has excluded EU funds to the UK. More importantly, they’ve left out the trade benefits we would get from membership. What is the value of this trade? How much is that worth per week? This is where serious people come into play. They are not writing on the back of a fag packet. They are holding themselves to high standards and subjecting their work to rigorous assessment by their peers. John Springford, for instance, is one of the leading economists assessing the impact of Brexit. His work compared the UK to a “doppelganger,” composed of economies that performed similarly to ours between 2009 and 2016. By the time we got halfway through 2022, he estimated that Brexit had reduced Britain’s GDP by 5.5 per cent. After that he retired the model – the energy shock from Covid and Ukraine meant that he simply couldn’t rely on the figures. It’s the kind of thing responsible economists do and which would obviously never occur to Stay Out. The National Bureau of Economic Research tried to find a way around the energy shock problem by using micro data on UK businesses. It estimated that by the end of 2025 Brexit had reduced UK GDP by between six and eight per cent as a result of “elevated uncertainty, reduced demand, diverted management time, and increased misallocation of resources”. Other studies have restricted themselves to assessing variations in UK trade. This summer, Springford and fellow economist Anton Spisak found a decline in trade across most goods and services. In terms of goods, chemicals and pharmaceuticals were particularly affected. In terms of services, they found that travel, transport and financial services were particularly badly damaged. Brexit reduced total UK exports to the EU by about 12 per cent and total imports from the EU by about 16 per cent. So how much money do we lose overall from not being in the EU? Springford estimates that the cost to the UK economy from Brexit is now between £3bn and £3.5bn a week in lost national income. Even if Stay Out’s grossly inflated figure of £750m a week was true, it would be completely overshadowed by the cost of remaining outside the EU. Stay Out is a proper amateur hour. But compared to Farage, it looks like the Platonic form of rigorous academic study. The Reform leader dashed straight to Brussels today, desperate to try and secure some attention. His chief claim is that every household would have to pay an extra £2,000 a year if we rejoin the EU. Where does this figure come from? No-one knows. What does it relate to? It’s not clear. How did he arrive at it? Impossible to tell. At this point, Farage doesn’t even bother to pretend that he’s doing genuine research, he appears to just magic numbers out of the air. It’s the economic equivalent of Sesame Street. It’s telling to see the gulf in quality between the pro-Brexit analysis and the empirical assessments put out by serious economists. That raises a question, one which should hang over this entire debate: if Brexit is such a good idea, why would you have to lie? Why would you ignore the rebate? Why would you fail to include the EU payments to the UK? Why would you pretend that there are no trading benefits? Why would you have to resort to the worst kind of Mickey Mouse mathematics to make your case? The reason is simple. It is because Brexit is a terrible idea. It was in 2016 and it remains so today.

Original Source

Read the full article at Inews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.