The AI boom hits its ‘final stages’ as Anthropic goes public and the jobless-growth economy delivers neither jobs nor growth

The AI boom hits its ‘final stages’ as Anthropic goes public and the jobless-growth economy delivers neither jobs nor growth

The AI stock boom is “in its final stages,” Capital Economics wrote on Monday, and what does the U.S. economy really have to show for it? Anthropic is going public, anyway, on Thursday, in a deal estimated to raise about $64.35 billion at the top of its range. That’s nearly twice what every U.S. IPO raised together last quarter, per Renaissance Capital. If Capital Economics is right, the timing is bad for more than Anthropic’s bankers. The AI boom has been carrying the growth half of what Goldman Sachs economists called “jobless growth.” The economy grew at a 3.4% annual rate in the third quarter while employers added an average of 48,000 jobs a month over the 12 months through September—before a massive 165,000 gain in October. AI spending drove more than half of business-investment growth in the first three quarters of the year, Goldman estimates. Take the boom away and you could be left with the jobless part. J.P. Morgan Asset Management’s David Kelly already sees real GDP growth slowing to 1.6% over the next four quarters, with hiring stuck near 50,000 a month. Capital Economics markets economist Joe Maher pointed to falling share issuance and “investors’ waning appetite for new shares of AI-firms at lofty valuations.” Anthropic, he wrote, is “a key test.” By Kelly’s math, two years of 2.3% growth “should have led to a monthly gain of roughly 155,000 net new jobs.” Instead, the economy got just 48,000. Kelly mainly blames “a lack of available workers due to a sharp reversal of immigration policy.” The bar has dropped to match. Morgan Stanley’s research digest on Monday, summarizing chief U.S. economist Michael Gapen’s 2027 outlook, put the breakeven at about 50,000 jobs a month. That’s the hiring pace needed just to keep unemployment from rising. Federal Reserve economists Seth Murray and Ivan Vidangos think labor force growth “could be near-zero starting this year,” which would put the breakeven near zero, too. If so, growth in potential GDP “will need to come entirely from productivity growth.” In other words, the economy needs the AI boom to deliver. Where the growth went So far, a lot of this growth has gone overseas. Goldman estimates AI investment will add 0.6 percentage points to “true” GDP growth in 2027 and only 0.2 points to the GDP that actually gets counted. Chips are undercounted in the official data and most of the servers are imported, so they get netted out. Morgan Stanley is more upbeat. Gapen sees hyperscalers spending $1.6 trillion on capex in 2027, adding 0.9 points to growth. Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley are the first two of 22 underwriters named on the cover of Anthropic’s prospectus. Even so, Gapen’s outlook says the AI money is mostly propping up upper-income households, while low- and middle-income consumers lead the slowdown. He expects AI disruption and tighter Fed policy to keep hiring subdued. The banks roughly agree on jobs. On growth, they don’t: Morgan Stanley sees 2.5% in 2027 and Goldman 2.4%, against JPMAM’s 1.6% over the next four quarters. Wall Street’s appetite for Anthropic, at least, looks intact. Bloomberg reported Nov. 12 that the deal was about six times oversubscribed, just days after Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia CEO, threatening the entire AI ecosystem at a pivotal moment. Nvidia is still buying about $10 billion of Anthropic stock in a private placement alongside the offering. Everyone else Goldman calls today’s job market “low-hire, low-fire,” repeating a phrase made famous by former Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell. That works out fine if you already have a job, but it’s dire if you’re young and trying to get one. Employers hired at a 3.4% rate in September, according to the Labor Department’s JOLTS report. The unemployment rate for 20- to 24-year-olds was 7.5% in October, against 4.1% overall. Stanford’s Digital Economy Lab found in August that employment of 22- to 25-year-olds in the most AI-exposed jobs was about 19% below where it would have been had it kept pace with peers in less-exposed work. Staying put doesn’t pay much in this economy, either. Average hourly earnings rose 3.1% over the 12 months through October, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said. JPMAM points out that “despite a tight labor market, real year-over-year wage growth has been negative for seven consecutive months.” Workers are scarce, and they’re still losing ground. They’re also getting a smaller cut of what they produce. Productivity in the nonfarm business sector rose at a 3.6% annual rate in the third quarter, the BLS said Nov. 5, while labor’s share of output, the part paid out to workers as compensation, fell to 53.0%, the lowest since the series began in 1947. AI investment “appear[s] to be contributing” to the productivity gains, Indeed Hiring Lab’s Aubrey Woessner wrote. But “increased labor productivity has not yet translated into higher real pay.” The most direct evidence that AI is holding pay down comes from Apollo Global Management. Economists Sania Edlich and Torsten Slok sorted occupations by how heavily their tasks show up in Claude conversations, using Anthropic’s own Economic Index. After 2023, real wage growth in the most-exposed occupations has run about 6.7 percentage points behind less-exposed jobs, they found, with no statistically significant effect on employment. Workers in the lowest wage quartile of those jobs took the biggest hit, about 10.7 points. “The first measurable labor market effect of AI adoption has been wage compression rather than employment displacement,” they wrote. Apollo estimates about 5.8 million workers are in the most-exposed occupations, and the authors caution that the period “may be partially confounded by post-pandemic labor market dynamics.” Not every measure points the same way. Advertised salaries in the most AI-exposed occupations have risen 46% since 2021, against 25% for the least exposed, according to Indeed data reported in September. That counts what employers offer new hires, not what people already in those jobs are earning. People can tell. The University of Michigan’s consumer sentiment index stood at 51.0 in its preliminary November reading. “About 57% spontaneously mentioned that their living standards have been eroded by high prices,” survey director Joanne Hsu wrote. Capital Economics says the boom is in its final stages. Goldman Sachs has a guess at the stage after that. Its economists expect today’s low-hire, low-fire job market to hold for about another year “before AI displacement begins to have a larger impact in subsequent years.” Generative AI was used for research assistance and/or transcription of this article. The reporter independently reported and verified the factual claims in this article, and a human editor reviewed it before publication.

Original Source

Read the full article at Fortune →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.