Sydney’s new Powerhouse Parramatta museum opened earlier this month after years of construction delays, controversies, and questions over its leadership and purpose.It was billed as one of the world’s major new museums and Sydney’s biggest cultural project since the Opera House. But criticism was constant even before the opening. Detractors called it the “milk crate” due to its white lattice exterior and questioned the cost of building it in a flood-prone area.The $915m (about £700m) museum opened with five exhibitions and drew nearly 20,000 visitors over its first weekend.David Borger, chair of the Powerhouse Trust, hoped the institution would become a cultural landmark for western Sydney, a region that had long lacked a museum of comparable scale. The budget for the project includes a collection storage facility at Castle Hill, another Sydney suburb. “I think once people get in there with their phones and their Instagram accounts, they are going to be sending messages to the world and all of Sydney that there’s a new house in town,” Mr Borger told the Australian Associated Press. The museum faced a leadership crisis even before its opening when chief executive Lisa Havilah stood aside while allegations concerning governance and procurement were investigated, according to local media reports. A formal misconduct investigation was launched following a whistleblower complaint and an initial inquiry. The precise allegations were yet to be made public.Preview of Powerhouse Parramatta on 6 November 2026 (Getty)Spending under Ms Havilah’s leadership reportedly included appointments of “artistic associates” and projects like a documentary about the museum’s construction, which cost at least $1.7m (£1.3m). Ms Havilah hasn’t commented publicly. But a petition started recently to reinstate her said she should be allowed to “stand alongside the extraordinary team who have brought this vision to life”. Abbie Galvin, the New South Wales government architect, was appointed interim chief executive. She described her role as that of a caretaker while the investigation was completed.“Once that’s complete, they might return, and I would certainly hope that would be the case,” she said.“I was just blown away by the capability of the team. They are phenomenal, they are so skilled, they are so passionate,” Ms Galvin told the Guardian. “And, of course, any team needs a good leader, and they’ve had a great leader.” Mr Borger defended the museum’s board, saying it had acted appropriately, while acknowledging the difficulties facing staff.“Whilst it’s been really tough, we’re standing by them and we’re going to open this thing, and I think it will be something we’re all going to be proud of,” he said.Powerhouse Parramatta in Sydney (Getty)The museum’s five inaugural exhibitions feature more than 3,000 objects, including over 1,600 items from the Powerhouse collection.A ticketed exhibition exploring aerospace history, Task Eternal, is one of the main attractions. Four other exhibitions are free, including The Dark, an immersive exploration of childhood imagination developed with artists from Sydney's theatre community.The Mall traces the evolution of shopping centres and consumer culture, featuring objects such as Levi's 501 jeans worn by Apple co-founder Steve Jobs.Another exhibition led by First Nations artists and curators explores water systems in New South Wales. The museum also presents five works by British artist Es Devlin, marking her first exhibition in the country.Overflow exhibition during a media preview of Powerhouse Parramatta in Sydney (Getty)Despite its ambitious launch programme, the institution continues to divide the museum and heritage community.Kylie Winkworth, a heritage consultant and former Powerhouse Museum trustee, is among the project's strongest critics, describing the Parramatta development as a cultural loss for Sydney.“I think people are going to be very shocked when it opens,” Ms Winkworth told AAP. “It should come with a product disclosure warning because it’s not the Powerhouse Museum. It’s not a museum.”“It wasn’t whether Parramatta needs a museum,” she added. “The problem was from the very beginning the community had no say in the museum, in what museum they wanted, what best suited their cultural aspiration.”Ms Winkworth argued that the new institution had little connection to some of the most significant objects in the original Powerhouse collection. These include a working 1793 Boulton & Watt steam engine, associated with the beginnings of the Industrial Revolution, and the Catalina Frigate Bird II, an early flying boat.The original Powerhouse Museum, located in the Ultimo district of central Sydney, is undergoing major renovations. Ms Winkworth also raised concerns about the long-term care of over 500,000 objects in the collection and whether the Parramatta institution would fulfil the educational role associated with museums.The Mall exhibition during a media preview of Powerhouse Parramatta on 6 November 2026 (Getty)“We’re concerned that the budget, the use of consultants, all that stuff is going to jeopardise Ultimo,” Troy Wright, assistant general secretary of the Public Service Association of NSW, which covers many Powerhouse employees, said. “Ultimo is really going to be our real game. Parramatta cannot replace Ultimo, it’s a very, very different museum.”Mr Borger argues that the two sites will complement each other and provide more opportunities to display the collection.“Obviously I think we are still a museum, but equally I think museums are changing,” he said.The Independent contacted Powerhouse Parramatta for comment but did not receive an immediate response. The state government forecasts the museum to attract two million visitors in its first year. Ms Galvin offered a more cautious estimate of between one million and 1.5 million.
Sydney opens £700m ‘milk crate’ museum amid controversies
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Independent →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.