Supernatural’s New Sam Winchester Spinoff Revisits Iconic Season 2 Episode

Supernatural’s New Sam Winchester Spinoff Revisits Iconic Season 2 Episode

Published Nov 17, 2026, 12:57 PM EST TJ Mills is an editor on ScreenRant's Comic team, where she combines her lifelong passion for DC with her analytical background as a former Intelligence Analyst. Since joining ScreenRant in 2023, she has specialized in covering major DC storylines, character evolutions, and industry developments. I was perhaps one of the biggest skeptics when I heard that Supernatural was returning with an early-season-set Sam Winchester series, because what's SPN without the Winchester brothers together? However, now that we're two installments into the spinoff, it has officially won me over. And a preview of January's Supernatural: Sam Winchester release has me convinced we may be revisiting the plot of one of the CW show's BEST Season 2 episodes. As a quick rundown for those out of the loop, the Supernatural franchise is in the midst of a massive revival, with Dynamite having launched a new flagship Supernatural title in 2025. Now, we're entering the second phase of this revival, with both Sam and Dean Winchester getting their own separate series as the brothers continue their classic monster hunts, but this time, they're doing it alone rather than together. To kick off this new era for the brothers, Dynamite released Supernatural: Wayward Special #1, a 48-page comic book one-shot, on September 2, 2026. By the end of the special, the Winchester brothers had gone their separate ways, with Sam believing it was the only way to save Dean's life, despite his older brother's protests. Now, that split leads into two new series: Supernatural: Sam Winchester and Supernatural: Dean Winchester. Splitting up the brothers for their next era was an ambitious move, to say the least. However, as a superfan currently on my fourth rewatch of the original show, I'm actually loving this new chapter for the Winchesters. And now, with an early preview of Supernatural: Sam Winchester #4, I'm even more excited, as I have a feeling this issue may revisit, or at least echo, one of my favorite episodes from Season 2: "CROATOAN." Sam Winchester's Next Case Could Be An Epic Callback To Season 2, Episode 9 Main Cover by Paulina Ganucheau for Supernatural: Sam Winchester #4 As a quick refresher, Season 2, Episode 9, "Croatoan," sees Sam and Dean visit a small Oregon town following one of Sam's visions. It's here that the residents become violently infected by a demonic virus, which is later revealed to be part of a larger demonic experiment. However, by morning, the infected residents have mysteriously disappeared, leaving the town empty. The episode's title, along with the mysterious disappearance of the town's residents, references the real-life American mystery of the Lost Colony of Roanoke. The word "Croatoan" was found carved into a post after the English settlers mysteriously vanished in the late 16th century, making it a fitting reference for one of Supernatural's most unsettling mysteries. Now, it appears that the franchise is gearing up to once again explore the premise of an entire town's residents mysteriously disappearing in writer Paulina Ganucheau and artist Kendall Goode's upcoming January 20, 2027, release of Supernatural: Sam Winchester #4. The synopsis for the issue teases: “Detective Sam scours microfilm of old newspapers, only to discover a tragedy from 1977...the last remaining residents of an old mining town all mysteriously disappeared. And then...those residents started reappearing once more…” With the mention of “...the last remaining residents of an old mining town all mysteriously disappeared,” it's nearly impossible not to think of Season 2, Episode 9, "Croatoan." While this obviously isn't a direct continuation of the episode, it raises the question of whether the cause of the mining town's residents disappearing will connect to the Season 2 mystery. This is entirely possible given that Supernatural: Sam Winchester is part of the franchise's official canon. The series also takes place during the early seasons of the CW show, making this a perfect opportunity for Ganucheau to revisit lore from an episode that never received much follow-up. While there hasn't been an exact confirmation of when Supernatural: Sam Winchester #4 takes place, it likely occurs sometime after Season 2, since Sam's hair in the comic is longer than it was during that season. That said, it will be interesting to see whether Sam mentions the similarities between the Oregon case and this mining-town mystery, particularly if the latter takes place after "Croatoan" in the series' timeline. Of course, this new case will present an entirely different mystery, and we already know it will differ from the original Croatoan case, given that the synopsis teases the residents' eventual reappearance. Either way, I'm keeping my fingers crossed that Ganucheau anchors this new Supernatural series more firmly in the franchise's continuity by referencing past cases. Supernatural: Sam Winchester #4 from Dynamite will be available on January 20, 2027! Supernatural

Original Source

Read the full article at Screenrant →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.