The steelworkers union argued labor board decisions were enough of a deterrent to secondary location picketing, to no avail.VANCOUVER, British Columbia (CN) — Steelworkers protesting a copper mine can’t continue picketing outside a British Columbia port terminal, a judge ruled Thursday.Granting an injunction to the port’s operator, PKM Canada Services Inc., B.C. Supreme Court Justice Simon Coval said United Steelworkers Local 7619 and its allied organizations’ actions outside the port were likely illegal under the province’s Labour Relations Code.B.C.’s Labour Relations Code restricts picketing at locations outside a union’s direct workplace, and USW had expanded its strike against Teck Resources’ Highland Valley Copper mine to PKM’s port terminal in North Vancouver.Coval sided with PKM and the B.C. Marine Employers’ Association, which sued sued last Tuesday and argued in court Monday that the port activities constituted an illegal secondary picket.Ruling from the bench, the judge broadly agreed with PKM’s claim the picket had caused irreversible damage, and that without an injunction, the port was at further risk.Attorney Ryan Copeland, representing PKM, argued that refusal by longshore workers to cross the picket line led to significant business disruptions over multiple days.Labor advocacy organization B.C. Federation of Labour, which ordered a “hot edict” against other unionized workers handling the mine’s materials, and a variety of other local unions also joined the picket outside the port.Copeland said the longshore workers ignored Canada Industrial Relations Board orders to cross the picket line and that the picket even continued into the morning of Nov. 9, despite an order by the B.C. Labour Relations Board barring the picket line the night before.Coval rejected arguments by the USW and the federation that the orders from the B.C. Labour Relations Board and Canada Industrial Relations Board were enough.The judge also noted the federal labor board can’t order the steelworkers not to picket the location — though it can order the longshore workers to cross the picket line — and that PKM doesn’t have standing to maintain or enforce the provincial labor board orders against picketing.“The BCLRB order may be amended or terminated at any time,” Coval said, echoing Copeland’s arguments that PKM is at the mercy of Teck’s decisions around enforcing or maintaining the order.Teck Resources itself has sued over the picketing at both its mine and PKM’s port. A court ruled last week to halt some activities but not picketing altogether at the mine.Coval said the more challenging question to answer was whether the injunction was still necessary.Though the picket line initially continued after the B.C. Labour Relations Board order, the union lawyers said the fact that there hadn’t been any picketing or related activity at the port terminal for a week as of the Monday hearing suggested there was no need for an injunction.They said they were also willing to agree not to return to the terminal without reasonable notice to PKM.“We don’t anticipate coming back,” said the federation’s lawyer, Chris Buchanan, on Monday. USW’s lawyer, William Clements, said the same.But Coval was unconvinced by that, pointing to the continued picket after the initial labor boards’ orders.“The defendants’ insistence on retaining the ability to revive the picket line with reasonable notice reflects their position that they have the right to carry out the impugned conduct,” Coval said.PKM and the B.C. Marine Employers’ Association are still seeking damages from USW and the B.C. Federation of Labour for the economic impact of that picket line.Arguments for that will be heard in trial at a future, yet-to-be-determined date.Courthouse News reporter Dustin Godfrey is based in Vancouver, Canada.Categories / Business, Courts, LawSubscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads
Striking British Columbia steelworkers blocked from expanded picketing
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.