STEPHEN GLOVER: From North Sea oil to welfare, Andy Burnham has become a prisoner of the troglodytes that fill his backbenches

STEPHEN GLOVER: From North Sea oil to welfare, Andy Burnham has become a prisoner of the troglodytes that fill his backbenches

Andy Burnham is popular with the majority of Labour MPs because they think he’s an electoral asset. But that doesn’t mean they will let him do whatever he wants.In fact, it’s becoming clear that the leader welcomed by most of his party is as much its prisoner as the man from whom he wrestled the seals of office, Sir Keir Starmer.On two vital issues – welfare reform and drilling for oil –Burnham faces significant opposition. Rebels are mustering. Plots are being hatched. Letters are being prepared.Even Europe is a bone of contention for Labour. Some trade unionists and Red Wall MPs don’t like the way the PM is enthusiastically nuzzling up to Brussels.Andy isn’t as much in control of his party as he would like us to believe. Although he’s more to the Left than Starmer, the centre of gravity of the parliamentary party is even further to the Left than he is.Look at the row over the Rosebank oil field north-west of the Shetland Islands. Burnham is probably in favour of drilling, having recently given the green light to the smaller Jackdaw gas field east of Aberdeen.Chancellor John Healey backs Rosebank because it will be good for the economy. On the other hand, Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband is fanatically opposed, as almost certainly is his protégé and successor as Energy Secretary, Miatta Fahnbulleh. Both are climate change zealots.The Cabinet is divided but, if all things were equal, there would be a good chance of Rosebank being approved. However, a group of Labour MPs has been covertly preparing a letter modelled on that of the rebels who forced Sir Keir Starmer to abandon very modest welfare reforms last year. Labour MPs will fly to the Cop31 climate change conference this week to warn that approving Rosebank would be hypocritical in view of Burnham’s promise to deliver Net ZeroSome 75 MPs have signed it and there are hopes of reaching 100, which would amount to about 45 per cent of Labour members not on the Government payroll. In that eventuality all plans to drill at Rosebank would surely have to be shelved.A gaggle of Labour MPs will fly to the Cop31 climate change conference in Antalya in Turkey this week to warn that approving Rosebank would be hypocritical in view of Burnham’s promise to deliver Net Zero.Isn’t it hypocritical of them to add to significant global emissions created by the 92,000 participants who have travelled to Turkey from all corners of the earth? Couldn’t these Labour worthies eschew the fleshpots of Antalya and make their point via Zoom?But then they and other signatories of the letter aren’t renowned for their good sense. They don’t care that Rosebank could provide oil that will otherwise have to be imported halfway around the world. Or that it would create as many as 1,600 jobs and supply oodles of tax revenue.One Labour MP, Simon Opher, told the Sunday Times: ‘We cannot expect other countries to cut emissions if we don’t.’ He’s got it entirely wrong. Countries such as China or India aren’t going to reduce their emissions by one cupful to follow us.Alas, there’s no point attempting to have a rational conversation with such people. In all likelihood they will scupper Rosebank, and prevent the Government from doing what it should. That is why I say Andy Burnham is a prisoner.Left-wing Labour MPs are also examining the Government’s latest welfare reforms. Former Blairite minister Alan Milburn will tomorrow unveil his much-trailed inquiry into the huge increase of young people aged 16 to 24 who are not in education, employment, or training (Neets).In fact, these troglodyte members may have no need to kill off Milburn’s reforms since they are so inoffensive. He has been guided by ministers and produced a package calculated not to enrage the comrades, though we can’t be certain he will succeed.Remember that when Starmer attempted to trim £5billion off the £350billion annual welfare budget (that’s about 1.5 per cent) he was seen off by angry Labour rebels, many of whom never forgave him.Milburn has approached his task with the extreme caution of a man defusing a highly explosive bomb. He has already warned that his reforms to youth welfare won’t deliver savings to the taxpayer for ten years.This is because he envisages the Government training and counselling young people, and even creating jobs for them, as it tries to wean them off disability payments.His reforms are fine as far as they go, which is not at all far. Their primary aim is to coax the unemployed or idle young into the workforce. If taxpayers’ money can be saved in the long term, that will be a nice bonus as far as Alan Milburn is concerned.Nor does it apparently occur to him that the State may not be suited to solve a problem it has largely created. There are roughly a million Neets, which is proportionately much higher than in most other developed economies.If the State has failed so abysmally in the past – for example, by handing out disability payments to many young people who can’t reasonably be described as disabled – how confident should we be that it will clear up the mess?Wouldn’t a little shock therapy – withholding all welfare payments from those who are plainly capable of working and can find jobs – be more effective, as well as ultimately beneficial to those involved?In any case, Milburn’s welfare reforms exclusively concern Neets. Under-25s account for only about 11 per cent of those who claim Personal Independent Payments (Pip), the main disability benefit.Some 3.9million people of working age receive Pip at an annual cost to the taxpayer of £26billion a year, which is projected to increase to £41billion by the end of the decade. Milburn’s so-called reforms won’t make the slightest dent on this spiralling sum.Although his proposals are designed to be acceptable to the Labour Left, some of its leading lights are already grumbling. The dependably obstructive MP Bell Ribeiro-Addy has said she isn’t sure she could back welfare cuts.The threat of a revolt may lead to ministers further watering down what is already disappointingly thin gruel. Even if there’s no rebellion, it’s clear the Left is running the show.Meanwhile some Labour MPs – though mostly not of the Left – are muttering about the Prime Minister’s shameful attempt to finagle us back into the EU. Of course, in this instance I hope they are effective, but their manoeuvrings demonstrate how Burnham is encircled whatever he does.Pundits such as myself naturally spend a good deal of time criticising the PM and ministers over their policies. The truth is that, on the rare occasions when the Government contemplates doing the right thing, it is blocked by obstreperous backbenchers.What hope is there for this country if the Government can’t open a single oil field during an oil crisis, or attempt the mildest welfare reform, without the massed ranks of the Labour Left flexing their muscles? So we plough on towards bankruptcy.Bring on an election! That is my cry. Great swathes of these ignorant and narrow-minded people are likely to be removed. If enough of them go, we’ll no longer have a government controlled by them.

Original Source

Read the full article at Dailymail →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.