Social worker 'didn't want to go in' to squalid home where four brothers died in house fire surrounded by faeces and rubbish, inquest told

Social worker 'didn't want to go in' to squalid home where four brothers died in house fire surrounded by faeces and rubbish, inquest told

The great-grandmother of four brothers who died in a blaze as their mother shopped in Sainsbury's told a pre-inquest hearing that a social worker 'didn't want to come in' to see the boys four months before the fire.Twins Kyson and Bryson Hoath, aged four, and Leyton and Logan Hoath, aged three, were left alone to die in a burning room full of rubbish and excrement.Single mother Deveca Rose, 32, was at her local Sainsbury's when the boys perished in the flames at their home in Sutton, south London, on December 16, 2021.Rose was convicted of four charges of manslaughter by an Old Bailey jury and jailed for ten years at the Old Bailey in January last year.Great-grandmother Sally Hoath told South London Coroner's Court she last saw Rose at her squalid home in Collingwood Road, five months before the fire.Mrs Hoath said: 'I was present when a social worker called on Deveca in September 2021.'She didn't want to come in.'I asked her if she wanted to see the boys. She said no and told Deveca 'I can see you have a guest,' and left. Twins Kyson and Bryson Hoath, four, and their younger brothers Leyton and Logan, three, died after being left home alone while their mother went shopping Deveca Rose was jailed for ten years after being convicted of the manslaughter of her four young sons, who died in a house fire in Sutton in December 2021'That was the last time I saw Deveca as my own health deteriorated,' said Mrs Hoath.Coroner Dr Sean Cummings told the pre-inquest review hearing it was 'too early to say,' whether any relevant authority would be found to have 'failed in its duty' over the deaths of the twins.'Social services were already aware of the clutter, the mother had reported spells of dizziness and fainting episodes, with the children present for one of the episodes.'The reports made in July and September that the apparent 'risk to life' had been reduced need to be considered.'Barrister Ivor Collett, for Sutton Borough Council, fiercely defended the borough's social services, and pushed for the inquest in April to be the less rigorous exercise avoiding 'Article 2.''There was nothing that would have given a competent social worker the impression that there would be an incident involving unsupervised young children with naked flames.'At the moment there is no basis for a finding of 'real and immediate harm' in my submission.'Coroner Dr Cummings said: 'The house had no working toilets and the kitchen was unusable.'Mr Collett said he is preparing a 'redacted' version of the 2000 page disclosure report for wider reading. The fire broke out at the family's home in Collingwood Road, while Rose was shopping at Sainsbury's Rose was convicted of four counts of manslaughter following the deaths of her sons Kyson, Bryson, Leyton and Logan 'It is standard for there to be redactions in a case of this nature,' he told the court.The boys' grandmother, Kerry Hoath, asked permission for their dad Dalton Hoath to give his evidence via a prepared statement.'He is still really struggling,' she told the coroner.'I supported him throughout the criminal trial, but I know it would be too much for him to sit through this.'Rose will be represented by Wainwright and Co at the inquest, the court was told.'She may of course decide not to give evidence,' said Coroner Dr Cummings.Rose left the boys alone for 40 minutes and was on the phone to a friend laughing and joking while she went to Sainsbury's for 'non-essential' items on December 16, 2021.By the time the blaze was brought under control by firefighters both sets of twins were dead.Investigators found the children's beds were dismantled and Rose was living in one room with them, using buckets as toilets.The bath was full of rubbish, the garden was also overflowing with junk, excrement was smeared on the walls, and the children had not been to school for three months.Social services contacted her again after an incident at school but 'disengaged' after Rose failed to attend meetings.Rose denied but was convicted of four charges of manslaughter by an Old Bailey jury after a trial in October 2025.She was cleared of one charge of child cruelty. Rose left her four young sons alone at home for around 40 minutes while she went to Sainsbury's to buy what were described as 'non-essential' items Rose was on the phone to a friend, laughing and joking, while shopping at Sainsbury's as her four sons were left alone at homeThe fire is thought to have been started by either a discarded cigarette or an upturned tea light. Neighbours heard the boys screaming, 'There's a fire', as flames engulfed the house.One resident tried to break down the front door but was unable to reach them.Firefighters later found the boys unconscious underneath their beds. They were taken to two separate hospitals but died later that night from smoke inhalation.The original trial heard that social worker Georgia Singh had raised concerns about the family, but the case was closed three months before the fire. Their father, Dalton Hoath, said he could not put into words how their deaths had affected him, adding: 'I simply want to join them.' Their grandfather Jason Hoath said the loss had shattered his life, while their aunt Casey Hoath described the boys as funny and full of character. Their great-grandmother Sally Hoath said the thought of hearing the boys crying and screaming for help would haunt her forever. The three-week inquest, starting on April 5, 2027, will cover the 'smoke spread,' 'rescue attempts,' and resuscitation, as well as touching on the 'school and nursery concerns', visits by social services in the build-up to the fire,' and the effects of the coronavirus pandemic on social work.Dr Cummings said he is 'planning to sit alone, without a jury.'I have the discretion to request a jury, but I do not think it will be necessary.'Witnesses are to include fire and rescue services, social workers, school and nursery professionals, Ms Rose's GP, and a neuropsychologist, some of whom were in court today.Andrew Banks, representing Westbourne Primary School, said staff would give evidence about a logged concern about a 'musty smell in the boys' bags'.'The court will make every effort to trace those who are no longer in the same jobs, or have left the country,' the coroner said.'We need to identify the person who closed the case in September.'The inquest begins April 5.

Original Source

Read the full article at Dailymail →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.