The Only Murders in the Building stars reflected on the priceless moment during their Jimmy Kimmel Live! interview. Martin Short and Selena Gomez on 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!' on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. Jimmy Kimmel Live!/YouTube Selena Gomez, Martin Short and Steve Martin are the trio that keeps on giving! During an interview on Jimmy Kimmel Live! Thursday night (Nov. 19), Gomez and Short recalled the hilarious moment when he accidentally cut into her wedding cake before she and hubby Benny Blanco could get a chance. “It’s insane because I’m blameless in this story,” Short cracked before describing a layout of 15-person sections, one of which housed a small, particularly appetizing cake. “I just assumed it was a cake for each individual [section]; turns out it was the wedding cake.” After corralling Steve Martin, his fellow Only Murders in the Building star, to try some of the cake, Short cut into it twice before everyone in the section yelled his name in horror. So at the Gomez-Blanco nuptials, the iconic first slice of wedding cake didn’t go to the happy couple — it went to her Emmy-winning costars instead. “The second I cut it, and I realized it was the wedding cake, I turned to Paul Rudd and said, ‘Should we just go?'” Short quipped. “I love the teeth marks of the fork [from] where he tried to save it,” Gomez joked after Kimmel flashed a picture of the wounded wedding cake on the screen, before Short chimed in, “That might’ve been the booze talking!” For her part, Gomez remembers her costar being adamant that no one tell her about his blunder, but she was still clueless as to what was going on. Until someone whispered in her ear, “Marty cut your cake.” She kept herself composed and found Short. “He looked like a little dog with his tail between his legs,” she teased, “I heard you ate my cake.” To gauge the scale of Short’s snafu, he wagered there were “more than 10 [and] less than 1,000” guests at the reception. Nonetheless, Gomez clarified that she intended to have a small “Just married!” cake for her and her new husband instead of giving every guest a slice. “We will always have that memory together, and honestly I’ll never forget it,” Gomez said. “And I’m grateful that you tried to eat my cake.” Season six of Hulu’s Only Murders in the Building returns on Tuesday, Dec. 8. Branded Only Murders in London, the new season finds the true-crime-solving podcast gang of Charles, Oliver and Mabel heading to England to catch their next killer. New cast members include Olivia Colman, David Tennant, Nicola Coughlan, Martin Freeman, Jodie Whittaker, Simone Ashley, Richard E. Grant and Geri Halliwell-Horner. Recently, the Grammy-nominated singer spent some time with friend and fellow Disney Channel alum Demi Lovato at a Rare Beauty-hosted Friendsgiving, which was followed by a night out at the Jonas Brothers’ Hollywood Bowl show. Watch Selena Gomez and Martin Short reflect on their hilarious wedding cake debacle below. Get weekly rundowns straight to your inbox Sign Up
Selena Gomez Recalls How Martin Short Accidentally Cut Her Wedding Cake Early: ‘He Looked Like a Little Dog’
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Billboard →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.