Scrapping pay equity breached women's rights, High Court rules

Scrapping pay equity breached women's rights, High Court rules

The Government breached women's rights when it scrapped dozens of pay equity claims and made it harder to apply in future, the High Court has ruled.In his judgment, Justice Paul Radich said the coalition's tightening of the Equal Pay Act discriminated against women and was inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act.Radich also said the changes had been driven mainly by a desire to save money, rather than to fix a broken system.The declaration does not revoke the law or restore the extinguished claims, but the next government will have to issue a formal response to be debated by MPs.The Crown could also yet appeal. The responsible minister Brooke van Velden has been approached for comment.The Public Service Association (PSA) declared the ruling a "groundbreaking historic decision" and demanded the next government restore the original regime "without delay"."The Government cynically cancelled pay equity claims under the cover of darkness, without warning and without due democratic process," PSA national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons said."It was an immoral and now an unlawful betrayal and wage theft, plain and simple."Fleur Fitzsimons protesting for pay equity in 2024.RNZ / Angus DreaverThe PSA was one of five unions which took action against the coalition's law change after it was rushed through Parliament under urgency in May last year.The Government's lawyers argued the changes were intended to keep the system more robust and sustainable. But Radich said they had provided "nothing tangible" to prove that the previous approach was not working as it should.He said official papers showed the changes were mainly motivated by the cost of settling the pay equity claims.Ministers could also have taken "more proportionate" steps that did less harm to women's rights, such as allowing existing claims to continue, Radich found.Radich said women in undervalued, female-dominated jobs had been subject to "unjustified discrimination" because of their sex."They deserve to have the importance of the right, and the fact of its breach, recognised by the Court."The court rejected a separate argument from the unions that the Government had breached their rights by passing the changes without consultation.Radich said there was no legal requirement to consult before introducing a bill.Fitzsimons called on all political parties to take heed of the ruling but specifically pressured the Opportunity Party to "take leadership" during any negotiations to form a government."No coalition deal should leave this egregious law on the books."The provisional election results give National, ACT and New Zealand First a narrow majority, but the final count could leave them reliant on Opportunity's support.Opportunity campaigned on restoring pay equity to the 2020 settings but did not make it an absolute bottom line.

Original Source

Read the full article at Rnz →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.