Safeguards against abuse of power essential to preserve critical institutions like ECI: S.Y. Quraishi

Safeguards against abuse of power essential to preserve critical institutions like ECI: S.Y. Quraishi

IFormer Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) S.Y. Quraishi has expressed concern over the functioning of India’s constitutional institutions. Speaking on Friday (November 20, 2026), he warned that the Election Commission of India (ECI)’s credibility “may take years, perhaps decades, to repair”.Opinion | The SIR and its error marginDelivering the 17th V. M. Tarkunde Memorial Lecture in Delhi on the theme ‘Constitutional Institutions of India: Where Are They Headed?’, Mr. Quraishi said institutions such as the ECI, judiciary and executive needed strong safeguards against the misuse of power.On the ECI, he said its credibility had come under strain since 2019. Further controversy over the 2024 Lok Sabha election turnout figures, former Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa’s dissent, and concerns over the SIR did not help.He pointed out that those who framed the Constitution probably did not anticipate a situation such as the one involving present CEC Gyanesh Kumar.Referring to West Bengal, he said, “The experience of West Bengal exposes the frightening consequences of the SIR exercise. Of the 27 lakh voters deleted during adjudication, 22 lakh appealed for restoration. Yet before the Assembly election, only 1,607 names were restored because hearings had not been done, leaving the overwhelming majority unable to vote. Although I think the Supreme Court had the option of saying that since the number is so large, 2.7 million, let them vote.”He said subsequent appellate tribunal decisions reportedly found 93% of more than 1.2 lakh exclusions incorrect, raising further questions about the exercise. He called for an independent audit of the SIR, disclosure of decision records and digital audit trails, and restoration of names deleted without lawful authority.Government control of ECIOn the appointment of election commissioners, Mr. Quraishi criticised the 2023 law replacing the Chief Justice of India with a Union Minister nominated by the Prime Minister on the selection panel. He said this effectively gave the government control over two of its three votes and called for transparent appointments and an independent selection process.Speaking on the current situation of the judiciary, he questioned the Chief Justice of India’s discretionary power in allocating cases and suggested that a panel of three senior judges manage the roster through a transparent, preferably computerised, system. He also flagged opacity in judicial appointments and delays in government clearances.He said the Supreme Court’s decision upholding the ECI’s authority to conduct the SIR in Bihar had not addressed concerns about procedural fairness and the exclusion of eligible voters.Questioning the inconsistent application of the principle that bail is the rule and jail the exception, he said, “In November 2020, a prominent television anchor’s bail petition received super urgent consideration, resulting in his immediate release. Meanwhile, another journalist, Siddique Kappan, was arrested while travelling to Hathras to cover a horrific crime.”He also cited another example in which the courts turned a blind eye towards a minister, who said ‘goli maro salo ko’ but kept students in jail for six years for charges that are yet to be proven.He also highlighted the backlog of nearly 5.6 crore cases across the country, calling for limits on adjournments and time-bound disposal.Mr. Quraishi condemned the Government over the suspension of 146 MPs in December 2023, when three major criminal laws were passed, saying legislation affecting citizens’ liberty required meaningful Opposition participation.He also questioned Speakers’ impartiality in deciding disqualification petitions, citing the delay in deciding cases following the 2022 Shiv Sena split in Maharashtra.He cautioned Governors against delaying assent to Bills for political reasons and called for clearly defined powers and timelines. He also sought greater scrutiny of the CAG, particularly over alleged suppression of adverse audit findings, and warned against political considerations in UPSC appointments.Concluding his address, Mr. Quraishi called for independent appointments, collective decision-making, recorded reasons and dissent, and stronger accountability. He said disputes involving electoral rights, government formation, and legislative disqualification must be resolved promptly to prevent irreversible damage.Former Supreme Court judge Madan B. Lokur and senior Supreme Court advocate Raju Ramachandran spoke about Justice Tarkunde’s long fight for Constitutional values and civil liberties.

Original Source

Read the full article at Thehindu →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.