Ryan Murphy Shares How He Convinced Jessica Lange to Return to AHS

‘American Horror Story’ Creator Ryan Murphy Reacts to Ariana Grande's Season 13 ExitJessica Lange was thirsty for more American Horror Story. After starring in five former seasons of the FX anthology series, the Oscar winner is set to reprise her previous characters in season 13, but creator Ryan Murphy joked that the script wasn’t what brought her back. In fact, the Glee creator quipped in an exclusive interview with E! News at the AHS: 13 premiere in New York Sept. 23 that he convinced Lange to return with one hilarious method: “Alcohol!” But now it's Murphy who is toasting to the actress, as he explained that working with “this level of talent” on American Horror Story has “changed” his life. “Getting to direct Jessica Lange in that [season one] pilot and Dylan [McDermott] and Connie [Britton] so long ago, it was sort of [asking yourself], ‘That level of actor would say yes to a horror piece?’” he continued. “You have to remember, back then people weren’t really doing a lot of horror things.” Murphy added, “I’ve always loved horror and thought it was always a very overlooked and neglected and maligned genre, so I love now that horror has just become a really cool thing.” Still, the TV mogul confessed it took “a lot” of convincing to recruit the Tootsie actress for a new installment of his spooky world. Cindy Ord/WireImage“A year before I got her, she famously did an interview where she was asked by a reporter if she would come back,” he told Deadline Sept. 23, “and she said, ‘Christ no!’ or something like that, which I thought was hilarious.” Afterward, the 60-year-old invited Lange to dinner and the two got to chatting. “I told her my idea, and she thought it was interesting because she loved doing those four characters,” he explained. “She said, ‘If you can figure out a way to do all four of them, I will do it.’ So, I said, ‘OK, great.’” As Lange sees it, she has admitted that her return to American Horror Story required some convincing. “Ryan Murphy talked me into coming back,” she said on the Sept. 22 episode of Live With Kelly and Mark. “First, he talked to me about playing [season 1’s] Constance, which I think was his favorite character that I did. But I said I’ll come back if I can do all four characters.” And Lange emphasized that her return to her past characters “was great” because, “I like all four of those characters.” She added, “It was fun to play them, and, coming back, it was great to do them again.” For a look back at some of the wildest moments from Murphy’s filmography, including Glee and Scream Queens, keep reading… FOX Image Collection via Getty ImagesScream Queens: Chanel #2's DeathWe all knew Ariana Grande's character in season one of Ryan Murphy's short-lived Fox horror-comedy wasn't long for this world, but we had no idea she'd get such a ridiculous death. Watching her text back and forth with the Red Devil as he stood right in front of her—"I'm going to kill you now." "Wait whaaaaat???"—before composing a tweet about being murdered (and popping up after being delivered a fatal stab to hit send) instead of, you know, trying to get away was truly the silliest thing we've ever seen. FOX Image Collection via Getty ImagesGlee: The Britney Spears EpisodeIn the second season of Glee, some of the members of New Directions (all of whom were minors) began visiting John Stamos' dentist Carl so that they may have anesthesia-induced hallucinations of Britney Spears. Yes, really.FXAmerican Horror Story: Myrtle's ExecutionAHS moments don't have to be terrifying or disgusting to go down as crazy. Case in point? Myrtle Snow's (Frances Conroy) death by immolation (she was burnt at the stake) in the show's third installment, Coven. As the flames swallowed the fashionable witch whole, she shouted (what we thought) were her last words: "Balenciaga!" Can you say iconic?FXNip/Tuck: The Impromptu AmputationIn one particular episode of Murphy's plastic surgery drama Nip/Tuck, which ran for six seasons on FX, Christian Troy (played by Julian McMahon) refused to perform a mastectomy on a patient who feared a family history of breast cancer. So she returned to the McNamara/Troy offices with a motorized saw, removed her shirt, and proceeded to take matters into her own hands right there in the waiting room, hacking away at her own flesh.The WBPopular: Mary Cherry's DaddyIn the second (and, ultimately, last) season finale of Murphy's first series, Popular on the WB, Leslie Grossman's breakout villain Mary Cherry was sent to an orphanage despite nearly being a legal adult (where she lip syncs to the Annie-sampling intro to Jay Z's "Hard Knock Life" while dressed like the iconic orphan) where she finds out that her father is a drag queen going by the name of Sweet Honey Child, played by none other than RuPaul.FXNip/Tuck: The Hot Tub BrownoutAfter the show moved Sean (Dylan Walsh) and Christian to Los Angeles in season five, we were treated to a disturbing scene in which Sean's new actress girlfriend Kate (played by Paula Marshall) took too many laxatives in her quest to be camera-ready and completely evacuated her bowels while the two were getting romantic in his hot tub. Be grateful we didn't attach the aerial shot of the water becoming brown all around them because it's something that we've never been able to shake.FOX Image Collection via Getty ImagesGlee: The Rock SlushieSlushies to the face were commonplace on Glee. Slushies with rocks in them, less so. But that's the fate that befell Blaine in the sesaon three episode "Michael" when rival Sebastian Smythe (played by future The Flash star Grant Gustin) hit him with one full of rock salt, leaving him injured so that Darren Criss could go star in How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying on Broadway during the month of January 2012.FXNip/Tuck: Gina's DemiseJessalyn Gilsig's Gina Russo was a thorn in Christian's side for the first five seasons of Nip/Tuck. Suffering from borderline personality disorder, she was one of the show's most volatile and unpredictable characters. That all came to an end in the fifth season when, while having sex on the roof of the new office in L.A., they begin to have sex, she climbs on the ledge as she's climaxing, and is thrown backward over the ledge to her death. Splat.Michele K. Short/FXAmerican Horror Story: Twisty's MouthAfter terrorizing audiences during the first three episodes of Freak Show, the fourth installment in the American Horror Story franchise, Twisty the Clown (played by John Carrol Lynch) shares the tragic backstory of an aborted suicide attempt that only left his lower jaw mutilated. To tell the tale, he had to take his mask off, revealing one of the more repulsive sights the show had ever delivered. And that's saying something.FXNip/Tuck: The Gay FantasiesThe entire subtext of Nip/Tuck was that Christian and Sean couldn't live without one another, lending a homoerotic thread to just about everything that ever happened between the two of them. But in season four, subtext nearly became text as Christian began having sex dreams involving Sean, nearly bringing plenty of fanfic to life. The gay pool party dream in the season's sixth episode was especially ridiculous.Fox9-1-1: The Rebar to the HeadMurphy's other creation for Fox, the first responder procedural 9-1-1, has had no shortage of truly insane moments over the course of its six seasons, but nothing has been as wild as the season one moment when series regular Kenneth Choi's Chimney was critically injured in the show's third episode ever. A car accident resulted in the firefighter/paramedic taking a piece of rebar through the head, only to survive with nary a scar. We repeat, through the head.FoxGlee: Sue Sylvester's WeddingVery few characters created by Murphy have been as consistently insane as Sue Sylvester, Glee's main antagonist. Played by Jane Lynch, she was a heinous bully who routinely harassed children, once sought to shoot at least one of them from out of a cannon, and occasionally dressed up like Nicki Minaj, as seen here. But nothing was as crazy as the season two episode where she married herself while wearing a blue Adidas track suit dress. Glee was nuts, you guys. Ray Mickshaw/FXAmerican Horror Story: Violet's ShockMuch of Murder House, AHS' initial installment, seems tame in comparison to all the insanity that came in subsequent seasons, but the late-in-the-game discovery by poor Violet Langdon (played by Taissa Farmiga) that she'd been dead for some time and was now a ghost, trapped in the confines of her spooky house, remains one of Murphy's all-time great twists.FXNip/Tuck: The Carver ConundrumWhen the season three finale of Nip/Tuck revealed that the masked serial rapist known as The Carver who'd been haunting Miami since season two was none other than recent hire at McNamara/Troy Quentin Costa (played by Bruno Campos), whose sister also happened to be the detective working the case while also aiding and abetting his many violent crimes. Oh, and it turned out that he was lacking a penis thanks to a rare genetic disorder caused by his being a product of incest, something none of the people he bedded throughout his time on the show (Christian, Julia, Kimber, his own sister!) apparently ever discovered somehow.FOXAmerican Horror Story: Shelly's TransformationPoor Shelly. Played by Chloe Sevigny, the poor nymphomaniac didn't deserve being remanded at Asylum's Briarcliff. Nor did she deserve the horrific experimentation inflicted upon her by Nazi Dr. Arden (James Cromwell), who also amputated both her legs. Her discovery by a group of frightened school children still sends a chill down our spine.FOXAmerican Horror Story: The Name GameLook, we don't really know why Sister Jude's electroshock therapy in Asylum's 10th episode prompted a hallucination in which Jessica Lange performed "The Name Game" with the rest of the cast in a moment more joyous than any single other second of that dark and depressing season, either. But we're sure glad it did. FXNip/Tuck: The Dog and the Peanut ButterWe will never forget the season four episode featuring Melissa Gilbert as Shari Noble, a woman needing her nipple reattached after her pitbull bit it off, Dean Norris as her husband returning home from a deployment in Iraq, and the revelation that Shari's accident actually occurred while she'd been using peanut butter to lure her dog, um, sexually. Naturally, during her follow-up consult, the husband showed up with the dog, now deceased, in a duffel bag. Naturally.FXAmerican Horror Story: Queenie and the MinotaurRemember when a Minotaur (head and tail of a horse, body of a man) was sent to menace Miss Robichaux's Academy in the third episode of Coven and Queenie (Gabourey Sidibe) responded by coming on to and having sex with it, only to be left bloodied and half-dead afterwards? Because we do.Suzanne Tenner/FXAmerican Horror Story: Meet the CountessIt wasn't until well into the premiere of Hotel, AHS' fifth installment, that we met new star Lady Gaga's character The Countess. But it was well worth the wait. She and her pal Donovan (Matt Bomer) go out for the evening, find a hot couple to bring back to the bed, get naked, and then slit their throats, drinking and basking in the blood, all while She Wants Revenge's "Tear You Apart" provides the perfect soundtrack. Needless to say, the character's introduction made quite a splash. Pun intended.FXAmerican Horror Story: The Addiction DemonElsewhere in Hotel's premiere, we witnessed what Murphy hailed as "the most disturbing scene we've ever done" when Max Greenfield's addict Gabriel checked into the Cortez to do a little heroin and was violently raped by the faceless Addiction Demon and his gigantic, sharp metal dildo. Turned out that Murphy wasn't lying. We still have nightmares about this thing.NetflixDAHMER: Jeffrey Offers Glenda a SandwichWhile Evan Peters' portrayal of serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer had many noteworthy—and controversial—moments throughout DAHMER - Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story, there was one scene that took the Internet by storm. We're, of course, referring to the encounter where Jeffrey offers his neighbor Glenda Jackson, played by Niecy Nash-Betts, a "meat" sandwich. Understandably, Glenda is wary to accept the snack, given the suspicious odors coming from his apartment. What's even wilder? This scene is based off a real conversation the infamous cannibal had with one of his neighbors. Pamela Bass, who used to live near Jeffrey, revealed in the 2012 documentary The Jeffrey Dahmer Files, that she did take a sandwich from Jeffrey. "I have probably eaten someone's body part," she noted.For the latest breaking news updates, click here to download the E! News App