Analysis - Anyone who tells you there was a singular "national mood" that defined the election result is wrong. There were many moods. It was the moodiest election we've seen in decades.Votes split between candidates and parties en masse, and the party vote diverged starkly between even nearby polling booths.There was also an historic high tide for the so-called "minor parties". Combined support for National plus Labour - the so-called purple vote - cratered all across the country, replaced with a vote of almost 40 percent for four smaller (but now all bigger than before) parties.To get a grip on all of these different goings on, RNZ has conducted a deep analysis of the results. It examines the votes of communities of roughly 1000 to 4000 people who live around polling booths.To paint a picture of each neighbourhood in the country, we looked at its defining features using information from the 2023 census. Are residents older and retired or younger? Do they rent, or do they own their home? How much do they earn?We grouped the "statistical area 2" (SA2) areas using 13 census measures, including age, household income and ownership, household make-up and population density into seven types of neighbourhoods. We've named these by their most defining characteristic.For example, in Auckland's Tāmaki electorate, Glendowie North falls into 'higher income areas' and Glen Innes West into 'young renting families'. These two neighbourhoods are only a few kilometres apart but are strikingly different in their profile - and the way they voted. Glendowie North's residents are older and richer - they increased their support for ACT and decreased it for National. People living in Glen Innes West are younger and earn less, they increased support for the Greens.The voter patterns of Glen Innes West are clearer when they're combined with the same sorts of neighbourhoods nationwide - our analysis identified 249 others that were most characterised by 'young renting families'. We also found 572 'higher income areas' like Glendowie North, with 1.5 million people.What follows is a rough sketch of how the country voted, broken out by these types of neighbourhoods.There are some caveats. These borders aren't perfect. Some neighbourhoods teeter on the cusp of two different 'types' we have assigned.It should also be noted that the census data is more than three years old and what was true then may be a little different now. When it was conducted in March 2023, for instance, the unemployment rate was at 3.5 percent. September's figure is 5.7 percent.The voting data is preliminary, as counting of special votes is ongoing. When we've compared results to previous elections we've removed that election's special votes so it's a fair comparison.The Mowbray twistThe biggest story of the election night results was the impact of vote splitting.Calling the MMP system a "complete dog", businessman Harry Mowbray said he set out to "show people how bad it is".His campaign called for National supporters to give their candidate vote to National and party vote to a coalition partner. The goal was to engineer overhang seats that would work in the coalition's favour.Whether it was a result of Mowbray's direction or something that would've happened anyway, vote splitting did occur in large numbers. It resulted in seven overhang seats going to National, putting the coalition in the lead.RNZ's analysis shows this happened most powerfully in rural areas and small towns. People living in these areas are mostly of European descent (86 percent compared to the nation's 68 percent). Just over 60 percent own their homes, and around half are in full-time employment.In this type of neighbourhood National's candidate vote grew by the tiniest amount, but its party vote plummeted 9.5 percentage points, while ACT and NZ First's combined party vote grew an almost identical 9.8 points.During the campaign, ACT's David Seymour made an explicit vote splitting appeal to a gathering of voters in West Melton, near Christchurch."Those [ACT] MPs count just as much as extra National MPs. It's the size of the coalition that matters. So there's no risk to putting your party vote with ACT. You're still helping re-elect the coalition."In Bankside, a small township close to West Melton, National's party vote dropped from 52.7 percent in 2023 to 43.3 percent. ACT's party vote climbed to 18.1 percent, up 5.1 points.NZ First also benefitted in these neighbourhoods. Nearby, in Darfield, most of National's losses shifted to NZ First, which grew its vote share by 7.9 percentage points.The pattern was repeated in rural and small town polling booths all across the country. ACT and NZ First's party vote increased in these areas far more than it did across the rest of the country. Rural and small town voters gave ACT 18 percent of the party vote, putting it a whisker behind Labour's 18.4 percent. NZ First received 13.8 percent.Part of Mowbray's case for creating a National Party overhang was to cancel out the one Te Pāti Māori was encouraging its supporters to spin up on the left."There's one plan, two votes; our plan has to be to focus on the candidate votes. We trust you with the party vote we trust and we see your love for our people, for our taiao. We trust that you will choose what is right," co-leader Debbie Ngarewa-Packer told supporters."You have the power to bring this government to its knees."The split in Te Pāti Māori's votes was seen across all neighbourhood types, including rural areas and small towns.In Waipaoa, in the Gisborne District, Te Pāti Māori's candidate received more than half the candidate vote, while the party only secured 7 percent of party vote. In Whatawhata East in Waikato its party vote dropped even lower to 2.3 percent compared to a candidate vote of 72.4 percent.Te Pāti Māori secured a four-seat overhang for the left bloc, with the Greens benefiting most.Greens new heartlandThe Greens had their best election result ever, gaining 13.3 percent of the party vote."[Voters] have given us the most historic support that we have ever seen. The Māori vote is quite phenomenal in terms of its increase even just from 2020, almost doubled. That may go up with specials. That is historic," said Green Party co-leader Marama Davidson.Compared with 2023, its vote grew 26.6 points among voters on the Māori roll, while Te Pāti Māori's party vote dropped 23.6 percentage points.Of the seven types of neighbourhoods RNZ looked at, the Greens grew most in areas where young renting families live. Roughly one in five votes in these suburbs came from voters on the Māori roll, more than double the national rate.Just over a third of people in these neighbourhoods own their own homes, well below the national average of 50 percent, with almost 40 percent living in social housing. The median personal income is $36,000.Voters here continued to support Labour, which secured 47 percent of the party vote, and they turned away from National, whose party vote fell to 17 percent. Te Pāti Māori's party vote also fell.The Greens vote grew 6.8 percentage points from their 2023 result, rising to 15 percent in these neighbourhoods.In Kaikohe, support for Labour, National and Te Pāti Māori dropped, while the Greens got 28 percent of the party vote, up from 5.7 percent in 2023 - a fivefold increase.The party had similar growth in Moerewa in the Far North and Ōtāngarei in the Whangārei district as well as in Tauranga's Matapihi and Whakatāne's Waingarara-Waimana area.It wasn't all clear sailing for the Greens. In some places their upwards trajectory stalled, with Opportunity's share of party vote growing.In the wealthiest areas of the country, where 38 percent of people have a degree, close to 60 percent work fulltime and more than half the residents own their own home, the Green vote grew just 0.1 percentage points from 2023.These neighbourhoods favour National, which secured a third of the party vote, despite falling 11 percentage points.Opportunity was the biggest gainer in higher-income suburbs, winning 7.8 percent of the party vote in these areas here. Nearly a third of all Opportunity's party votes were cast in these suburbs.In Wellington's Wadestown and Karori East, about one in five party votes went to Opportunity.Opportunity's riseFor a party that more than doubled its tally of votes, it's unsurprising that Opportunity grew its share of support across all seven types of neighbourhood. It cleared the 5 percent threshold everywhere except rural and small towns, and young family renting areas, but one neighbourhood type stood out from the rest.Student-heavy neighbourhoods threw the most support behind Opportunity, nearly doubling its party vote share from 5.7 percent in 2023 to 11.7 percent.The party vote share for National, Te Pāti Māori and ACT dropped in these areas, with Opportunity growing more than Labour. NZ First and the Greens had very small increases.The Greens remained strong in this neighbourhood, winning 34.9 percent of the votes, ahead of Labour (28.9 percent) and National (14.6 percent).Student areas are the smallest type of neighbourhood RNZ tracked, with just 29 neighbourhoods, compared to other types with hundreds. While Opportunity did well here, it was only worth 6400 of its 144,298 votes.Higher income areas were responsible for 30 percent of the party's votes, middle New Zealand 21 percent and retirement areas 17.6 percent.Boomers versus millennialsOlder and younger areas both moved away from National, but in different ways. Retirement areas split their party vote while younger areas shifted it.The support that went away from National (down 9.4 points) was fairly evenly divided up between the smaller parties of the left and right blocs in retirement areas.Opportunity grew its vote the most, up 3.8 points, despite claims its land tax policy would turn off these communities, which have the highest rate of home ownership in the country (63.6 percent against the 51.2 percent average).NZ First got 11.7 percent of the party vote in these areas, its best result in the past four elections. Retirement areas matter to the party, roughly one in every four of its party votes come from these neighbourhoods.Nationwide NZ First received 9.8 percent of the party vote, its best result since 2002 but on election night leader Winston Peters, called the election campaign "difficult".Peters may have been hoping for more of the votes in these areas that went to ACT (up 2.7 points) and even the Greens (up 2.6 points), which also both got their biggest share of the party vote here since 2017.Labour barely moved, rising to 25.8 percent, but this still represented its second lowest result among retirement neighbourhoods since 2017.Across a fairly underwhelming map for Labour, the one area it did make meaningful ground was in neighbourhoods with a lot of young renters with few children.Residents in these areas have a median age of 34, and only 28 percent own their own home. Fulltime employment rates are the highest in the country, at 59 percent, and the median household income is $101,000.Here the vote shifted, rather than split, with Labour increasing its share of both the party and candidate vote.National dropped from 37.1 percent of the party vote to 26.5, while Labour gained 5.1 percentage points to 31.9 percent.Labour edged ahead on candidate votes across these neighbourhoods too, with a gain of nearly 5 points, putting it narrowly ahead of National.Opportunity gained strongly here too, increasing its party vote share from 2.8 percent in 2023 to 7.3 percent.The neighbourhoods that moved like the country didHome to roughly a quarter of the population, middle New Zealand neighbourhoods almost mirrored how the country vote.Voters here are close to the country's median age of 39, with around half owning their own home. The median personal income is $39,000, slightly under the national average of $43,000 with a household income of $84,000, again below the country's median. Roughly 10 percent live alone and 57 percent are families with children.National's vote share dropped 8.7 points here, with NZ First and ACT picking up 5.5 points between them. The Greens and Opportunity picked up 6.9 points.Labour got the biggest share of votes in this type of neighbourhood - around 30 percent compared to National's 28.3 percent - but its increase from 2023 was only 1.4 percentage points."Tonight New Zealand has spoken. It may take us a little bit longer to figure out what exactly it is that you've said," Labour's Chris Hipkins said on election night."Every vote matters and every vote must now be counted."The official count, which includes special votes, is due Friday 27 November.MethodologyRNZ grouped Stats NZ's SA2 areas into seven types using 13 measures from the 2023 Census including age, home ownership, income, education, work, household make-up, social housing and population density. We tested between four and 12 types and repeated the grouping hundreds of times on resampled data. The seven neighbourhood types reappeared consistently, and the main vote findings held when neighbourhoods on the edge between two neighbourhood types were left out.We named each type after what most sets it apart from the New Zealand average, such as a high share of young adults, older residents or families with children. Votes are those cast at voting places, linked to the neighbourhood the voting place is in.Neighbourhoods with fewer than 100 residents, such as city centres, industrial areas and airports, were not given a type, because their census figures are unreliable. Votes cast there are included in national totals but not in the figures for any neighbourhood. Votes with no location, such as mobile and hospital voting were treated the same way. Combined these represent about 2.7 percent of the vote.2017, 2020 and 2023 figures are the official count, and 2026 the preliminary count. Special and overseas votes are not included in any year, because they can't be tied to a place. One voting place in Mt Roskill (Blockhouse Bay Primary School) is left out because of a probable error in its 2026 preliminary result.
RNZ's election results analysis reveals a complicated, moody electorate
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Rnz →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.