Researchers ask to block Trump administration from terminating grants based on ‘disfavored terms’

Researchers ask to block Trump administration from terminating grants based on ‘disfavored terms’

A group of researchers say NIH grant applications are screened for more than 200 terms that could reflect disfavored viewpoints, including “gender,” “diverse” and “climate change.”SAN FRANCISCO (CN) — Researchers seeking funding from the National Institutes of Health say the agency requires grant applications to go through an algorithmic screen for over 200 “disfavored terms,” including “gender,” “diverse” and “climate change.”They claim if flagged terms are not removed and replaced with “preferred phrasing,” their research funding could be terminated, a violation of their First Amendment rights.On Wednesday, the researchers asked a judge to block the government from enforcing policies requiring grant applications to go through a political viewpoint screen and to certify two nationwide classes of researchers challenging the policies.“The government is not a private funder that gets to say ‘these views are the ones I want to hear.’ Instead, the government is governed by the First Amendment,” Vera Eidelman of the American Civil Liberties Union, representing the researchers, said. “While it has no obligation to fund private speech to begin with, the only restriction once it funds private speech, it cannot discriminate based on viewpoint and cannot impose restrictions that are unreasonable in the forum.”U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria agreed there was a First Amendment issue with the government policing which words researchers use to describe their work but was skeptical of the argument that grant terminations based on the administration’s policy preferences also ran afoul of plaintiffs’ constitutional rights.“What does not sound like a First Amendment violation to me is canceling a grant because the research the grant is funding is inconsistent with the administration’s policy goals. I think the executive branch has the right, and this is a tentative view … to make policy-based decisions about what sort of research projects to fund and not to fund,” he said.However, the Barack Obama appointee acknowledged that his belief may not ultimately matter, given the controlling precedent set by Thakur v. Trump.In Thakur, a federal judge ruled the government’s cancellation of research grants for reasons related to diversity, equity and inclusion likely violated the First Amendment and granted a preliminary injunction vacating the federal agencies’ terminations of the class members’ grants.The Ninth Circuit later denied the government’s request to stay the judge’s ruling and the Supreme Court declined to review the appeals court’s decision.“My tentative view is that would not be a violation of the First Amendment,” Chhabria said in reference to the government canceling a grant that studied the impact of structural racism on kidney disease. “But, I think it pretty clearly is under Thakur.”The judge told the plaintiffs that he was tentatively inclined to find that the grant terminations violate the First Amendment under Thakur and grant certification for the class of researchers whose projects were terminated.He added that he was also inclined to find the challenged policies violate Thakur and the Administrative Procedure Act but indicated he would deny class certification to the plaintiffs’ second class of researchers as moot if he stayed the policies.Jordan Hulseberg, representing the Department of Justice, conceded that some of the grant terminations are unconstitutional under Thakur but argued the case does not apply to NIH’s current policies because the policies do not discriminate based on viewpoint; instead, they focus on “what makes good science, good science.”“Right now, we don’t believe that there are First Amendment problems with the current operative guidance,” he said.Hulseberg told the judge that the agency has limited funds available for grants and it should prioritize use of the funds in a way that “maximally benefits Americans.”Prioritizing research focused on chronic conditions, cures and treatments for medical issues Americans face drives more measurable scientific results, he explained, describing research into structural racism as “amorphous.”Further, Hulseberg claimed, the language changes being instituted, such as requiring researchers to say “extreme heat” instead of “climate change,” were “arguably more precise” and removed language “marred by political controversy.”“These terms are associated with types of research that are problematic, not because of the viewpoint, but because they don’t align with the priority of advancing the gold standard in science,” he said.Chhabria said he would likely release a ruling by the end of the year.Both parties did not immediately respond to a request for comment.The 14 named plaintiffs are being represented by the American Civil Liberties Union, ACLU of Northern California, Center for Science in the Public Interest, Jacobson Lawyers Group and Protect Democracy.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.