As the U.S. faces a measles resurgence, a conservative nonprofit argues a recent emergency docket decision on parental rights opens a new path for families seeking to dodge shot requirements.WASHINGTON (CN) — Religious parents asked the Supreme Court on Tuesday for help skirting Maine’s school vaccine requirements.James Childs, the father of an eighth grader, says the state’s mandate violates his Christian faith. He is asking the justices to give him and other religious parents an opt-out, citing recent First Amendment decisions.“Childs and his fiancée both work, and he is paying out of his own pocket for remote instruction in place of the schooling Maine has denied his son — the very dilemma this court declared ‘insulting and legally unsound,’” attorneys for Childs and We the Patriots, a conservative nonprofit, wrote. “Childs will not violate his faith, and, because Maine’s vaccination law bars him from public, private and religious schools, he has nowhere to send his son.”We the Patriots filed a similar emergency application on behalf of religious parents in California last year. Both appeals sought an exemption from immunizations based on an attenuated connection to abortions.Vaccines do not contain fetal cells. The American Academy of Pediatrics says some vaccines involve growing viruses using human cell cultures derived from two fetuses aborted in the 1960s. While those cell lines are still active, no new aborted fetuses are needed, according to the association.But Childs claims authorizing vaccinations for his son would make him complicit in abortion, which he described as “unconscionable sin in his faith.”In 2025, the Supreme Court said Maryland schools had to provide opt-outs to religious parents whenever LGBTQ books were used in classrooms. Childs and We the Patriots said the same principle in Mahmoud v. Taylor applies to vaccines.“As Mahmoud recognized … a policy that will ‘substantially interfer[e]’ with ‘the parents’ ability to direct the ‘religious development’ of their children,’ or that poses ‘a very real threat of undermining’ the beliefs and practices they wish to instill, burdens parents’ religious rights and triggers strict scrutiny,” Childs and We the Patriots wrote. “Nothing in Mahmoud confines that rule to instruction or ‘inculcation.’”The Supreme Court rejected similar arguments in We the Patriots’ emergency application for California parents. But the group cited a more recent emergency docket win to support its appeal in Maine.In March, the Supreme Court granted an application forcing California schools to disclose confidential information about students’ gender identity without their consent. We the Patriots claims the decision held that the parental right included the right not to be shut out of decisions about a child’s mental health.“The First Amendment likewise protects a parent from being displaced or punished for making a religious judgment about a state-required physical intervention on his child, because the right ‘extends to the choices that parents wish to make for their children outside the home,’” the group wrote.The emergency appeal was filed as an independent commission within the World Health Organization revoked the U.S.’ measles-elimination status after the virus spread uninterrupted for more than a year.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads
Religious parents ask for Supreme Court pass on school vaccine mandate
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.