Rail workers respond to transport minister after Spain train crash: ‘Human errors occur when you don’t have the equipment you need to do your job’

The train crash on Wednesday near Urda (Toledo), in which two high-speed trains collided, has once again placed the spotlight on the situation of train drivers and other rail workers, who have been in conflict for years with the public companies that operate Spain’s rail network. The driver of the Renfe AVE and a trainee who was accompanying him are among those who have not been located after the accident, according to the latest reports. The tragedy comes just nine months after the death of one of the drivers involved in the Adamuz rail crash in Córdoba, in which 46 people died; and after the death of a trainee driver in the collision at Gelida (Barcelona), which also occurred in January. The string of disasters in such a short period of time has reignited the discontent of a professional association comprising nearly 6,000 members, who object to workers being blamed before the investigations are complete.“Human error? How can the minister say that?” protests Vicente Almenar, a driver and national head of operations for the railway sector at the UGT labor union, referring to explanations given by Transport Minister Óscar Puente. “Human errors occur when you don’t have the equipment you need to do your job,” he adds, audibly upset, on the other end of the phone. “Zero risk will never exist, but when you have the proper tools you reduce it as much as possible,” he stresses. “What he’s done is really unacceptable. He’s just shifting the blame outside his area of responsibility. The necessary investments haven’t been made here; there’s a shortage of staff, of experienced people…” he emphasizes. “All these statements do is create conflict.”“We know from experience that throwing out conspiracy theories is useless; what matters are the data,” says Diego Rodríguez, national section chief for the CGT labor union at state-owned railway infrastructure manager Adif. “What we are all clear on is that we don’t know what happened,” he adds by phone. “We are totally shocked by what happened, and what we are looking for are the causes that led to this,” he says. The trade unionist also rejects hasty explanations at a time when not all the evidence has yet been gathered.Still, Rodríguez uses the opportunity to spotlight what he sees as structural problems in the rail system. “We are not going to be taken for fools. There is a lack of staff everywhere, and there is no investment here,” he warns. The CGT representative draws a parallel with the Angrois accident in A Coruña, in which 80 people died in 2013 after an Alvia train derailed. “At that time all the responsibility fell on the driver and everyone else got off, even though there were earlier warnings that something was wrong,” he stresses. “The rail system as it stands is outrageous. We have to change it entirely because it makes no sense,” he concludes.The Railway Traffic Union (SCF) also expressed dismay at another instance of blaming workers and rejects attempts to assign responsibility before all investigative conclusions are drawn. “It’s very easy to blame the last link in the chain. There are many details we still don’t know,” one of its representatives says. Although early reports point to a failure of the LZB signaling system, an automatic protection technology designed to prevent two trains from occupying the same point on the network, the union focuses attention on other factors related to the condition of the infrastructure. In particular, it points to the age of some of the computer equipment installed at the Atocha Regulation and Control Center (CRC) in Madrid. “It’s a disgrace that a facility like this still has equipment from the 1990s,” they say.Strike actionThe accidents in Adamuz and Urda, which occurred less than a year apart, represent the most dramatic aspect of the train operators’ grievances against Adif and Renfe. Against this backdrop of growing labor tensions, the group is called upon to participate in a one-day strike on Friday, October 30. The strike, which had been called before the accident occurred, will go ahead after Semaf, the largest union representing train drivers, confirmed its support for the action.Once the scale of the tragedy was known, Semaf issued a statement calling for “prudence” until “all the facts are known in detail so as not to engage in speculation.” At the same time, the union sent a message to all sector workers: “We also want to inform all drivers and sector professionals that, regardless of tomorrow’s call, we are studying new actions and measures in defense of rail safety.” It then told its nearly 6,000 members that the strike scheduled for Friday will be maintained “in support of rail safety, as well as to demand fulfillment of commitments to achieve a structural change in safety.”Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition