When Hollywood actresses want to cry, they drop small amounts of glycerine into their eyes. This fools the body into producing tears. The result: fake emotion that cons audiences.We now learn that Andy Burnham's speeches use something similar. A scoop in The Mail on Sunday caught one of the Prime Minister's speech writers asking the artificial intelligence programme ChatGPT to add 'emotive' content to a Burnham address.The aide was spotted working on a train from London to north Wales. He was drinking prosecco at the time. It's all sugar and fizz working at Downing Street these days. Did he put the bubbles on expenses?Being too idle to write the speech himself, or too callow to root the speech in true experience, the unnamed aide asked the robot to do it. As B-film directors used to yack in Tinsel Town: 'Make 'em weep, baby – we need da box office.'In some ways the exposé made one laugh. What ineptitude and sloppiness by a prime ministerial official! To work at No10 was once a great thing for civil servants. Only the sharpest minds would be accepted and they needed discipline and stamina to cope.Some Whitehall high-fliers later rose to become figures in our public life, among them Harold Wilson, Douglas Hurd, Chris Patten and George Robertson. They understood that political debate demanded both intellectual rigour and authenticity.Does Andy Burnham possess either of those qualities? Or is he just a construct of ChatGPT? Is Eyelashes Andy really AI Andy?Much was made of Mr Burnham's speech at the recent Labour Party conference when he paused melodramatically before talking tearfully about his late father. That speech was presented as a moment of spontaneity, some sort of cut-through to the real Andy Burnham. A scoop in The Mail on Sunday caught one of the Prime Minister's speech writers asking the artificial intelligence programme ChatGPT to add 'emotive' content to a Burnham addressAt the start of the speech he told the Liverpool audience: 'It's very hard to put into words the emotion I feel standing here before you all.'Was it so hard that he asked AI to help do the job for him?His speech repeatedly pulled out the onion, talking about his grandmother, working-class aspiration and 'kids' no longer being able to get ahead in life, all because of Brexit and the wicked Tories. How genuine was all this? Did he really believe it?Now that we know his speechwriters ask artificial intelligence to spoon 'emotive' content into his speeches, is it time to reconsider the party conference speech?Some Westminster commentators lost their heads and hailed that speech as the greatest to be given in British politics for a generation. I wrote that there were moments in it when sugar levels were so high, they gave me diabetic twinges.A generation ago, Westminster was not short of people with raw knowledge of the rough end of life. Parliament contained men who had worked in coal mines and on North Sea trawlers, in agriculture and in factories. Others had fought and killed in war.Today's Commons has a few ex-nurses and doctors. But only a handful of today's MPs, at most, seem to have known significant misfortune, and Mr Burnham is certainly not one of them. He was born into a loving, middle-class family. He went to Cambridge. He became a Westminster special adviser. Talking of which, should an Oxbridge English graduate not write his own speeches?The Left likes to freight its arguments with emotion about poverty and hardship. It reaches, still, for the Thatcher years as some sort of assault on opportunity – when they were in fact the very opposite, doing more for social mobility than decades of socialism.Like those Hollywood directors, Labour MPs exaggerate woes and give grievance a vigorous rub of Brasso. This is how they try to form the intellectual case for higher taxes and yet more welfare spending. They think it creates the justification for their assaults on 'privilege' (by which they usually mean excellence, as in the destruction of our independent schools and the desecration of the arts).Now we see that it is a fraud. Mere ChatGPT- generated content. A device to excuse their farming of the welfare vote. I am sorry to say that our outwardly likeable Prime Minister has been caught peddling poverty porn for dirty electoral purposes.If there were real force to their arguments, and real hardship that needed addressing in our politics, no aide would need to ask a computer programme for help. He would be able to reach into his own gizzards for the words.And the voters of Britain would understand that, for the speechwriter would be reflecting the truth.You cannot govern by artificial intelligence. You must legislate and regulate and rule according to true life.And that, Mr Burnham, comes only from the heart.READ MORE: Half of civil servants at several Whitehall departments admit using AI to save time at work as Andy Burnham faces fresh questions over speechwriter using it to help craft keynote speech
QUENTIN LETTS: Is Andy Burnham authentic or just a construct of ChatGPT?
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Dailymail →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.