Thousands of Premium Bond holders have been told they must hand back money to National Savings & Investments (NS&I) after the bank accidentally duplicated some payments, meaning savers got more money than they actually won.Treasury-backed NS&I said £518,000 in Premium Bond prize money was mistakenly dished out to Direct Saver accounts because of a 'technical error'. The blunder affected about 3,500 savers and happened after May's prize draw, according to a story first reported in The Times. This is Money understands that NS&I wrote to affected customers to tell them that transactions on their accounts were temporarily being blocked while the duplicate prize money was removed. Some of the wrongly doled out prize money was automatically taken back from affected customers' accounts, but there is still £1,600 from the total that needs to be repaid. An NS&I spokesman said: 'In May this year, due to a technical error, duplicate Premium Bonds prize payments were made to around 3,500 Direct Saver accounts. 'We contacted all account holders and apologised for the inconvenience caused and cancelled the duplicate payments.' Savers are flocking back to Premium Bonds after last month’s prize rise and Sylvia Morris expects more good news to followOne NS&I customer told The Times that NS&I temporarily froze his account after he genuinely won £1,700 but was overpaid a further £325. Access to his accounts was frozen until the money was recovered. In cases like this, you do not have the right to keep the money that was incorrectly paid to you. However, the money should not be taken back if it puts you into debt.Scott Dixon, of The Complaints Resolver, told This is Money: 'We have seen similar cases before with banks who have made payments by mistake in the past.'Although consumers have no legal right to keep money paid to them in error and NS&I is entitled to recover it, they should not suffer a detriment due to NS&I's incompetence.'He added: 'Customers shouldn't be forced to repay it in full if they cannot afford to because they have already spent it on other things. If you reasonably thought you had won some money on Premium Bonds, you're unlikely to question it and may well have already spent it.'NS&I should offer affordable interest-free repayment options and offer a goodwill payment or compensation to put things right.'A series of blunders NS&I holds £240billion for 24million savers and runs the monthly Premium Bonds prize lottery that gives out anything from £25 up to £1million in prizes every month. The latest NS&I blunder follows a string of other incidents over the years. The Treasury-backed savings bank was embroiled in a scandal earlier in March 2026 after it was believed that around £475million belonging to 37,500 affected customers who had died had not been handed to families. The issue was blamed on the search process which failed to identify all relevant NS&I products.In an update this month, NS&I said: 'As the work to analyse cases has progressed, this number has reduced and is likely to reduce further. 'In May, NS&I’s assessment was that some 34,000 estates with a value of £367million may be affected. 'In the months since, NS&I has continued to analyse cases and today its estimate is that just under 30,300 estates with a value of up to £181.9million may be affected.'As a result of the scandal, NS&I's former chief executive, Dax Harkins, resigned, and was replaced with the former boss of HM Revenue & Customs, Sir Jim Harra. In May, NS&I said that all affected estates with holdings of £10 or more would be contacted to 'reunite them with the full value of those holdings'. Some bereaved families had spent years trying to access their late loved ones' money, completing multiple forms and making numerous phone calls. NS&I rules mean anyone claiming a savings pot of more than £5,000 must obtain probate first.In June 2023, NS&I lost £2million by paying the wrong rate of interest to thousands of savers, with 3,265 people receiving an extra £600 by mistake. But in that case, those who received overpayments did not have to pay the money back. SAVE MONEY, MAKE MONEYUp to £300 cashbackUp to £300 cashback£25-£300 cashback on at least £3004.90% cash Isa4.90% cash IsaTrading 212: 1.05% fixed 12-month bonus£5,000 cashback£5,000 cashback£100-£5,000 cashback when opening SippUp to £150 cashbackUp to £150 cashbackOpen a savings account with at least £5,000Welcome bonusWelcome bonusGet up to £200 when you invest £100Affiliate links: If you take out a product This is Money may earn a commission. These deals are chosen by our editorial team, as we think they are worth highlighting. This does not affect our editorial independence. Terms and conditions apply on all offers.
Premium Bond savers forced to hand back cash due to NS&I blunder
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Dailymail →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.