Nottinghamshire Police are once again facing backlash for their handling of triple killer Valdo Calocane after not examining his phone within the first three years.It is the latest in a string of damning failures that the families of Ian Coates, Barnaby Webber and Grace O'Malley-Kumar said was 'gobsmacking'.Police have admitted that despite being in possession of Calocane's holdall, they did not notice the killer's phone in one of the pockets.It took the force – which has been accused of covering up evidence regarding Calocane and not effectively handling the case – three years to finally forensically examine the device.The paranoid schizophrenic was sentenced to indefinite detention in a mental hospital after he fatally stabbed the 65-year-old school caretaker and two teenage students in a killing spree in June 2023, and seriously injured three more pedestrians when he rammed them with a van.A public inquiry was launched earlier this year into the case, which has highlighted a string of significant failures by police who failed to arrest Calocane despite him being wanted for previous attacks and mental health services who released him back into the community.The Nokia phone was only rediscovered when the families had recently asked police about an item in Calocane's holdall, prompting an officer to go through all the pockets once again. Although the phone was revealed to hold no information, the bereaved families said it 'beggared belief' that failings were still emerging despite evidence hearing for the inquiry being concluded months ago. Valdo Calocane stabbed to death caretaker Ian Coates (left) and students Barnaby Webber (centre) and Grace O'Malley-Kumar (right) Paranoid schizophrenic Valdo Calocane (pictured) has been detained in a secure hospital (left to right) Grace O'Malley-Kumar's brother James, with their parents Dr Sanjoy Kumar and Dr Sinead O'Malley, James Coates, the son of Ian Coates, and Emma Webber, the mother of Barnaby Webber following a press conference with the families of the victims of the Valdo Calocane in February 2025Grace's father Dr Sanjoy Kumar said the police have also admitted that they did not forensically examine a pole that Calocane had used in the attack because it appeared in CCTV footage.'It’s unimaginable to me as a parent that in a multiple homicide a full and thorough fingerprint analysis has not been done to rule out accomplices. This represents an absolutely botched investigation,' Grace's father Dr Sanjoy Kumar was reported to have said in The Times. The paper also claimed that Nottinghamshire Police lost a sensitive file relating to the case but had not immediately informed the inquiry. An officer is said to have lost the file after giving evidence at the inquiry, and left the document in a taxi while travelling from a train station to a pub.The file was claimed to have been recovered after a few hours and senior officers were informed, but not the inquiry, however concerns of a data breach have been raised by the victims' families. Barnaby’s mother Emma Webber has asked whether this incident was raised to the force's professional standards department over the potential breach.'It just gets worse and worse. It is gobsmacking. They did not do their jobs before the attacks, and they didn’t do them afterwards,' Ms Webber was reported to have said.Nottinghamshire Police have not publicly commented as yet on the latest revelations regarding the phone. The Daily Mail have contacted them for comment. However, they have been reported to have said: 'We are aware of the incident and are in the process of providing evidence to the inquiry in relation to it. In the circumstances, we are not able to comment further at the moment.'In September, Nottinghamshire Police was forced to apologise for failing to disclose notebooks belonging to the attacker which contained lists of bomb making ingredients.Among pages of drawings were lists of explosives including acetone peroxide, which is also known as TATP or Mother of Satan, Semtex, mathematical equations, 'deeply misogynistic' ramblings and references to the Manchester Arena attack.The material was found after the attack in 2023 in bins and a holdall at the house Calocane was recently evicted from, but Nottinghamshire Police did not disclose it because it was not deemed to be of 'evidential value'. The notebooks contained lists of explosives including Semtex and acetone peroxide as well as mathematical equations Rachel Langdale KC, counsel for the inquiry, said it would be 'clear to everyone that the inquiry would be interested in this material' after the notebooks were finally disclosed three years onIt was only provided to the inquiry into the attacks in recent weeks, after the conclusion of evidence hearings, when lawyers for the bereaved families noticed a reference in a police statement.The notebooks crucially were not given to the Crown Prosecution Service or to psychiatrists who assessed Calocane's culpability.That meant they were not considered before their recommendation, accepted by a judge, that Calocane should escape a murder trial and be allowed to plead guilty to manslaughter by diminished responsibility to the anger of the victims' families who wanted him jailed instead of given a hospital order.Days earlier, it was reported that the police failed to tell the bereaved families that they were being stalked by a mentally ill man who is said to have had a 'fixation' on the 2023 atrocity.The unnamed suspect sought out Barnaby's family home in Somerset, and the GP surgery where Grace's father Dr Sanjoy Kumar worked, after absconding from a mental health hospital.Yet police did not notify the grieving families at the time, despite being aware of the threat. Officers are said to have downplayed the risk he posed because he was supposedly trying to 'help' them.Nottinghamshire Police referred itself to the Independent Office for Police Conduct.The police watchdog is already examining several potential failures in the case, including how Calocane was at large and free to strike despite an outstanding warrant for his arrest on another matter.CCTV footage showing Calocane attacking a warehouse worker months before the triple stabbing also emerged for the first time in September after being uncovered by lawyers.Reacting to the news, Dr Sanjoy Kumar, Miss O'Malley-Kumar's father, said: 'Since we lost Grace, it has been one shock after another, one failing after another.'I cannot get my head around how much has been kept from us, even the last day of summation.'We've got people telling us that Valdo Calocane was planning to possibly bomb Nottingham. He was looking at venues and he was looking at pipe bombs.'Elsewhere, 15 NHS workers have been fired in recent weeks for inappropriately accessing the victims' medical records. And at the beginning of the inquiry, a family liaison officer is said to have told one of the survivors that the police were not made aware of Calocane before the attack as part of an approved timeline.This is said to not have included any of the 11 police dealings with Calocane, who was made aware of his attacks on neighbours and forcing entry to a woman's flat. Footage of Calocane attacking co-workers at a Leicestershire factory five weeks before the attack had also been deleted, the inquiry was told, citing 'human error'. Sophie Cartwright KC, representing survivors at a public inquiry, said 'withholding of relevant information appears to be an issue considered at the highest level of Nottingham police.'John Beggs KC, representing Nottinghamshire Police, said there had been 'communication failures' but insisted it was 'simply not correct to suggest a cover up'.
Police failed to examine Nottingham triple killer's Nokia found in pocket of his holdall for three years in latest blunder
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Dailymail →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.