Pentagon press escort requirement faces heavy fire at DC Circuit

Pentagon press escort requirement faces heavy fire at DC Circuit

A separate panel in April allowed the Pentagon to maintain a policy requiring journalists to make appointments to interview officials and staff, which it added after the initial press policy was struck down.WASHINGTON (CN) — The Justice Department on Monday urged a D.C. Circuit panel to maintain the Pentagon’s restrictive press policy, specifically a requirement that journalists be escorted at all times within the complex, suggesting the government has the right to fully close the Pentagon to reporters.The three-judge panel heard consolidated Pentagon appeals challenging Senior U.S. District Judge Paul Friedman’s summary judgment ruling that its press policy and subsequent escort requirement violated the First and Fifth Amendments.On Oct. 6, 2025, the Pentagon announced a policy allowing journalists to be labeled a “security risk” for reporting classified or unclassified information without authorization. Dozens of major news outlets across the political spectrum refused to sign, leaving Trump-aligned journalists with “Pentagon Facilities Alternate Credentials.”The New York Times challenged the policy Dec. 4, 2025, arguing it discriminated against reporting disfavored by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. During litigation in spring 2026, the newspaper said the restrictions reversed longstanding press access during wars and crises, including Sept. 11, 2001, as the U.S. conducted strikes on Venezuela and entered a war with Iran.Senior U.S. Circuit Judge Judith Rogers pressed the Justice Department on the limits of its position, citing the Supreme Court’s view that reporters “roaming the halls” of government serve the public and “helps aid the security of this nation and of our democracy.”Justice Department attorney Sean Janda argued that the Pentagon is a nonpublic forum under the First Amendment, like an airport terminal or polling place, where the government may reasonably restrict speech and journalists have no inherent right of access.“They have no right in the first instance under the First Amendment to be in the Pentagon, which is closed to the public, and they have no right to get access to government information, which is not being provided to the public,” Janda said. “The cases are exceedingly clear that the government can close a non-public forum to all expression if it’s doing so in an even-handed basis.”Janda argued that the escort requirement on its own could not be retaliatory as it applied to all credentialed reporters.U.S. Circuit Judge Patricia Millett emphasized that news gathering is central to journalism, questioning a provision that presumes reporters knowingly “ferreted out” unauthorized information unless they provide sufficient evidence otherwise.The Barack Obama appointee said the standard, which resolves doubts in the Pentagon’s favor, exceeds criminal evidentiary standards.Theodore Boutrous of Gibson Dunn, representing the New York Times, argued the presumption effectively puts “journalism on trial” whenever reporters use unauthorized information.He urged the panel, which also included Senior U.S. Circuit Judge Karen Henderson, a George H.W. Bush appointee, to reinstate Friedman’s summary judgment order lifting the escort requirement.On April 27, a separate panel allowed the escort requirement to remain during the appeal, finding the Pentagon likely to succeed in arguing the provision was not properly before Friedman because it was absent from the original 2025 policy.Three days after Friedman granted the Times summary judgment on March 20, the newspaper reported that the Pentagon had introduced an interim policy retaining many restrictions on journalists and adding the escort requirement.The Times moved to compel compliance, asking Friedman to vacate the revised policy and restore press access to its pre-October 2025 level.At a March 30 hearing, Friedman was particularly concerned with the policy’s restriction barring the “intentional inducement of unauthorized disclosure” — the prior version used the term “solicitation” — calling it “way worse.”Friedman then granted the motion to compel on April 9, slamming Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth for reinstating the unlawful policy “under the guise” of taking new agency action and expecting “the court to turn a blind eye.”The Justice Department has also asked the appeals court to vacate Friedman’s compliance order as an abuse of his discretion, arguing the Pentagon was right to try and amend its press policy following Friedman’s initial ruling.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.