Paper Tigers' Best Trick Completely Changes The Film

Paper Tigers' Best Trick Completely Changes The Film

Published Nov 20, 2026, 4:20 PM EST Brandon Zachary is a Lead Writer for Screen Rant's New Movie Team. He also writes or has written for Comicbook.com, CBR, That Hashtag Show, Just Watch, and TVBrittanyF. Brandon is an Emerging Screenwriters Semi-Finalist, co-writer of a Screencraft Quarter-Finalist, a seasoned on-screen interviewer, and a MASSIVE nerd. You can reach him at bs.zachary@gmail.com The following contains spoilers for Paper TigerPaper Tiger initially presents itself as a crime thriller, but that's only a feint for what the movie is really about. Written and directed by James Gray, the initial teasers for the film presented Paper Tiger as a tale of criminal intrigue and intense consequences. The film sets itself up as such, too, especially once Miles Teller's Irwin gets on the wrong side of his new Russian "business associates. However, while that underlying tension and fear never necessarily goes away, the movie shifts gears tonally and becomes something very different. Rather than be a sprawling crime movie or turning into a violent shootout, Paper Tiger (much like its namesake) proves to be a far more quiet, introspective piece. It's a surprising but solid feint that only works because of the talent of the cast assemble for the movie. Paper Tiger Isn't The Crime Thriller It Initially Sets Itself Up To Be Paper Tiger is much more of a focused character drama than a tense crime thriller, a trick that only really works thanks to the skills of the cast assembled for the movie. At first, Adam Driver's Gary is perfectly positioned to be our morally dubious protagonist. He's a smooth-talking former cop, infamous on the force for being one of the rare non-corrupt officers. His business dealings with the Russians, though, are quickly complicated by his brother's well-meaning interference. His efforts to keep things from spiraling out of control could have become the impetus for a good cop to finally break bad, especially once his extended family is getting overtly threatened by the Russian mafia. That first act really lays the groundwork for something more tense and focused on criminality, only for that to fall by the wayside. There are no secretly evil cops, no grand conspiracy. There's only ever even two real fights between the protagonists and the Russians, with the first one entailing a quick beating with a belt. The movie sets up a crime thriller that never really occurs. The flm never gives in to schlockly impulses or cinematic flights of fancy. The movie remains painfully grounded as Gary tries to convince the Russians to calm things down while bristling with his brother. There's no action movie theatrics to his arc, no morally dubious touches. Instead, the movie treats Gary like a real person using logic to try to escape his problems. [Paper Tiger] works because it feels the drama feel real. Perhaps the best example of this comes when the Russians bluntly tell Gary they're coming for him. Other movies might have given Gary a badass load-up scene or showcased him preparing for one last duel to save his family. Instead, he says goodbye to his loved ones and quietly sobs in his car, prepared to die for their sake but nevertheless scared of it. James Gray's best trick was to set up a crime thriller that never stops being a character drama. Even Gary's final confrontation could be seen as anticlimactic, with him taking out two gangsters before being shot in the back. There's no monologue or flashback, just a man we've come to know collapsing and quickly fading amidst the corn stalks he'd used as cover as a key part of Paper Tiger's ending. It works because it makes the drama feel real. It's not propped up as a cinematic shootout or the conclusion of a man's moral journey so much as the consequence of his ambitions catching up to him. It keeps Paper Tiger from ever leaving the drama genre to become a thriller, a risky call that ends up working in the film's favor. Paper Tiger Works As A Character Drama Because Of The Thriller Elements It Leaves Out Scarlett Johansson is another example of Paper Tiger subverting expectations when it comes to the way the story sets itself up. In plenty of other crime thrillers, Johansson would make a natural femme fatale. Even if she's not an active player in the criminal drama, her role as Irwin's wife could make her a complication for the other characters. While she does play a key role in inadvertently dooming Gary by reaching out to the FBI about his dealings with the mafia, her real arc is a much more muted and somber storyline. Diagnosed with a terminal brain tumor, Johansson's Hester finds herself wrestling with the fear and grief that comes with. Just as her husband downplayed the threat of the Russians, however, Hester hides the truth. Her story becomes another example of how lies and secrets can tear apart a family, which serves as the underlying moral theme of the film. Paper Tiger codifies this with a surprisingly sweet dynamic between Hester and Irwin's sons, a direct reflection of the fracturing bond between Irwin and Gary. Likewise, Hester is keeping a big secret from her husband, all in the name of protecting him. These turns could have all felt melodramatic, but the cast does terrific work making everyone feel lived in and real. Johansson gets lots of dramatic beats and potentially showy moments, but her best work in the film (and perhaps all year) comes as she shakily comes to terms with the prognosis given to her by a doctor. Paper Tiger is a character drama first and foremost, using the trappings of the crime thriller genre to lure audiences into a much more grounded and emotionally resonant story. That blunt realism and the way it plays out in mundane ways even on the biggest screen underscores the humanity too often lost in flashy films made in this genre, elevating Paper Tiger in a key way. Paper Tiger Release Date November 20, 2026 Runtime 115 minutes Director James Gray Writers James Gray Cast

Original Source

Read the full article at Screenrant →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.