NOVEMBER 17, 2026 20:00Otzma Yehudit submitted a bill to amend Israel's Law of Return two days after the 26th Knesset was sworn in, seeking to restrict recognition of conversions to those performed "according to Jewish law" and effectively overturn a landmark High Court of Justice ruling recognizing Reform and Conservative conversions for immigration and registration purposes.The bill, submitted by MK Limor Son Har-Melech, adds the clause into the law's definition of a "Jew": someone born to a Jewish mother who is not a member of another religion, or someone who converted "according to halacha," meaning Jewish religious law.The stated aim is to render meaningless the High Court ruling that also recognized Reform and Conservative conversions for the purposes of aliyah and registration.Between 2005 and 2008, 11 petitions were filed by immigrants who had undergone Reform or Conservative conversions in Israel. The High Court repeatedly postponed ruling on the petitions to allow the government and Knesset to formulate an agreed-upon solution.In 2021, in what became known as the Dahan ruling, an expanded panel of nine justices ruled that the state must recognize such conversions performed in Israel within a recognized Jewish community for the purposes of the Law of Return. The court emphasized that the issue was civil, not religious.MK Limor Son Har-Melech reacts during a National Security committee meeting at the Knesset, the Israeli parliament on March 5, 2024; illustrative. (credit: YONATAN SINDEL/FLASH90)Former Supreme Court president Esther Hayut explicitly wrote that the Knesset was entitled to give the term "conversion" a different meaning through future legislation.This is an important point for the bill's sponsors: From their perspective, and the court's, the proposal represents a legitimate decision by the sovereign legislature rather than an attempt to circumvent the court.What does 'according to halacha' mean?The bill does not define the term, and that is where the questions begin.Halacha is not uniform. In the past, the Supreme Rabbinical Court even annulled conversions performed within the Rabbinate's own state conversion system in 2008 and 2009, most notably those conducted by the late Rabbi Haim Druckman, before the High Court intervened in 2012 to stop the practice.Who, then, would determine whether a conversion complies with halacha? Would that authority rest with the Chief Rabbinate, or would private Orthodox rabbinical courts also qualify?The question also affects the constituency represented by the bill's sponsors.The private Orthodox conversion initiative Giyur K'Halacha, supported by religious Zionist rabbis, converts about 220 people annually. That is more than the Conservative movement, which converts approximately 92 people a year, and comparable to the Reform movement, which converts approximately 234.The High Court has previously recognized private Orthodox conversions for the purposes of the Law of Return, even though the Chief Rabbinate refuses to recognize them.If "according to halacha" is interpreted as referring exclusively to conversions approved by the Chief Rabbinate, converts who went through Giyur K'Halacha could also be affected.The reverse is equally true. The term "according to halacha" does not specifically refer to Orthodox Jewish law, meaning its ambiguity could allow the courts to interpret it as referring to the religious law of any denomination of Judaism.What about Diaspora Jewry?The High Court recognized Reform and Conservative conversions performed abroad for population registry purposes as early as 1986 and 1987. That recognition was subsequently extended to the Law of Return.The current bill makes no distinction between conversions performed in Israel and those conducted abroad.According to an analysis by the Israel Democracy Institute, Reform and Conservative conversions performed overseas would no longer confer eligibility for aliyah as Jews.This is a dramatic development, given that a Pew Research Center survey found that only 9% of Jewish adults in the US identify as Orthodox, compared with 37% who identify as Reform and 17% as Conservative.The Jewish Agency for Israel and Jewish organizations in the Diaspora have previously warned against similar proposals, fearing a deep rift with world Jewry.Notably, the bill does not repeal the "grandchild clause" of the Law of Return.Someone with a Jewish grandparent would therefore still be eligible to immigrate to Israel as a family member, although they would not be registered as Jewish.However, someone who underwent a non-Orthodox conversion and has neither a Jewish relative under the new definition nor a spouse who meets the relevant eligibility criteria could lose the right to immigrate to Israel.A return to Ben-Gurion?In 1950, David Ben-Gurion chose not to include any definition of the term "Jew" in the Law of Return.It was only in 1970, following the Shalit ruling, that the Knesset first enacted Section 4B, defining a Jew as someone "born to a Jewish mother or who has converted."Lawmakers deliberately avoided adding the words "according to halacha" as part of a historic compromise intended to prevent a rupture with Diaspora Jewry.Since then, prime ministers from both the Right and Left have resisted repeated attempts to add those words for more than 50 years. The campaign has also historically been associated with the Lubavitcher Rebbe and the Chabad Hassidic movement.The current bill therefore does not represent a return to a previous arrangement, but rather a fundamental change to the status quo.As recently as the final days of the 25th Knesset, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu blocked an identical proposal by MK Simcha Rothman, partly because of concerns over the response from Diaspora Jewry.What problem is the bill intended to solve?In numerical terms, the High Court ruling affected a relatively small group: an average of approximately 326 Reform and Conservative converts annually in Israel, compared with thousands who convert through the state conversion system and the IDF.In terms of public opinion, an Israel Democracy Institute survey found that 46% of Israeli Jews recognize people who have undergone non-Orthodox conversions as Jewish, compared with 39% who do not.The same survey found that 46% believe representatives of Diaspora Jewry should be included in discussions about changes to the Law of Return.By contrast, the potential diplomatic cost in relations with American Jewry could be extremely high.What do supporters say?Supporters of the proposal argue that the legislation addresses a fundamental issue that the Knesset has avoided for decades.They contend that preserving conversion "according to halacha" is intended to ensure unity in matters of Jewish religious law and prevent a situation in which the state recognizes as Jewish people who cannot marry or be buried as Jews under the rules of Israel's Chief Rabbinate.MK Simcha Rothman has previously argued that most conversions in traditional Jewish communities abroad are already performed according to halacha.He has also maintained that the intention is not to harm liberal Judaism, but to prevent an influx of "fictitious conversions" or conversions conducted under more lenient standards for immigration purposes.Follow us on Google
Otzma Yehudit proposes Law of Return amendment threatening recognition of Diaspora conversions
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Jpost →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.