The state of Oklahoma argues the rules do not let parties reopen a final judgment based on a different tribe’s case. (CN) — The 10th Circuit weighed Tuesday whether the Osage Nation can reopen a 15-year-old ruling that Congress ended its reservation or whether a procedural rule blocks that effort because a later Supreme Court case involved a different tribe and different laws.In oral arguments in Denver, Eugene Bertman, representing the Osage Nation, told the panel the lower court never finished the analysis required by the rule that lets parties seek relief from old judgments.“The District Court held that it held no power to grant that relief,” Bertman said, pointing to McGirt v. Oklahoma, in which the Supreme Court said a reservation ends only if Congress clearly said so in a statute. Courts cannot decide a reservation is gone based on later population changes or other outside evidence.“It stopped at injunction, and it stopped at change in law,” Bertman continued. “So it never did the rest of the analysis the rule requires. It never considered the extraordinary circumstances that only Congress has the power to diminish or disestablish reservation boundaries.”Bertman said the Osage Nation is the only tribe in Oklahoma that has not received a full McGirt review of its reservation because of the continuing effect of the 2010 decision in Osage Nation v. Irby. He asked the court to wipe out only the part of that old judgment that dealt with the reservation’s boundaries and to declare that Irby no longer controls that question.U.S. Circuit Judges Gregory A. Phillips, Michael R. Murphy and Joel M. Carson III asked whether the Nation has other ways to raise the issue. Asked why the Nation could not simply file a new lawsuit, Bertman said most cases involving the relevant federal Indian-country law are criminal cases in which the Nation is not a party. He added that the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals has already refused to revisit the question while Irby remains in place.Asked whether winning this case would force the state to refund taxes collected since 2010, Bertman said the Nation is not asking for that relief here and has dropped its original tax claims, though he acknowledged other lawsuits could be filed later. He also rejected the idea that individual tribal members or a class action could settle the underlying boundary question without the Nation itself being involved.On one part of the procedural rule, Bertman argued the situation is more than a routine change in the law because the earlier court went beyond its power by declaring the reservation ended without clear language from Congress. He said Irby and McGirt used the same basic framework for looking at Oklahoma reservations created during the allotment era.Garry M. Gaskins, representing Oklahoma Tax Commission officials, said the appeal is narrower than the Nation claims.“This is not about whether the Osage Reservation exists today,” Gaskins said. “The only question is whether [the procedural rule] allows a party to reopen a final judgment 15 years after this court affirmed it, and the Supreme Court denied certiorari because a later Supreme Court decision about a different tribe construing different treaties in different statutes reached the result the [Nation] prefers.”Gaskins argued one part of the rule applies only to judgments that require a court to supervise ongoing conduct, not to the ordinary binding effect of a final decision that simply ended a case. He said another part of the rule does not help the Nation because McGirt is not closely related enough to this case under the appeals court’s prior decisions, given the different tribes, treaties and statutes involved.He also noted the Nation waited more than four years after McGirt to file its motion and pointed to unique language in the law that made Oklahoma a state, which turned the Osage Reservation into a county — one of the largest in the country. Gaskins disagreed that Irby went further than McGirt allows by relying on outside factors after finding no clear statutory language ending the reservation. He said the statehood law creates uncertainty unique to the Osage.Murphy, a Bill Clinton appointee, asked whether the rule’s broad equitable powers could still apply because the case involves tribal sovereignty. Gaskins said the court has already ruled a later change in the law is rarely enough to reopen a case, and creating a special exception for sovereignty issues would open the floodgates to more such requests.On rebuttal, Bertman said the Nation already tried the alternative path the lower court suggested and that the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals rejected the argument that the law had changed. He added that the Irby decision itself found no language ending the reservation in the relevant statutes. Phillips is an appointee of Barack Obama and Carson is an appointee of Donald Trump. The panel took the case under submission without indicating when it would rule. Follow @gabetynes Subscribe to our free newsletters Our weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts. Additional Reads
Osage Nation asks 10th Circuit to revisit 15-year-old reservation ruling
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.