The Carnaby Street Christmas lights switch-on happened nearly two weeks ago - so why is everyone suddenly talking about it now? It’s not because of the spectacle of the lights twinkling overhead, but because of what was happening down below.People watching the Christmas lights at Carnaby Street on their phonesInstagramLook, I’m Gen Z. I love my phone, I live on social media, and I’m definitely not here to lecture you like some sort of tech-hating grandma.Full disclosure: I was there on the night filming it too. Granted, I was literally being paid to get the video for work, and perhaps even if I wasn’t working, there’s a fair chance I’d have whipped my phone out to capture it anyway.Even so, standing in the middle of that crowd, I was genuinely taken aback by the sheer ocean of devices pointing up into the air.People in the streets were packed like sardines, pushing and shoving just to get the cleanest shot. One person behind me actually shouted “put your phones down”… and I’m pretty sure they were the only person in Soho not recording the countdown.Singer Jamie Miller switches on the Carnaby Street Christmas Lights with Laura WhitmorePAIt was so noticeable that host Laura Whitmore clocked it on stage alongside ‘Babydoll’ singer Jamie Miller before the big moment.Honestly, a part of me felt a bit bad for him. He wasn’t performing to a crowd of people, he was performing to a wall of smartphones.And the most ironic part? This year’s display is called ‘Press Play on Christmas’, inspired by the 90s. Organisers say it’s meant to celebrate a time when culture was experienced together in person, and Christmas was all about shared, spontaneous moments. Laura even said as much right before the switch on: “We’re gonna go back to a time folks, a time when shopping brings us all together and not just scrolling online. And I love seeing every single one of your faces here, ’cause that’s what it’s all about… community, bringing people back together in real life in Soho...”Except she wasn’t looking out at a sea of faces. She was looking at a sea of screens.Carnaby Street turned on its Christmas lights on November 4PASince the clips blew up online, people have compared the whole scene to an episode of Black Mirror, with EastEnders legend Natalie Cassidy calling it “scary and depressing” that nobody was watching the display with their own eyes.Psychologists actually have a name for what happens when we do this: “photo-taking-impairment”, where relying on a camera to capture a moment stops your brain from properly remembering it.Now, maybe some people wanted a keepsake to send to family who couldn’t be there. But having grown up on social media, I know first-hand how we use it as a highlights reel. It’s the whole “pics or it didn’t happen” mentality.Read MoreBut it makes me wonder who these videos are actually for, and what they’re trying to prove. Because if we’re so busy trying to show off what a cool night we’re having, it raises some pretty big questions. Did we actually even see it? And were we really even there?Madelaine Dowds is a video journalist at The Standard
OPINION - Lights, cameras, distraction: If you didn’t film it, were you even at Carnaby Street’s Christmas launch?
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Standard →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.