Ohio State's season is over, but Jeremiah Smith is still worthy of this year's Heisman Trophy

Ohio State's season is over, but Jeremiah Smith is still worthy of this year's Heisman Trophy

Before Nebraska’s 31-28 win over Ohio State at Memorial Stadium on Saturday, the Cornhuskers honored former defensive tackle Ndamukong Suh, who is set to be inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame next month. After the pregame festivities concluded with Suh, the Buckeyes took the field with the best player to compete in Memorial Stadium in the 17 years since Suh was a Cornhusker. That player was receiver Jeremiah Smith. There are plenty of storylines from what happened in that game: Nebraska ended a 31-game losing streak against ranked opponents, Ohio State lost its fourth game in a season since 2011, and head coach Ryan Day‘s long-term future in Columbus is being questioned by fans. But for Smith — who had six receptions for 165 yards and two touchdowns, one of which was a 31-yard catch in the back of the end zone with an insane toe-drag — everything that happened around him shouldn’t have an impact on how he’s remembered. Smith is a legend, just like Suh. He’ll be honored before a game at Ohio Stadium in 15 years. But one big difference between Suh and Smith is how the Heisman Trophy vote should end. Suh, a menacing defensive player, finished No. 4 in the 2009 Heisman voting. Smith, one of the greatest players in college football history, should win it this season. Following Ohio State’s win over Northwestern seven days ago, Day made a statement about Smith that you’ll rarely hear a coach make about a player. “At the end of the day, the No. 1 goal is to win, but we also have an obligation to this young man,” Day said. “Given what he’s done for this program, who he is as a person, how he plays, and what he does for his teammates, he deserves the opportunity to touch the football.” Day’s news conference this Saturday didn’t even last five minutes after Ohio State lost to Nebraska. The Buckeyes are in complete shambles, and given that this is one of the most expensive rosters in college football, it’s understandable that the head coach wanted to get away from the cameras and back to the team bus as quickly as possible. The truth is, Ohio State’s season was over long before it arrived in Lincoln, Neb., to face the Cornhuskers. Maybe some Buckeyes fans allowed themselves to fantasize about backdooring their way into the College Football Playoff, but this team just isn’t good enough. Across the board. But that doesn’t mean Smith shouldn’t win the Heisman Trophy. That award is his. While it’s a weird juxtaposition that the greatest player in Ohio State history is playing on perhaps the worst team in 30ish years — 2011 doesn’t count, given all of its most important players were suspended — Smith’s greatness transcends the Buckeyes’ weakness as a team. It’s jarring to watch Ohio State play without playmakers on either side of the ball, outside of Smith. Though no player has ever been as good as Smith, you could argue that none of the Buckeye greats over the last three decades were surrounded by so little. Still, Smith produces. Week in and week out. How much should a team’s record go into how we vote for the award? In the past, it always felt like the quarterback on the best team had the inside track. But in 2026 — two years after Travis Hunter led a 9-3 Colorado team to win it — maybe there’s more to the equation? That may be true given the sport’s current landscape, where no single dominant player or team draws all the national attention. The last full-time receiver to win the Heisman was Alabama’s DeVonta Smith in 2020. In 11 games, he recorded 98 receptions for 1,511 yards and 17 touchdowns. Given it was the odd season impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic, those were Smith’s numbers at time of voting. Ohio State’s Smith has 86 receptions for 1,482 yards and 17 touchdowns so far this season. While a truly outstanding season is necessary for a receiver to win it, and Smith is doing that, the Buckeyes haven’t been able to deliver it for him. Quarterback Julian Sayin was injured against Indiana, and Ohio State has lost three games since. The thought was that Smith would have to save Ohio State’s season to win the award. The truth is, Smith didn’t save Ohio State’s season. But the idea that he could have — despite terrible jobs by both coordinators, no pass rush, no toughness, and no playmaking ability outside of him —reinforces the type of player Smith is. And Day pointed out last week that this isn’t a career achievement award. But the truth is, Smith may have been the best player in college football for each of the past three seasons, including his freshman season, when he helped the Buckeyes win the national title. The craziest part about that? Smith hasn’t won the Heisman Trophy or the Biletnikoff Award, given annually to the nation’s best receiver. There will be plenty of talk about Ohio State’s record. Heck, it could get worse next week if the Buckeyes lose to Michigan. But we all have eyes. We all know who the country’s best player is. It’s Smith. The Heisman.

Original Source

Read the full article at On3 →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.