6 min readThe Republicans in Congress are scrambling to fill as many government positions with unqualified replicants as they can find before the clock runs out on their majorities. The giddy-up on these nominations has impressed Democrats as being unseemly. From nominationnotes on Substack:Senator Chris Coons ... expressed frustration. “The Constitution entrusts us as senators with providing advice and consent on nominations to the federal judiciary. And that means we need the time to interview you, to review your backgrounds, to be prepared for a hearing like this, and to take seriously what is a lifetime appointment,” he said. “I have never seen this happen in my 16 years. We typically get a month to review committee questionnaires so that we can be prepared to do our jobs, and that just did not happen here.”Senator Cory Booker likewise decried the short period of time senators had to review records, saying that he was yet again “watching the norms of the Senate and the constitutional dictates be undermined for petty political advantage.” He also criticized the Republicans’ “post-election race to get people on the bench” in states like North Carolina, South Carolina, and Texas, where incoming Senate Democrats would likely appreciate having a role in selecting judges in their states.This has resulted in some hilarious testimonial follies, and at least one near hooley between the two senators from Texas. On Tuesday, it was a panel full of judicial nominees, and there were some real lulus in there. The Democrats on the committee decided to test the nominees' independence. Who, they asked, won the 2020 election?The six district court nominees also refused to say that Biden won in 2020. [Philip] Aubart stated that “President Joseph Biden was certified the winner of the 2020 election” and said he wasn’t “entirely sure of what the popular vote results were.” [Joseph] Falvey said that “in 2020, through the Electoral College, Joe Biden was certified the winner of the presidential election.” He said that “in our constitutional system, the president is selected through the Electoral College, not through the popular vote.” He also said that “the question implicates a matter of public and political controversy” and that it would be inappropriate for him to respond. Senator Blumenthal said that Falvey’s response demonstrated “a lack of independent judgement and truth-telling.”[Eric] Hamilton was up next. After asking Senator Blumenthal to remind him of the question, he said that “Under our Constitution, it’s the vote of the Electoral College that has constitutional significance. Joe Biden was certified as the winner of the 2020 election when the electoral votes were tabulated.” The other nominees agreed, with [James] Sullivan saying he couldn’t improve on Hamilton’s answer. “I think you probably could,” Senator Blumenthal responded. Sullivan also invoked the judicial canons, saying it wouldn’t be appropriate for him, as a nominee, “to get into that.”“Just so everybody understands, the reason I’m asking this question is a test of your independence,” Senator Blumenthal stated. “You are going to be the voice and face of justice to anybody who appears in your courtroom if you are confirmed. And they’re relying on your objectivity and resistance to any political loyalty test, which is, unfortunately, what you’re demonstrating here.”This is just equal parts silly and insulting by now. Just say it, people. Joe Biden won the 2020 election.The real dust-up came over the nomination of one T. Elliot Gaiser, the head of the DOJ's Office of Legal Counsel to a seat on a federal district court in Texas. Outgoing Senator John Cornyn refused to return the "blue slip" on Gaiser's nomination, at least in part for the reason that Gaiser is from Ohio, which makes sense to me.“He’s not from Texas. He hasn’t been vetted. And this is a lifetime job, and there’s better qualified people to hold that job,” Cornyn said in an interview on Wednesday. “This is part, of course, of the constitutional responsibility of senators in the Senate to provide advice and consent. But it’s hard to provide advice and consent when there’s zero consultation, which happened in that case.”Which is where the fun begins.Cornyn lost the Republican primary for re-election to the inexcusable Ken Paxton, who had the support of the president, and the president's poodle, Senator Ted Cruz, Cornyn's colleague from Texas. So I feel pretty safe in speculating that they're not prom dates or anything. Cornyn blue-slipped Gaiser. Then, on Wednesday, this happened. From the Washington Sun:John Cornyn and Ted Cruz got into a heated fight on the Senate floor yesterday about one of Donald Trump‘s judicial nominees. Cornyn was yelling so loudly at his Texas colleague at one point that he could easily be heard from the press gallery above the mostly empty chamber. “I don’t find you credible. I’m mad at you!” Cornyn told Cruz, his voice booming across the room.Cornyn then told Cruz he was upset at someone “for ending my career!” We couldn’t make out whether that was directed at Cruz or Donald Trump, who endorsed Ken Paxton in the Texas Senate Republican primary, ending said career. Cruz’s response, which we couldn’t hear, set Cornyn off again. “Oh, that’s bullshit!” he said. Cornyn then waved off Cruz with his hand and stormed off to the Democratic side of the aisle. Turns out that there are reasons enough to be dubious about putting Gaiser in a lifetime seat on any court. From Just Security:The administration’s affront to legal constraints on the use of military force intensified when it proceeded to attack Iran without congressional approval in violation of the Constitution, the War Powers Act, and international law. At the center of these outrageously illegal uses of the U.S. military is the Office of Legal Counsel. As its head—a position for which he was not qualified but for which the Senate confirmed him by a narrow party line vote of 53-45—Mr. Gaiser has been the government’s chief source of legal advice justifying both. Yet, as perhaps a measure of the administration’s confidence in that legal advice, neither of Mr. Gaiser’s written opinions has been made public. Notably, Mr. Gaiser’s memo on the Venezuela operations resulting in Maduro’s capture and rendition, which was released in redacted form, is often legally incoherent and replaces analysis with an almost shocking deference to the president. The overwhelming weight of expert analysis is that this operation, like the ongoing Iran War and boat strikes, was unlawful under domestic and international law. And Mr. Gaiser’s “misstatement of the law” in the other respects has “sweeping implications” for the protection of civilians in armed conflict. It is notable that these uses of military force run afoul of Article I of the Constitution—giving Congress the power to declare war, alongside a host of other adjacent powers—and of the 1973 War Powers Resolution (WPR) that was intended to ensure Congress has tools to constrain the president in unilateral uses of force. Senators of both parties have every reason to be especially concerned, as Mr. Gaiser is the legal architect of robbing the Congress of its constitutional place and making an end-run around the War Powers Resolution. I will grant you that the draining of Congress's war powers to the Executive branch is a horse that left the barn decades ago; in fact, on Thursday, the Senate killed a war powers resolution as regards to the Iran war. But, sooner or later, there has to be a test case, and it might as well be Gaiser.And, yes, Gaiser was yet another person who could not say who won the 2020 election.Come Thursday, a panel of nominees for an assortment of administration jobs met the Senate Homeland Security Governmental Affairs Committee. Senator Richard Blumenthal once again climbed on the merry-go-round. He went up and down the panel asking who won the popular vote in 2020, and he once again was handed the rote bafflegab. Blumenthal was particularly irked by Michael Losapio, a former Palantir (!) executive who been picked to head the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency. Blumenthal changed things up a bit and asked Losapio if there had been an "attack" on the Capitol on January 6, 2021. Losapio's response smacked gobs all over Capitol Hill.“I don’t know. I don’t believe it was an attack.”Blumenthal was agog."You don't know? You're giving us that answer?""I wasn't involved in politics back then. I know what I saw on the news."Were you alive on the planet?”“I was,” LoSapio said.The next two months are going to be such fun.
Of Course Trump’s Judicial Nominees Are a Bunch of Election-Denying Yahoos
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Esquire →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.