‘Not a silver bullet’: How tax cut demands could torpedo Neets plan

‘Not a silver bullet’: How tax cut demands could torpedo Neets plan

Businesses are set to demand tax cuts in exchange for supporting a new plan to help almost a million 16- to 24-year-olds into work. Government insiders fear a recommendation in Alan Milburn’s review to offer national insurance cuts to employers who hire more young people could derail the proposals. Labour grandee Milburn made the proposal – which would be a significant funding commitment to the Treasury – in his long-awaited review into tackling the problem of Neets – those not in employment, education or training – which will be published on Tuesday. One of its key proposals is to make hiring young people more attractive to businesses by reducing the amount of national insurance contributions (NICs) employers have to pay – starting with retail and hospitality companies, which provide almost 40 per cent of jobs for Neets. It is thought that as well as reducing the burden on businesses and freeing up money to create more jobs for young people, this would also encourage them to recruit young people in the first place. The former health secretary also wants the Government to legally guarantee a job, training or employment support for under-25s, with those who refuse to take up the offer potentially losing their benefits. Milburn is expected to recommend that the employer contributions cut is introduced over the course of five years. But a Government insider has said there is now concern that business support for adopting Milburn’s proposals could be dependent on whether the Prime Minister decides to cut NICs for employers immediately.Immediately axing the tax on earnings paid by employers for 21- to 24-year-olds alone would cost the Treasury around £5.1bn, according to research by the Resolution Foundation think-tank. Alan Milburn wants the Government to legally guarantee a job, training or employment support for under-25s (Photo: Joe Giddens/PA) The source told The i Paper: “NICs are going to be the thing that business pulls out of it. “I worry that we will end up in a space where business effectively says you either accept the full report or you don’t, or we’re not engaging with it. “It’s not an unreasonable assumption to make because you can’t say you accept absolutely every single thing apart from the thing that helps us out with the additional requirements you will have of us coming out of this to find opportunities for people.” At the moment, businesses pay no employer NICs for workers younger than 21 or for apprentices under 25, unless they earn above a threshold of £50,270. However, for non-apprentices aged 21-24, employers pay 15 per cent on annual earnings above £5,000. The change was introduced in April 2025 by then Chancellor Rachel Reeves. She increased the rate from 13.8 per cent and lowered the threshold from £9,100. Craig Beaumont, from the Federation of Small Businesses, said firms will be “looking at the range of commitments made in the review”. He said: “That includes easing the chilling burden of National Insurance hikes, but also new SME [small and medium-sized enterprise] employer incentives and including entrepreneurship alongside education, employment and training – as young people don’t have to work for someone else.” Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden is expected to initially welcome Milburn’s report in a statement to Parliament on Tuesday. The Government’s formal response to Milburn will come in the new year, with legislation expected in April or May. Reeves hiked employer Nics across the board in order to raise £40bn in a widely criticised move. The Tories say this is contributing to the problem as it makes hiring workers too expensive. But a Downing Street spokesman denied this, arguing the rise of Neets has been ongoing for some years. “Alan Milburn has said himself that untargeted and unaffordable cuts in employer NICs isn’t a silver bullet to the needs crisis, which is decades in the making,” the spokesman said. “Between the end of the pandemic and the general election in 2024, before the increase to employer links was made, the number of Neets went up by 250,000. “(The report) also makes clear the drivers of youth inactivity are deeply entrenched and require a whole system reform, which we wholly agree with, and that does include realising the role business plays in tackling this issue, which is why we’ve already made it easier for business to hire young people.” Ministers expected to welcome Milburn plans Government sources said Burnham was taking a keen interest in the debate, having urged MPs to vote against former Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer’s abandoned welfare reforms last year. “This has moved from something that Pat [McFadden] commissioned 12 months ago to something Andy is taking a massive personal interest in, so ultimately, he’ll decide whether cutting NICs is a go-er. But it’s going to be the thing that the Tories jump on,” the Government source added. “Given the noise that (Chancellor) John (Healey) and Andy were making early on about wanting to support small businesses, high streets, etc., this is not the worst recommendation Alan could have come up with for us to have to find a chunky sum of cash. I just worry that not doing it gives businesses an easy out to discredit it [the Milburn review] from the start.” Milburn is also likely to recommend reducing benefits for under-25s. They should no longer be able to claim the health element of UK-wide Universal Credit or personal independence payment (Pip), which is the main disability benefit in England and Wales. But it is unclear whether a separate review into Pip chaired by minister Sir Stephen Timms will agree. His report is due as soon as next week, sources said. The Treasury declined to comment.

Original Source

Read the full article at Inews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.