No, Republicans Didn’t Lose Because of Trump’s Immigration Policies

No, Republicans Didn’t Lose Because of Trump’s Immigration Policies

In the aftermath of Republicans’ historic midterm defeat, Democrats and the establishment wing of the Republican Party are both claiming that President Trump’s immigration policies helped fuel the Democrats’ victory. The Wall Street Journal’s Allysia Finley writes of the president’s “unpopular tariff and immigration policies.” The subheading of a Nation article reads, “Voters made their disgust with Trump’s war on immigrants clear.” Forbes senior contributor Stuart Anderson asserts that “Trump’s trade and immigration policies played a significant role in motivating voters, leading to significant Republican losses in the midterms.” The Wall Street Journal’s news section, in an article called “How Trump Lost the Midterms,” claims that by early 2026 the “immigration crackdown that had helped get Trump elected had become an albatross.” Exit polling, however, tells a very different story. Voters were asked which party “is better able to handle” eight different aspects of governance. They favored Democrats on seven of those eight — on handling “the economy,” “artificial intelligence,” “healthcare,” “foreign policy,” “government corruption,” “taxes,” and, amazingly, “transgender” policies. The only one on which Democrats didn’t win was “immigration,” where the two parties were tied (42 percent apiece). Beyond this, exit polling makes clear that voters who were really focused on immigration favored Republicans. Indeed, nearly three-quarters of voters said that “immigration enforcement policies” were either a “crucial” or “major” factor in their vote. Those 72 percent of voters favored Republicans — by 50 to 48 percent. (Democrats, meanwhile, won heavily among the 27 percent of voters who said that such policies were only a minor or nonexistent factor in their vote.) Among the 36 percent of voters who called immigration enforcement policies “crucial” to their vote, Republicans won by a margin of 56 to 43 percent. In other words, voters who cared a lot about immigration backed Republicans — and the more they cared, the more likely they were to back the GOP. Exit polling also asked voters which issue was “the most important facing the country.” Of the six issues offered, “immigration” came in third, with 13 percent saying it was the most important. Those voters backed Republicans by an almost nine-to-one ratio — 89 to 10 percent. It’s a strange sort of “albatross” that produces such electoral support. How, then, can Democrats and establishment Republicans feasibly claim that immigration helped swing the election toward the Democrats? They try to do so by pointing to exit polling showing that a clear majority of voters (59 percent) regarded the Trump administration as having “gone too far” on immigration enforcement. But this result doesn’t change the numbers cited above — it only helps explain why Republicans didn’t fare even better with voters on immigration. Democrats and establishment Republicans also point toward how voters weren’t too happy with Immigration and Customs Enforcement — with voters disapproving, rather than approving, of the job that ICE is doing, by a margin of 61 to 39 percent. Leaving aside that ICE nevertheless polled better than both Congress and the president — and almost as well as the Supreme Court and Republicans — this likewise doesn’t contradict the exit polls’ other findings on immigration. What’s actually indicated by the answers to which Democrats and establishment Republicans are pointing is that something else — something other than ICE’s actions — influenced voters’ views on immigration. That something, rather clearly, was enforcement at the border. Exit-poll questions aren’t written by conservatives, so such polling didn’t ask voters about the job they thought the Trump administration had done in securing the border, or about which party they trusted more when it came to border enforcement (as opposed to broader immigration enforcement). Voters thought ICE enforcement in the country’s interior got a little overzealous (probably particularly before Trump sacked Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem) yet still viewed Republicans more favorably on immigration than on any other issue. This strongly suggests that they appreciate the job that the Trump administration has done at the border. This is likely especially true on the heels of President Biden’s four years of refusing to enforce federal immigration law, which resulted in roughly 8.6 million illegal aliens — more than double the population of Los Angeles — either sneaking across the border or (more often) being deliberately released into the country on his watch. In truth, exit polling suggests that — when it comes to reasons why they voted against Republicans — voters objected first to perceived corruption, second to the high cost of living (brought into effect under Biden but not alleviated under Trump), and third to the Iran war (which in turn also affected the high cost of living). In all, 90 percent of voters said“government corruption” was either a major or crucial factor in their vote, 89 percent said “the cost of living” was, and 74 percent said “the war in Iran” was — with such voters favoring Democrats in each instance by a margin of at least 18 points. In marked contrast, those who said “immigration enforcement” was either a major or crucial factor in their vote favored Republicans by 2 points — and those who said it was a crucial factor backed the GOP by 13 points. After Trump rode his opposition to open borders to not one but two victories in presidential elections, one would think that establishment Republicans and reasonable liberals would finally recognize that, as much as they love open borders, most Americans don’t agree with them. This year’s exit polling provides further evidence of that fact. In a year when Republicans lost on essentially everything else, they didn’t lose on immigration. Jeffrey H. Anderson is president of the American Main Street Initiative and served as director of the Bureau of Justice Statistics at the U.S. Department of Justice from 2017 to 2021. 20262026 midtermsBorderImmigrationMediaPolitics

Original Source

Read the full article at Thefederalist →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.