No mandate only women personnel can ‘handle’ women in crowd-control operations, Delhi Police to SC

No mandate only women personnel can ‘handle’ women in crowd-control operations, Delhi Police to SC

Security personnel patroling near Jantar Mantar on the eve of a protest call given by CJP against CEC Gyanesh Kumar, in New Delhi. Image used for representation purpose only. | Photo Credit: Sushil Kumar Verma The Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court there is no strict rule that only women police officers must “handle” women in crowd-control operations.The police was responding to allegations of manhandling women protestors and journalists by male police officers during widespread protests demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar. The allegations were made in petitions by Network of Women in Media, India, represented by advocate Aarthi Rajan, and others like the Delhi Union of Journalists, Free Speech Collective and the Kerala Union of Working Journalists.The legal requirement that only women police officers could arrest or carry out searches on women was not a mandate in crowd-control situations, the police submitted in an affidavit.“With regards to the allegations of manhandling of women journalists, it is respectfully submitted that the requirement of women personnel handling women is not a statutory mandate in the context of crowd-control operations, in the same manner as it is expressly prescribed under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023 in relation to searches and arrests,” the police said.The police said the deployment of women personnel in a crowd-control situation was an “operational consideration” depending on various factors, including the need to maintain propriety, avoid unnecessary confrontation and defuse tensions at a protest site, particularly if there were women participants.The mere presence or involvement of male police personnel in crowd-control operations during the CJP protest cannot, itself, be construed as misconduct.There is no legal bar on a male police officer from acting as a first responder. Nor is he stopped from assisting a woman police officer in the discharge of her duties.“Such decisions have to be taken at the fraction of a second,” the police affidavit said.The affidavit said an October 11 direction of the apex court to the Delhi Police to not “hinder” journalists, lawyers and other professionals in the discharge of their professional duties did not extend to reel-makers, social media influencers or unruly elements who break the lawful directions of the police at the site of a prohibited assembly.The police said it “fully respects the role of the press”. However, there were individuals masquerading as journalists by using a camera and a microphone. The protest site, which the police repeatedly said was “illegal”, was replete with ‘content creators’ for YouTube.The affidavit said though the police had found it difficult to distinguish between journalists and reel-makers, the latter were neither obstructed nor hindered unless they posed a risk to public order and law.The Delhi Police pointed out that the current laws, guidelines and rules did not consider reel-makers, creative or otherwise, or content-creators as ‘working journalists’.The police said it was yet to be determined if “reel-makers can be elevated to the status of journalists or reporters”. The police said the lack of a clear distinction in law hampered the police in its duties to maintain law and order, especially in an unprecedented situation when thousands marched to the Parliament in July as part of an “unauthorised” protest. The July protests were against question paper leaks in the NEET-UG 2026.The affidavit said that the police have consistently maintained restraint though people with cameras and microphones defied orders to keep a reasonable distance from “operational areas”.The police denied any attempt on their part to obstruct or interfere with journalists engaged in their professional pursuits. Anybody apprehended on account of mistaken identity had been immediately released in verification of identity, the police said.“The police action was directed solely towards dispersing and removing the protestors from the illegal protest sites and restoring public order, and was neither intended nor directed towards detaining, restraining or obstructing any media personnel in the lawful discharge of their professional duties,” the Delhi Police maintained. Published - November 18, 2026 12:30 pm IST

Original Source

Read the full article at Thehindu →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.