The panel weighed whether a lower court improperly threw out testimony from Texas-based ear surgeon Dr. Yoav Hahn.SAN FRANCISCO (CN) — San Antonio parents Carlos Gordoa and Ariani Reyes say their son had Apple’s first-generation AirPods Pro in his ears when the sound of a high-pitched Amber Alert in May 2020 “tore apart” his eardrum, damaging his cochlea and leaving him with permanent hearing loss in his right ear.However, their case against Apple was tossed last April after a judge concluded that the evidence showed the AirPods in question cannot produce an Amber Alert loud enough to cause acoustic trauma.“There is no dispute B.G. experienced tragic hearing loss and injury, but to hold Apple liable for those injuries plaintiffs must proffer evidence sufficient to find something Apple did caused those injuries,” U.S. District Court Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley wrote.To support their claims, the plaintiffs offered testimony from Dr. Yoav Hahn, an ear surgeon from Dallas, Texas, who said in a deposition that the Amber Alert could have caused an “acoustic shock” that damaged B.G.’s ear.However, Corley found the doctor unqualified to render an opinion about the cause of the plaintiff’s injury and found his conclusions unreliable. Without that testimony, the Joe Biden appointee concluded, the plaintiff’s case couldn’t hold up.On Tuesday, plaintiff’s attorney William Haacker told a Ninth Circuit panel that Hahn was more than qualified to provide expert testimony, given his two decades of experience diagnosing and treating inner ear injuries in clinical practice.Haacker pushed back on statements made by Apple’s expert that the type of hearing loss at issue was impossible under 120 decibels, citing another study that looked at call center operators who experienced similar symptoms as B.G., including tinnitus, ringing in the ears and vertigo, which Haacker says is consistent with inner ear injuries between 82 and 120 decibels.However, Neil Lloyd of ArentFox Schiff, representing Apple, challenged the study, pointing out that it was published in 2002 on a non-peer-reviewed site.“[Hahn] didn’t cite anything, and there’s nothing in the literature that suggests that a sound intrusion of below 120 decibels can cause this type of hearing loss,” Lloyd said.Haacker also doubted Apple’s expert theory that the boy’s hearing loss came from Covid, explaining that he had no symptoms leading up to the Amber Alert and that the symptoms he exhibited did not occur until after he heard the alert.At the time of the boy’s injury, the Covid vaccine had not yet been released, and Covid testing was not widely available. Some studies have linked hearing loss with Covid, even if the infection is largely asymptomatic.“It’s not just that B.G. was asymptomatic. He didn’t have any symptoms leading up to it,” Haacker said, adding, “There was no indication right before, and they are only an indication of those same injuries that we claim here after the Amber Alert plays for 10 seconds, and only his right ear, and he loses hearing in only his right ear.”Lloyd argued Hahn was wrong to completely rule out Covid as the cause of B.G.’s symptoms just because he did not exhibit traditional Covid symptoms such as loss of smell.“He didn’t say it could have been either, and I don’t know … Dr. Hahn’s opinion was that it was only this acoustic shock, and in ruling it out, he ruled it out in a logically contradictory way,” he said.U.S. Circuit Judge Ryan D. Nelson, a Donald Trump appointee, questioned why there weren’t more cases like B.G.’s if wearing headphones during an Amber Alert caused the symptoms he experienced.Haacker said the case’s rarity shouldn’t be a factor in considering Hahn’s methodology and should ultimately be weighed by a jury. In contrast, Lloyd told the judges that the case was rare because it was impossible.The panel included Senior U.S. Circuit Judge Richard A. Paez, a Bill Clinton appointee, and U.S. Circuit Judge Daniel P. Collins, a Donald Trump appointee.In a statement to Courthouse News, Haacker said he appreciated the panel’s attention to the case and thoughtful questions.“Our client’s son lost the hearing in his right ear when an Amber Alert played through his AirPod. A board-certified neurotologist examined him and explained why it was the Amber Alert that caused his injuries. That testimony deserves to be heard by a jury. We are confident in our position and look forward to the court’s decision,” he said.A representative for Apple did not immediately respond to a request for comment.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads
Ninth Circuit questions tossed expert testimony in AirPods hearing damage case
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.