Ninth Circuit balks at back pay fray over vaccine mandate for San Francisco workers

Ninth Circuit balks at back pay fray over vaccine mandate for San Francisco workers

A religious discrimination complaint by San Francisco city and county workers is ongoing, but an appellate panel didn't seem to want to wade into their request for back pay.SAN FRANCISCO (CN) — An attorney for two former San Francisco city and county employees didn’t get far into his argument on Wednesday that his clients deserve back pay after being reinstated to work following a dispute over Covid-19 vaccinations before a Ninth Circuit judge interrupted him.Cutting off attorney Russell Davis’ argument the back pay claims was an “Occam’s razor,” U.S. Circuit Judge Ryan Nelson said “I think what I’m struggling with is, we seem to be getting the cart before the horse.”A separate Ninth Circuit panel found a lower court should not have denied the employees a preliminary injunction and reinstated the employee’s jobs.“Usually, an injunction does not go towards monetary damages, right? I mean, because that is not in equity. You can go and get that at the end of the day,” Nelson, a Donald Trump appointee, said.Davis countered that the lower court erred when it didn’t include the monetary relief.“The district court abused its discretion again by failing to order back pay with its order for reinstatement,” said Davis, arguing the back pay should be characterized as restitution, not damages.U.S. Circuit Judge Daniel Collins, also a Trump appointee, wasn’t convinced the issue couldn’t be rectified at the federal court level and noted the absence of a request in record that the back pay was one of the remedies.“As the district court said, it’s without prejudice,” said Collins. “Just bring the proper motion in the district court and then maybe you’ll get the relief, in light of what we’ve said about the merits and the prior appeals.”San Francisco Deputy City Attorney Adam Shapiro argued that the city and county wasn’t against the employees seeking back pay, only that it would have to be up to a jury to decide, as the back pay doesn’t address the harm the employees sued over.The employees’ religious discrimination case is ongoing. They say they were wrongfully denied a religious exemption from a 2021 mandate that all 35,000 city and county of San Francisco employees must receive a Covid-19 vaccination. Selina Keene, Melody Fountila, and one other employee first filed their complaint in March 2022, claiming the vaccines used stem cells harvested from aborted fetuses during the development process, and therefore contradicted their Christian beliefs against abortion.Shapiro said a trial over the merits of the employees’ Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 religious discrimination and Fair Employment and Housing Act claims was likely.Shapiro also noted that the employees were reinstated to their former positions, but they declined to take them.“The record, it’s a little convoluted,” he said. “One could argue they just flat out rejected taking their jobs back.”But Davis pushed back at the characterization of reinstatement, saying the language was “rehiring” at a lower income level without seniority status.Nelson asked if the lower court didn’t reinstate them to their former positions, why didn’t Davis point out to the lower court that it may have violated the injunction.“Kind of a big deal,” said Nelson. “You came up here to get relief you never asked for. So, anyway, you’ll have to go figure it out.”A federal judge initially rejected the employees’ lawsuit in September 2022, saying that the plaintiffs’ claims were not based on religious grounds but on “personal preference.” He said they disregarded scientific consensus about the efficacy of the vaccine and determined based on previous rulings they did not face irreparable harm from having to choose between the vaccine and their employment status.But the other Ninth Circuit panel said White made factual errors in his dismissal and did not properly weigh their individual rights against public interest.U.S. Circuit Judge Richard Paez, a Bill Clinton appointee, rounded out Wednesday’s panel.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.