NHS trusts record more than 3,000 incidents of staff snooping in patient records

NHS trusts record more than 3,000 incidents of staff snooping in patient records

More than 3,000 incidents of staff inappropriately accessing patient information have been recorded by NHS hospital and ambulance trusts in England in recent years, figures obtained by the Press Association show.The data covers a period that has seen a raft of high-profile cases of snooping by health service workers, including dozen of employees who looked at the medical records of the victims of attacks in Southport and Nottingham.Such incidents “erode trust” in the organisations involved and the wider NHS, with a “lack of transparency” deepening the damage, patient advocates said.NHS England chief executive Sir Jim Mackey described the figures as “extremely worrying” and said the health service “will not tolerate this behaviour”.There have been a number of high-profile cases of staff looking at the records of patients with no good reason, including the victims of the Southport attack, which left three children dead in July 2024 (James Speakman/PA)PA ArchiveThe findings are based on Freedom of Information requests PA submitted to 143 acute hospital and ambulance trusts in England.Some 79 trusts provided precise figures for incidents of staff inappropriately accessing patient records between 2021/22 and 2025/26 inclusive, which together totalled 3,029.But the actual number of incidents that took place will be higher as other trusts declined to provide exact data and instead said there had been “fewer than five” in a particular year, to avoid a risk of individuals being identified.Trusts must report breaches that could pose a risk to a patient’s rights to data protection regulator the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) within 72 hours.The ICO revealed last week that it has received more than 300 reports this year of staff looking at records with no good reason, inspecting records of people they know or sharing information with others.The regulator’s chief executive Paul Arnold wrote to hundreds of health leaders across the UK calling for an end to breaches.Mr Arnold said: “When we seek medical care, we trust the NHS with some of our most sensitive information and we need to be confident that only people with a legitimate reason will ever access our records.Read More“Looking at medical records out of curiosity is unacceptable and jeopardises the vital trust people place in the health service.“These figures are deeply concerning and I know how much distress this type of behaviour causes patients and families.“Recent incidents have shown that the culture and behaviours needed to protect patients have not been good enough, and that needs to change. Organisations need effective access controls, monitoring, training and consistent action when things go wrong.“Last week I wrote to health leaders across the UK asking for assurance on this. Where safeguards don’t work in practice, we expect organisations to put that right.”Recent examples of high-profile incidents include dozens of health workers who were found to have looked at the records of victims of the 2024 Southport attack, which left three girls dead and 10 others injured.A crackdown on staff inappropriately accessing patient records was launched by NHS England in September, with chief executive Sir Jim Mackey calling for any workers suspected of snooping to be immediately suspended (Peter Byrne/PA)PA ArchiveAt the time, Leanne Lucas, who was the instructor at the Taylor Swift-themed dance event and is one of the three adult survivors, said she was “devastated and horrified”.Elsewhere, 11 staff were dismissed and a further 14 had action taken against them at Nottingham University Hospitals Trust after they accessed the medical records of students Barnaby Webber and Grace O’Malley-Kumar, plus grandfather Ian Coates, who were stabbed to death by Valdo Calocane in 2023.The records of a three-year-old boy hurt after falling into a crocodile pit in Cambridgeshire in June were viewed by around 40 hospital staff while two workers at Yorkshire Ambulance Service are believed to have accessed or attempted to access the records of William Chapman after he was mauled to death by a tiger at Yorkshire Wildlife Park.In September, NHS England chief executive Sir Jim Mackey said he expected any workers suspected of accessing patient records inappropriately to be suspended immediately and have their access to online systems cut off.Days after launching the crackdown, 10 staff at East Suffolk and North Essex NHS Foundation Trust were suspended or removed from duty after a possible data breach of the medical records of three-year-old Noah Woods, who was found dead in a lake a day after going missing in Brantham, Suffolk.Sir Jim said: “These figures are extremely worrying and it’s completely unacceptable that any staff would risk betraying patient confidentiality in this way and causing harm to families in our care.“The NHS will not tolerate this behaviour – whether being done out of curiosity or to see their own notes or results, accessing a health record without a legitimate professional reason is never acceptable and is unlawful.“It is right that trusts are now proactively identifying and investigating this abhorrent behaviour – and our new guidance makes it crystal clear that staff face immediate suspension, as well as dismissal, if they are found to have accessed confidential patient information without an authorised reason.”Rachel Power, chief executive at the Patients Association, told the Press Association: “Patients share some of their most sensitive and personal information with the NHS, and they should be able to trust it will only be accessed when there is a legitimate reason to do so.“We are concerned by recent media reports alleging that staff at multiple trusts accessed the records of patients.“Cases like these erode trust, not only in the trust involved but in the wider NHS.“Lack of transparency deepens that damage, especially in the context of previous data breaches and leaks.“Patients need confidence that strong safeguards are in place, that inappropriate access will be detected and acted on without delay, and that they will be the first to know, not the last, when their confidentiality has been breached.”Of those trusts that responded to the Freedom of Information request with precise data, University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay had the highest number of incidents across the period 2021/22 to 2025/26, at 242.This was followed by West Suffolk with 213 and Northumbria Healthcare with 195.Anna Telfer, chief nursing officer at Morecambe Bay, said the trust has a “zero-tolerance approach” to breaches.A Northumbria Healthcare spokesperson said that in 2024, it introduced a system to proactively monitor access each month which has reduced the number of incidents.Matthew Hopkins, acute and ambulance network director at the NHS Alliance, said: “NHS staff work hard every day to protect confidential patient information and any misuse of records is a serious breach of trust.“Strong data governance is essential as digital technology becomes increasingly central to patient care. Any requirements around access controls, audit trails and monitoring must be achievable within current systems.“Maintaining public confidence in the use of patient data is crucial.”

Original Source

Read the full article at Standard →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.