Nexstar fights to salvage media merger with Tegna

Nexstar fights to salvage media merger with Tegna

A lower court blocked the proposed merger earlier this year, forbidding any corporate integration until a trial takes place.PASADENA, Calif. (CN) — Nexstar Media Group isn’t necessarily opposed to a judge temporarily stopping its proposed merger with Tegna, but it does want an existing nationwide injunction cut down to size.Attorney Deanne Maynard, representing Nexstar, told a Ninth Circuit panel Tuesday that DirecTV and states like California challenged only some 30 TV stations included in its proposed merger. However, a lower court earlier this year imposed a sweeping injunction, forbidding any corporate integration pending a trial on the merits.That trial is set for July 2027.“The other side has the burden to justify the preliminary injunction,” Maynard said. “District courts shouldn’t issue injunctions that are broader than the alleged harm.”The panel made no decision Tuesday and took the issue under submission.A key issue in the litigation is whether the Nexstar-Tegna merger would give Nexstar an oversized share of the market. Attorneys have argued that would cause higher prices for DirecTV and similar services, which would fall on consumers.They’ve argued that consolidating market share would violate the Clayton Act, which prohibits certain anticompetitive actions.Maynard said the injunction shouldn’t affect all stations. U.S. Circuit Judge Marsha Berzon, a Bill Clinton appointee, questioned how that would work.“There’s an integrated national corporation,” she added. “So, who’s holding it separate? It’s not an individual financial entity.”Maynard said the panel could remand the issue with instructions about the injunction.Pivoting to the issue of standing, Maynard said lower courts should only issue injunctions to people who have standing. Berzon suggested the panel need not immediately address that issue. U.S. District Judge Xavier Rodriguez — a Texas jurist and George W. Bush appointee, sitting by designation — said legal briefs had little information on standing.Arguing for California and other states, attorney Emily Curran said the panel could forgo ruling on standing. She only needed to show an antitrust injury existed.“We manifestly have that here,” she added.Curran asked the panel to view the injunction from the lower court’s perspective, with the evidence he had before him. That judge opted to pause the merger through the injunction until a trial on the merits occurred.U.S. Circuit Judge Johnnie Rawlinson, a Clinton appointee, noted that Maynard had called the injunction overbroad. Curran disputed that, arguing the remedy lay in restoring competition that was lost. The states provided evidence the injunction would restore it.“We met our burden to the extent we had one,” she said.Rodriguez questioned why the lower court couldn’t impose an injunction affecting only the challenged stations, like Maynard had suggested. Curran said no information exists on how that would work.“That’s a hypothetical entity that never has existed,” Curran added.Representing DirecTV, attorney Ben Horwich said the Clayton Act is focused on transactions that hurt competition in any line of commerce. He said his client opposes the proposed merger. However, Nexstar could refine its proposal, though it’s not DirecTV’s job to reshape a transaction that helps a competitor.Horwich argued that setting aside some of Nexstar’s stations in an altered injunction would create a separate entity or potentially orphan stations that would need a home. He favored the existing injunction, saying the lower court needed the discretion to impose it.“We want the competition we had before the illegal merger,” Horwich said.While Tuesday’s hearing focused on the injunction, the larger issue of the merger remains.DirecTV and several states involved in the suit have argued the merger would drive up prices and hurt local TV station newsrooms. In turn, Nexstar has said the merger would lower prices.Plaintiffs also have argued the merger would damage the quality of news from Nexstar stations. They say a merger may result in the news being broadcast for more hours, but it wouldn’t improve its quality.Additionally, they’ve said Nexstar has a history of consolidating newsrooms. That leads to journalists losing their jobs, a loss of different viewpoints and a shift from local news to more general content.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.