My Brother’s Girlfriend Broke the Cardinal Rule for a Wedding. She’s Blaming “Cultural Differences.”

My Brother’s Girlfriend Broke the Cardinal Rule for a Wedding. She’s Blaming “Cultural Differences.”

Dear Prudence She owes me an apology. Advice by Enter your email to receive alerts for this author. Sign in or create an account to better manage your email preferences. Unsubscribe from email alerts Are you sure you want to unsubscribe from email alerts for Jenée Desmond-Harris? I’ve served as Prudie since 2021. In my personal life, I’ve composed text messages about delicate situations for people aged 12 to 80 and have received excellent reviews. Nov 17, 20266:00 AM Photo illustration by Slate. Photos by Getty Images Plus. Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. Dear Prudence is Slate’s advice column. Submit questions here. Dear Prudence, I never thought I’d be the kind of bride whose wedding caused a ton of unnecessary family drama, but here we are. My brother has been dating the same girl for almost a year, and prior to my wedding, we didn’t have any issues and hung out one-on-one several times. She wasn’t one of my bridesmaids, so I didn’t see her and my brother until after the ceremony, and I was shocked by what I saw. She was wearing a white dress! It wasn’t the same shade of white as mine and was more of a cream color, but I was still horrified and angry. I didn’t confront her (as much as I would have loved to go all “Real Housewives” and throw a glass of red wine on her) but did confront my brother during the reception. He played dumb and said it “wasn’t even that white” and acted like I was being overdramatic. Even worse, he tried to justify her behavior by reminding me that she was born in another country with a culture that is pretty different from ours, and that not wearing white to a wedding just might not be a thing in her culture. I walked away and barely talked to either of them during the reception. It’s now two weeks after the wedding, and I believe I deserve an apology she refuses to give me. I texted her directly, and she said exactly what my brother had: that she didn’t know that wearing white to a wedding is a huge faux pas here and an insult to the bride. I called her out on this because she’s lived here since her early teens, watches reality TV, and has never done anything else indicating a lack of knowledge about etiquette here. I told her I thought she was lying about her ignorance (she’s very attractive and loves attention, which I think is probably why she wore it), but that if she was going to lie, she at least needed to apologize for making a mistake and embarrassing me on such an important day. I’ve continued to talk to my brother about this, but he thinks I need to drop it (I think he’s being a coward who doesn’t want to upset her). Any ideas about how to move forward? I don’t want this to ruin my relationship with my brother (I don’t even care about my relationship with her at this point), but I don’t know how to make him realize what a big deal this is to me. Please help! —Dress Drama Dear Dress Drama, Join the club! Someone wore a white dress to my wedding, too. I actually think the rule against doing this is not as universally known and embraced as it once was. And I am buying the lack of cultural familiarity excuse a little more than you are. Now, that said, a kind and reasonable person who was called out for making this faux pas would be happy to say, “Oh no, I’m so sorry I wasn’t aware. How embarrassing,” and the fact that your brother’s girlfriend wouldn’t do that doesn’t reflect very well on her. I can’t say I understand what her goal could have possibly been when she chose a white dress. If she’s very attractive, she would be very attractive in any color. It’s not as if wearing white meant people actually thought she was the bride and sent her to the middle of the dance floor to do a first dance with all eyes on her. And hot pink could have also elicited extra attention, if that’s what she was after! Her response to your complaint does suggest an “I do whatever I want and I don’t care about how it affects others” mentality. It’s perfectly reasonable to put a note in your mental HR file about her and conclude that she failed to meet expectations when it comes to being gracious. You can use this information to decide how you want to interact with her going forward—for example, maybe you don’t want to be a bridesmaid for her if, God forbid, she and your brother get married, and she asks. Maybe you’ll pass on family trips that would include spending a lot of time with her. And if you’re the person in the family who coordinates holiday pajamas or outfits for photo shoots, mentally prepare for her to refuse to get with the program. But then close the file and move on with your life, because obsessing over this is taking away from your enjoyment of what should be a happy time in your life! If the worst interpretation of her behavior—that she was determined to take away from your special moment—is accurate, you’re absolutely letting her win. Please keep questions short (<150 words), and don’t submit the same question to multiple columns. We are unable to edit or remove questions after publication. Use pseudonyms to maintain anonymity. Your submission may be used in other Slate advice columns and may be edited for publication. Dear Prudence, I am a gay man who grew up in an intolerant religious family and spent years denying who I really was, even going so far as to convince myself that I would get “better” if I married a woman. I had been married to “Nina” for three years before I met “Rick” and realized I could no longer live a lie. Rick and I had been seeing each other for six months before I finally sat Nina down and told her the truth. She burst into tears, windmilled me, and said she never wanted to see me again. We quickly divorced and went our separate ways. Fast forward 24 years. Rick and I have built a wonderful life and family (two kids conceived via surrogate). However, my 19-year-old daughter recently took one of those DNA tests and learned online that she has a half-brother. She checked, and it turns out he is the son of my ex-wife. The timing of his birth means that Nina was pregnant with him while the divorce was being finalized and never told me. Rick and the kids have been incredibly understanding, but I feel completely betrayed by my ex. I would have definitely been there for my son had I known about him. The question I have is whether or not I should reach out to him. As far as I know, he is not aware of his half-siblings or me. If my daughter discovered him via that DNA test, it’s not unreasonable to think he might take one himself one day and wonder why I “abandoned” him. We’re all trying to decide what the right course of action is. Thoughts? —Surprise SonDear Surprise Son, I realize you can’t just flip a switch to turn off feelings of betrayal and anger, but I think it would be wise to do all you can to at least turn down the volume on these emotions before attempting to make contact. There are going to be plenty of strong feelings when, and if, you meet your biological son, and if yours are dominated by being angry at his mom, that’s going to get in the way of your ability to connect with him. In fact, you should wait until—through therapy, having had time to process everything, or exploring the experiences of others who have been connected with children they didn’t know existed—you feel like you want to meet your son. Not that you should, or that you need to do it to defend yourself against any possible claim of abandonment, but that you’d actually like to get to know him. I’m glad your family is so supportive. They obviously care about you. Ask them to weigh in on whether they think you’re in a good place to reach out. Prudie Wants to Hear From You! Readers often have great suggestions for our letter writers, occasionally disagree with a point Prudie makes, or simply want to provide some additional advice. Each week, Prudie will be replying to some of these comments and suggestions from readers, which will be featured on the site on Fridays for Slate Plus members. Write to us! Or submit a question here. Dear Prudence, I’m an early bird at work and usually arrive just before a member of the food services team arrives to set out the morning snacks each day. They have to leave their cart on the landing and carry everything down five steps. Other staff who arrive while this is happening often help, carrying food and coffee down the stairs. I am generally rather clumsy and took a fall down some stairs two years ago and hurt my leg pretty badly. I’ve mostly recovered, but am more cautious on stairs than ever, and especially never walk down them with full hands. What I’m saying is: I am not the right person to help with this task. But it makes me feel like an asshole! I regularly express my gratitude for their work and chat and ask after their families, but it still feels rude not to help. Am I overthinking this, or should I explain why I don’t help? —Stairs Are Not My Strong Suit Dear Stairs Are Not My Strong Suit, Go ahead and explain it. Although I doubt the food services employee is wondering why you aren’t stepping in to help with their job, you’ll feel much better and save yourself stress every morning if you clear the air. Why don’t you pair the announcement with a nice gesture, like a small holiday gift—a bag of cookies or something similar—as physical evidence of your generosity? This is appropriate since you two already have a friendly relationship. At the end of that exchange, say something like, “I have been meaning to tell you, every day I wish I could help you out as you set up the morning snacks. But I fell down some stairs and hurt my knee a while ago, and now I’m afraid to walk downstairs carrying stuff. It makes me feel like an asshole!” They will probably say, “Oh, don’t even worry about it!” and you can respond, “OK, I was probably overthinking. But it’s always great to chat with you. I hope you like the cookies, and I’ll see you in the new year!” Classic Prudie We got married about 3½ years ago. We shared our wedding photographer’s picture files with our family. My grandmother-in-law misplaced the files and instead of asking for help ended up printing off two that she took at the wedding. One of them is lovely, and it’s sweet, as she took the picture. The other is of the bridal party at the ceremony. It is an OK but not great picture, and to be honest is not the most flattering one of me… Advice Dear Prudence Family Weddings

Original Source

Read the full article at Slate →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.