Most zoning laws could be scrapped with no bad consequences

Most zoning laws could be scrapped with no bad consequences

It’s hard for some people to imagine an America without zoning laws, but that doesn’t mean zoning laws are good or necessary.For the first 150 years of our country, towns, cities, and counties were very limited in their ability to do zoning, so property owners had more rights. Then in 1926, the Supreme Court ruled in Village of Euclid v. Amber Realty Company that states had the right to regulate private land use for the sake of preventing potential nuisances, and that states could delegate those powers to local governments.Washington Examiner editor Joe Lawler has an essay at The New Atlantis about what has happened in the century since: “Downtown commercial districts that empty out in the evenings, industrial areas far from population centers, family homes surrounded by nothing but other houses in developments with no nearby access to anything — no grocery stores or shops, no places of work or entertainment, no restaurants, day cares, or public parks: These are the distinguishing characteristics of the American urban form.”Throughout the essay, Lawler raises many problems with 21st-century zoning laws around the country: They infringe on the right to property, they make the landscape uglier, they weaken community bonds, and they make us more dependent on cars.So what’s the alternative? What about getting rid of zoning, or at least most zoning?Most Americans would probably object to this idea pretty vociferously, imagining an ore-smelting plant next to their suburban house or a skyscraper on the corner. What’s to stop one landowner from just destroying a neighborhood, then?If you are arguing for stricter rules and your argument begins with the words “what’s to stop…,” you are very likely to make a bad argument.After the Supreme Court ruled in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores that the owners of a small family business deserved religious-liberty protections, liberals asked, What’s to stop Exxon from declaring itself Jehovah’s Witness and claiming all health insurance violates their religion? During COVID-10, lockdowners justified every lockdown and opposed every exemption based on “what’s to stop” reasoning.The answer is often “the market will stop it.”For instance, what’s to stop someone from building a massive apartment building in your small town? Well, the lack of demand for a bunch of apartments in a small town, for one thing. If you worry that those apartments will all be subsidized, low-income housing, then your problem is with the low-income subsidies, and you should fight those.And that’s where Lawler’s essay is helpful. He points out that localities and landowners have many tools with which to ward off serious nuisances.First, you could ban and punish the worst effects of mixing industry and housing. For instance, a state or town could keep factories from stinking up a family’s yard with laws that make it illegal to stink up someone’s property with factory fumes.WALKABILITY, BUT FOR CHILDRENLawler points out that property owners, through contracts and lawsuits, can address some problems:“One example is neighborhood covenants, or restrictions on the use of a property included in the deed when sold. A covenant might restrict the land from being redeveloped as a giant apartment building. Through the use of such covenants, neighborhoods can protect their character without imposing rules on the entire city or town. Another example is the use of private nuisance lawsuits — that is, families and individuals, rather than the government, suing over noise, smells, or dangers imposed on a property. Homeowners’ associations, or HOAs, also restrict the use of property, and now govern a majority of newly built homes.”In other words, zoning is one tool for preserving and shaping neighborhoods. It has lots of negative consequences while preventing many bad things. If we use a different tool to prevent those bad things, we might see far fewer negative consequences.

Original Source

Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.