Missouri presses Eighth Circuit for fresh chance to roast Starbucks over DEI

Missouri presses Eighth Circuit for fresh chance to roast Starbucks over DEI

One appellate judge questioned whether the state was just targeting a company for being "woke" without evidence of an injury.(CN) — Missouri dueled with Starbucks before Eighth Circuit judges Tuesday over whether the state can sue the coffee giant for its diversity, equity and inclusion employment practices.Attempting to reverse a dismissal order, the Show Me State argues upholding the lower court judgment would “cripple” states’ ability to bring federal race discrimination claims against organizations.“Starbucks has made hiring and promoting decisions across the state based on racial quotas,” Missouri’s attorney, Louis Capozzi, said. “Being unable to compete for jobs or job opportunities because of race is a cognizable injury.”Meanwhile, the nation’s largest coffee chain — which employs roughly 225,000 U.S. workers — says Missouri has no case and relies merely on “unsupported speculation.”“It is unique to have a case filed without any investigation whatsoever,” Starbucks’ attorney, James Bennett, said. “No complaints were made to the attorney general, no references to specific instances of people.”That reasoning is what led U.S. District Judge John A. Ross to dismiss Missouri’s complaint in February, finding the state lacked standing to sue on behalf of its citizens under the parens patriae**doctrine.The Barack Obama appointee found the state attempted to mount an abstract, generalized challenge against a company’s internal initiatives without identifying an injury to “even a single Missouri resident.”That challenge was launched in February 2025, when Missouri sued the coffee chain over its commitment to DEI — beginning with a 2020 company announcement after the killing of George Floyd — which the state claims Starbucks uses as a pretext to discriminate based on race, gender and sexual orientation.State officials accuse Starbucks of tying executive pay to racial and gender-based quotas, singling out preferred groups for promotions and employing a system to ensure an ethnically diverse board of directors.In doing so, the state claims Missouri employees, job applicants and consumers are harmed — adding that selecting employees based on DEI goals over merit skews the workforce and drives up costs and wait times.Starbucks disputes Missouri’s characterization of its policies, noting the referenced diversity targets, which have largely expired, were strictly “aspirational,” and that bonus structures did not penalize managers based on demographic metrics.The Eighth Circuit panel appeared to favor Ross’ dismissal ruling Tuesday, with U.S. Circuit Judge Daniel Traynor leading a pointed attack against Missouri’s legal strategy.“Was the attorney general just looking around for a company to target and say ‘you’re woke, or DEI, and we’re going to take you to court’?” the Donald Trump appointee said.Bennett later echoed Traynor’s comment.“There are no allegations,” Bennett said. “I would characterize this complaint as asserting essentially that there’s some unknown citizen at an unknown location who’s had some unknown adverse employment action happening to them.”Missouri noted it doesn’t need to assert specific injuries at the motion to dismiss stage, when even generalized pleadings are taken in a light most favorable to the suing party.“We do specifically allege that many individuals throughout the state were denied jobs or denied promotions, we don’t need to have that evidence at the pleading stage,” Capozzi said. He added the state should be able to halt policies that stop just short of explicitly barring candidates based on race.“This is open, obvious and egregious discrimination, and if this doesn’t state a Title VII claim, it’s really hard to know what would,” he said.Bennett fired back at that notion, arguing that allowing states to exercise full legal power on behalf of their citizens without any prior investigation establishes a risky precedent.“The state AG apparently has the right to file in federal court without going through any of the procedures,” Bennett said. “They’re asking the court to grant it the power to come in and enforce federal laws much broader and without any of the process that Congress has put in there.”Despite appearing largely skeptical of Missouri’s argument, Traynor noted the state would typically obtain a large amount of evidence about Starbucks’ policies in discovery, after the pleadings stage.Twenty states, including Florida and Texas, filed amicus briefs in support of Missouri, arguing a state’s ability to protect its citizens from “widespread discrimination” is an honorable legal pursuit.In a settlement in September, Starbucks agreed to pay Florida $1 million and suspend race- and gender-based goals and preferences in the state — though the agreement included no admission of wrongdoing by the company and fell well short of the initial $100 billion the state sought.Missouri’s suit aligns with the second Trump administration’s broader push to roll back corporate and academic DEI initiatives. Tuesday’s hearing also comes just a day after the U.S. Supreme Court let stand a ruling blocking Trump’s cuts to DEI research grants.U.S. Circuit Judge Steven Grasz and U.S. Circuit Judge Ralph Erickson, both Donald Trump appointees, rounded out the Eighth Circuit panel.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.