Minnesota fends off anti-abortion activists at Eighth Circuit

Minnesota fends off anti-abortion activists at Eighth Circuit

State officials say the anti-abortion coalition is misusing the courts to push for stricter abortion laws with no legal basis.MINNEAPOLIS (CN) — Anti-abortion clinics and doctors told an Eighth Circuit panel Wednesday Minnesota’s abortion laws terminate parental rights without due process and must be completely overhauled.Arguing against a lower court’s dismissal order, the anti-abortion coalition claims the state’s framework violates 14th Amendment protections against involuntary operations and allows private clinics and doctors to take action typically handled through strict court procedures.“The Minnesota Constitution requires officials of the state to delegate, empower, license and protect doctors and nurses to terminate a pregnant mother’s existing relationship with her child by killing her child,” the coalition’s attorney, Harold Cassidy, said. “Even deliberatively involuntary terminations and killing of the child is allowed. The prohibition of it is forbidden.”The coalition, including the Women’s Life Care Center and the National Institute of Family and Life Advocates, urged the appellate panel to not only reverse dismissal, but grant an immediate injunction — contending Minnesota’s abortion laws unconstitutionally deny mothers equal protection and exempt abortion providers from state fetal murder statutes.“The killing of any child after conception is murder, punishable by mandatory life imprisonment,” Cassidy said.State officials and abortion providers, meanwhile, argue the court can dismiss on jurisdictional and statutory grounds without reaching the merits of appellants’ “novel” constitutional claims.“You can’t sue the government just because you want new or different laws,” Margaret Jacot, Minnesota’s attorney, said. “They’re unhappy because Minnesota hasn’t passed the restrictive abortion laws that other states like South Dakota have.”U.S. District Judge Nancy Brasel, who dismissed the coalition’s suit last year, agreed — finding neither the individual doctors nor the pregnancy help centers had standing to challenge Minnesota’s abortion laws.The Donald Trump appointee determined the group’s claims of resource diversion, abortion pill reversal treatments and harm to their overall mission and reputation were too insufficient to demonstrate an injury — though Cassidy told the Eighth Circuit that finding is “absolutely incorrect.”“Every single day, the pregnancy help centers get out of bed to go to help women keep their children. That’s all they exist for,” Cassidy said. “The biggest thing that prevents them from seeing through on their mission is the abortion laws … they have to ward off the pressure that these women are being subjected to.”U.S. Circuit Judge Jane Kelly, a Barack Obama appointee, appeared puzzled at the notion that Minnesota was somehow pressuring women and mothers to have abortions rather than simply providing the choice.The anti-abortion group initially sued the state in November 2024 in a 241-page complaint consisting of constitutional arguments, historical comparisons to adoption and child protection laws, accounts from former clinic workers and personal stories from three women who say they were coerced into unwanted abortions.The coalition targets state officials, including Minnesota Governor Tim Walz and Attorney General Keith Ellison, claiming they work in collaboration with abortion providers to promote and protect abortion access while discouraging pregnancy help centers.Minnesota has some of the strongest abortion protections in the country. State laws establish that every pregnant individual has a fundamental right to obtain an abortion without mandatory counseling, waiting periods or a statutory cut-off date.Those laws reflect a landmark 1995 Minnesota Supreme Court ruling that held Minnesota’s constitutional right to privacy encompasses an individual’s right to terminate their pregnancy.While the lower court determined state officials cannot be liable for abortions because Minnesota does not itself provide them, the appellants insist that’s not the case.“Of course the state doesn’t do it that way because it would be unconstitutional,” Cassidy said. “But the state can delegate to a private entity a method of termination."The state flipped Cassidy’s argument on its head, noting that very delegation and “inaction” renders the entire complaint meritless.“Appellants haven’t alleged that they’ve had abortions, they don’t allege they’re forced by state law to provide abortions, they don’t allege that state law imposes any obligation or restriction on them,” Jacot said. “Instead, their alleged harm is because the law doesn’t prohibit others from providing abortions.”Jacot added the state of Minnesota “took itself out of the abortion process” — choosing instead to leave such decisions up to individual and private actors, which providers say is perfectly legal.“Plaintiffs’ boundless theory would subject essentially all sorts of private actors to constitutional liability,” Simon Anthony De Carvalho, attorney for Planned Parenthood and other providers, said.Ending the argument, Cassidy claimed 21,000 women received abortions since the coalition filed its preliminary injunction in April 2025, and that it would be “naive” to say each and every one of them walked into abortion clinics “freely informed and totally voluntary.”U.S. Circuit Judges Steven Colloton and Bobby Shepherd, both George W. Bush appointees, rounded out the Eighth Circuit panel.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.