Minnesota county asks judge to trash petition over toxic incinerator ash

Minnesota county asks judge to trash petition over toxic incinerator ash

An environmental group claims the county has been inactive on ash mitigation and must clearly state strategies to meet reduced toxicity in its waste plan.MINNEAPOLIS (CN) — Minnesota’s most populous county urged a state judge Tuesday to dismiss an environmental advocacy group’s lawsuit over a controversial Twin Cities waste incinerator.While the plant’s future remains a flashpoint for residents and county officials, Tuesday’s arguments hinged on whether the county’s solid waste plan actually addresses incinerator ash, and whether environmental advocates have legal standing to force the issue through a mandamus petition.The Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy, a nonprofit that petitioned the court in July, claims it does, noting a clear link between how the county frames its policy and public trust in oversight.“If you’re a member of the public, you should be able to read the county’s plan and understand how it plans to meet those goals,” the group’s attorney Luke Norquist said. “If the county is not talking about these goals, it raises the possibility that it’s not attempting to address these goals.”Hennepin County, which includes Minneapolis and its surrounding suburbs, maintains the group’s underlying motivation is a political pressure tactic to force the county board to reopen its waste plan and examine environmental impact and potential plant closure.“The relief petitioner seeks is a language change to the plan. Different language would not lessen their environmental work,” Hennepin County attorney Brittany McCormick said. “Petitioner is not here to correct a wrong, but to impose its understanding of an intellectually complex county process.”Hennepin County Judge Michael Browne pushed back on the notion that a change of language would have no effect, noting the advocates argue phrasing directly shapes public understanding of how ash is managed.The downtown Minneapolis waste incinerator — called the Hennepin Energy Recovery Center — turns around 365,000 tons of municipal trash into roughly 80,000 tons of toxic incinerator ash every year, according to advocates.Ash generated at the plant contains significant levels of lead, mercury and other contaminants that pose a threat to the environment and human health, including pregnancy-related harms and cancer risk.Because of this, Minnesota law requires counties to clearly state plans to meet reduced toxicity and quantity of incinerator ash in their solid waste management plans, which advocates claim Hennepin County has omitted.“The county’s plans violate the plain language of the statute, and as far as the public can tell, the county does not appear to be accounting for the ash goals at all,” Norquist said.He added no solid waste plan in the county for at least 14 years has clearly stated how it will reduce incinerator ash toxicity despite community and legislative pressure.“At a minimum, the government needs to say what those goals are and connect and tell the public as to how it’s satisfying the goals,” Norquist said. “It’s that connection that is missing.”The county, however, notes it includes extensive pages detailing mitigation strategies in the plan, including a focus on upstream methods and other waste reduction programs such as removing metals and managing volumes, rather than singling out incinerator ash.McCormick further argued the advocacy group is misusing a mandamus petition — an extraordinary court order with a high bar to meet — to force a political and policy debate.“Opening the door to further discussion is not a basis for mandamus,” she said. “Influencing policy is not a basis for mandamus.”Because mandamus petitions are actions of last resort, the county notes advocates chose to wait until the administrative deadline to challenge the plan passed before petitioning the court.Brushing aside arguments about what could have been done in the past, Browne zeroed in on the immediate reality of the hearing.“Isn’t that what we’re doing now though?” he said. “Aren’t we doing judicial review anyway?”The county also argues the center’s “injury” — spending staff time and resources researching and answering member questions about the incinerator — is not a legal harm that leads to mandamus, though the group claims its harms exceed that.“There’s a clear failure in following state law,” Norquist said. “We think that the county has been inactive on this and there is a lot of room for improvement.”Tuesday’s hearing is the most recent step in a long fight against the incinerator, with clashes between environmentalists and officials dating back years.In an October report, the Zero Burn Coalition claimed county officials were surveilling a group of community activists who’ve been pushing for years to shut down the incinerator.As the suit awaits a dismissal ruling, the city of Minneapolis has already requested the waste incinerator be shut down by the end of 2027 because of pollution concerns.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.