Michigan coal plant kept open by 7th order; groups estimate $600k daily cost

Michigan coal plant kept open by 7th order; groups estimate $600k daily cost

A Michigan coal plant scheduled to shut down remains open under a seventh federal emergency order despite an appeals court ruling; environmental groups estimate the extensions cost families over $600,000 a day/Image: APA 64-year-old coal-fired power plant near Grand Rapids, Michigan, will continue operating under a fresh federal emergency order, extending its life beyond the planned retirement date despite a court ruling against the administration's earlier actions.Energy Secretary Chris Wright issued the latest directive late Friday, requiring the J.H. Campbell Generating Plant to remain operational. The department said the facility was needed to protect electricity supplies and reduce the risk of blackouts.The extension is the seventh emergency order issued for the plant since May 2025. Environmental groups have challenged the repeated interventions, estimating that keeping the facility running costs Midwest households more than $600,000 every day, according to AP.Court ruling challenges federal interventionThe latest order follows a September decision by a three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, which sided with environmental organisations and several states challenging the administration's directives.The court found that the government had not demonstrated an actual emergency under the law to justify keeping the plants operational. The ruling set aside the administration's previous actions as unlawful.The Energy Department has disputed the decision and petitioned for a rehearing before the full appeals court. A decision on whether the case will be reconsidered by the wider bench remains pending, with a possible appeal to the Supreme Court.Michigan, Illinois and Minnesota were among the states that joined environmental groups in challenging the orders.Despite the legal dispute, Wright has maintained that the Campbell facility and other coal-fired plants are necessary to protect electricity reliability. The administration has relied on emergency powers to prevent their scheduled closures.Environmental groups raise concerns over costsThe latest extension has drawn criticism from environmental organisations, which argue that the government has not demonstrated that the Michigan plant is needed to prevent a power shortage or has helped avert an outage.The Sierra Club estimates that keeping the facility operational adds more than $600,000 a day to costs borne by electricity customers across the Midwest.Its Burning Money tracker puts the total cost of federal orders extending the operating lives of fossil fuel plants in six states at more than $600 million. More than half of that amount is attributed to the Campbell plant in Michigan.Jessi Eidbo of the Sierra Club criticised the latest directive, saying: “At a time when prices are soaring and Americans are struggling to make ends meet, the Trump administration’s decision to issue yet another illegal and expensive extension is punishing.”Ted Kelly, director of US clean energy at the Environmental Defense Fund, also questioned the decision.“Instead of saving families’ money and letting the plant retire as planned, the Trump administration keeps putting its thumb on the scale for costly coal,” Kelly said.Trump administration continues push to support coal industryThe extension forms part of President Donald Trump's broader efforts to revive the US coal sector and maintain coal-fired electricity generation.In June, the administration announced plans to spend nearly $700 million supporting coal-fired power plants and coal exports. The Environmental Protection Agency has also repealed regulations limiting greenhouse gas emissions from coal- and gas-powered facilities.The agency, led by Administrator Lee Zeldin, is also seeking to restrict the ability of future administrations to regulate climate pollution from power plants.Wright has defended the use of emergency orders, arguing that keeping certain facilities operational is necessary to maintain a reliable electricity supply. Environmental groups and state governments, however, continue to challenge the legal basis and financial implications of those decisions.The dispute over the Campbell plant remains unresolved as the full appeals court considers whether to take up the case.

Original Source

Read the full article at Timesofindia →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.