Mary Beth Barone’s Dating History Is a Pretty Wild Ride

Mary Beth Barone is not only an It Girl but a multihyphenate in her own right. She hosts the Ride podcast with her longtime best friend, Benito Skinner, and stars on his Prime Video series, Overcompensating. But before all of that, she made a name for herself in the world of stand-up comedy by joking about her trials and tribulations in dating.Now that her stand-up special Galaxy Brain is on Netflix, she might sneak a punchline or two about some unnamed questionable men in there. If you’re a certified Baronie waiting for a new stepdad to treat Mother Mary as the queen she is, it’s the perfect time to brush up and scroll through her rumored (and confirmed!) romances over the years.Edward Bluemel: 2021–2024Roy Rochlin//Getty ImagesMBB was romantically linked to English actor Edward Bluemel, who you may recognize from projects like Killing Eve and My Lady Jane, for three years. Their relationship was documented during a 2021 interview with The Independent promoting Mary Beth’s comedy special, Drag His Ass, which confirmed she was “currently staying with her boyfriend, the Killing Eve star and bonafide not-fuckboy Edward Bluemel” in London.Mary Beth and Edward went on to make a few public appearances together over the years, including the 2023 Cartier Queen’s Cup Polo in the U.K. and several screenings for My Lady Jane.They quietly split in 2024, but they’re still on good terms. She even brought him in as a guest on Ride to discuss their breakup, which they claim went down because they were “the worst couple of all time” while navigating a long-distance relationship.Adam DiMarco: 2025Phillip Faraone//Getty ImagesEven before they played on-screen lovers in Overcompensating, fans immediately clocked the chemistry between Mary Beth and Adam DiMarco...especially after Mary Beth alluded to having a new love interest during a February 2025 episode of Ride (plus some reported sightings on Reddit of MBB and Adam together).However! While their real-life connection was never confirmed, the comedian announced she was newly single during a July 2025 appearance on Late Night With Seth Meyers...and fans were quick to speculate that the split was from Adam.Without dropping names, she shared that the recent split had thrown her for a loop, saying, “Yeah, it’s crazy when someone is deeply in love with you and then they’re just like, ‘Actually, I changed my mind.’”Add Cosmopolitan as a preferred source in your Google search results.Use your Google account to add this to your settings.Moving on!Lucas Bravo: 2026New York Knicks//InstagramBaronies were stoked to learn that they might have a new stepdad when Mary Beth and Emily in Paris star Lucas Bravo first sparked dating rumors at a New York Knicks game in March 2026. The NBA champions’ official account snuck a pic of the pair in a photo dump, which prompted Mary Beth’s Ride cohost and bestie, Benito Skinner, to comment a heart-eyes emoji.What’s more: They seemed to soft-launch during the Cannes Film Festival on May 13, when DeuxMoi tipsters claimed they were “quite the unexpected pair” and were caught “making out” at an after-party for his film, La Vénus Electrique. Neither of them publicly acknowledged the reports, but it seems like whatever fling they had going on came to an end. Which brings us to MBB’s most recent sighting with…KJ Apa: 2026Okay, take this with a grain of salt, because it hasn’t necessarily been confirmed. According to another DeuxMoi tipster, Mary Beth and KJ were “seemingly on a date” at Cafe Collette in Williamsburg, Brooklyn on Friday, July 24.The nature of their connection—or, if there even is one—is unclear, but the Baronies at Cosmo HQ are definitely keeping track to see what happens next.