A man who struck a Belfast teenager who later died has said he had been “terrified” after “repeated threats to his life” and felt he had “no other option” to defend himself.Conor Erskine said Fionntán McGarvey glared at him and told him he was going to kill him several times outside the Devenish Complex in the Finaghy Road North area in the early hours of December 27 2021.He said he reacted after seeing a “micro movement” of Mr McGarvey’s shoulder and swung up his right hand, “semi-open handed”, to “swipe” him after which Mr McGarvey fell to the ground.Mr Erskine said he knew Mr McGarvey but had never had a negative interaction with him before.Fionntan McGarvey (Family handout/PA)PA MediaThe 18-year-old Queen’s University student died more than three weeks after the incident.An inquest into his death, which opened at Belfast Coroner’s Court on Monday, also heard from a detective that some theories were put forward but no cause for the tension was ever confirmed.Mr McGarvey, who was a talented sportsman, sustained a fractured skull and blood clot on the surface of his brain.He was discharged from hospital eight days after the incident but suffered a bleed on the brain a week later.His condition rapidly deteriorated and he died in hospital 24 days after the initial altercation.On the first day of the inquest, coroner Louisa Fee heard from several witnesses who were outside the bar when Mr McGarvey was struck by Mr Erskine after a verbal exchange between the two men.On Wednesday, Mr Erskine gave evidence to the inquest, appearing by videolink from Australia.He said he had been 21 at the time of the incident and knew Mr McGarvey as someone he had gone to school with, and had mutual friends with, adding they would have had “passing conversation” when meeting.He said that on December 26 2021 he had attended the Down Royal Races with friends during the day before going to the Devenish that night, and had been drinking alcohol throughout.Answering questions from counsel to the coroner Ian Skelt KC, Mr Erskine said there had been no arguments, and described being drunk in a “giddy way… a good buzz”.He said he had not been aware of Mr McGarvey at the bar until the younger man approached him “aggressively” at the door as he stood with friends in the early hours of December 27.Read More“He was staring at me, and then he said, ‘I’m going to kick your c*** in’. I was a bit taken aback, he repeated it, and I said. ‘We’re not doing that’,” he told the inquest.“He was saying, ‘I’m going to f****** kill you and stuff like that’. I felt terrified, sort of like a deer in headlights, didn’t know what to do, just trying to calm him.”Mr Erskine said Mr McGarvey went away for a few minutes before returning.“He was staring at me, his eyes, couldn’t get them off me, wasn’t blinking, he kept saying the same things except more aggressively, he seemed very tense, he was saying, ‘I’m going to f****** kill you’, ‘I’m going to kick your c*** in’, ‘I’m going to kick the f*** out of you’, and kept repeating these phrases over and over again… there was no talking to him,” he said.“I kept saying, ‘We’re not doing this, we’re friends, we’re not fighting’, but every time he would just stare at me and say something else again… nothing was going into his head, he was fixated on me.“I have no explanation at all why he picked me out that night.”The inquest saw CCTV footage of the two walking away from the door followed by a group of people behind.Mr Skelt put to him that a witness described seeing him take off his jacket and waistcoat before they walked towards the nearby railway halt.Mr Erskine said he offered to talk to Mr McGarvey away from crowds of people at the door to “defuse the situation” and “get away from the pressure of all the people watching”.The inquest heard that during one of Mr Erskine’s police interviews he described taking off his waistcoat and jacket because he “was panicking, I felt like I was being choked because I was getting really hot and really sweaty and just scared and just took them off”.Asked if he accepted he struck Mr McGarvey, Mr Erskine said yes.“I saw an incoming threat, and with the threats made before, I was fearful for my life, so instinctively I reacted and threw my arm up,” he said.Asked to demonstrate how this happened, Mr Erskine stood up with his arms by his side and made up upward movement with his right arm.“There was no thought behind it, no power, almost like swiping up to knock him away… from my blow I didn’t think there was so much power in it as to cause damage, so what has happened since then was a shock to that… it was the floor that did the damage when he went down,” he said.“I didn’t feel my blow was too heavy as to cause injury… everything happened so fast, I just remember him being on the floor and going down to help him.”In another excerpt from a police statement read the inquest, Mr Erskine said: “There was no response, I was like, ‘Shit, what’s happened here’, I put my hands around him and saw blood, and that’s when I was like, ‘Oh shit, something’s really happened here’, so that’s when I started shouting for people, then I felt for his pulse to just see if he was still alive, and I felt a strong pulse.”He added: “It was never my intention to go out that night and swing, it was the fact he kept coming back, he put me in a situation where I feared for my life, and I felt like there was nothing else I could do.”Eugene McKenna, acting for the McGarvey family, asked Mr Erskine if he had “lost control”, to which he replied: “No, I feel like the stress I was put under from someone threatening my life multiple times, I seen something I thought was going to do me harm and the only option I had was to protect myself.”Mr McKenna asked if, in his police interview, he said he feared for his life, or felt terrified, to which Mr Erskine replied: “I didn’t use those words, no… I said in there in case he attacked me from behind, I feel like that’s sort of insinuated that someone’s threatened your life.”Mr McKenna asked why Mr Erskine had not walked away.He responded: “I didn’t feel like I had a choice to walk away after repeated interactions. What’s to stop him coming back a third time when I’m not looking, walking home?”The inquest also heard from a detective chief inspector who initially led the investigation.He said they officers been unable to get CCTV footage from Translink from the railway halt. He also said they interviewed witnesses who advanced a number of theories for the tension, but police had not been able to clarify the reasons.At the end of the day’s proceedings Ms Fee addressed Mr McGarvey’s parents, saying she appreciated it had been an “extraordinarily difficult day” for the family.“I wish to acknowledge the dignity and courage with which you have sat through this morning’s evidence and I thank you very much for that,” she added.
Man who hit teenager who later died ‘had no other option to defend myself’
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Standard →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.