A 75-year-old former registered sex offender arranged to have a child via surrogacy and is now appealing a ruling denying him custody, exposing the many dangers of the commodification of pregnancy. In November 2025, a male infant was born in Rockwall County, Texas. His biological father is Sanford S. Kaplan, who lives in Colorado. Kaplan had pleaded no contest in 2009 in Nebraska to seven counts of child abuse and one count of false imprisonment involving multiple adolescent boys and was sentenced to consecutive terms totaling up to 24 years. He had served roughly seven years in prison, completed parole in 2021, and (at the time) remained on the sex-offender registry. Contemporary news accounts described the offenses as involving binding, blindfolding, gagging, and suspending boys from rafters in a garage at his Lincoln home while he was a youth soccer coach. Kaplan had arranged a gestational surrogacy with a young woman (“SM”). SM carried a child conceived with a donor egg and Kaplan’s sperm. The arrangement was formalized in a February 2025 agreement. In July 2025, the two jointly asked a Travis County district court to approve the agreement under Texas law and to skip the normal home-study requirement used to assess the intended parents’ home for the child’s safety. The court entered an order approving the arrangement in August 2025. This preliminary order declared Kaplan would “be the legal father” and would have the right to “immediate custody” of and access to the child “upon birth,” the right to name the child, and the right to make any and all health decisions regarding the child. Only the intervention of the hospital where the birth was expected, followed by the Department of Family and Protective Services, stopped Kaplan from taking immediate custody once the baby was born in November. A jury later terminated his parental rights. Kaplan has appealed. The case is a stark illustration of the risks inherent in commercial and quasi-commercial surrogacy arrangements — risks that advocacy groups such as Surrogacy Concern have long highlighted: the prioritization of adult desire over child welfare, the commodification of pregnancy, the enabling of single older men, and the structural incentives that discourage anyone in the transaction from raising red flags. Statute Bypassed, Criminal History Obscured Texas law has required since 2003 that intended parents under a gestational agreement be married to each other. An unmarried person acting alone is not eligible. The law also normally requires a home study unless a judge waives it. Kaplan was unmarried. He nonetheless claimed in court records that he, as the “intended father,” was “unable to carry a pregnancy to term.” Kaplan and SM asked the court to skip the home study. The court initially approved the arrangement. Kaplan was 75 years old when the process began. Average male life expectancy in the United States is roughly 76–78 years. Even under optimistic assumptions, he was highly likely to die or become incapacitated while the child was still a minor — almost certainly before the child was old enough to drive. The child would have been left without his sole legal parent, dependent on whatever arrangements Kaplan had made, or on the state. The criminal history was more immediately alarming. Public records and news reports documented the 2009 convictions and the underlying allegations involving multiple boys. Kaplan’s own attorney for the surrogacy arrangement later withdrew, stating, “It has come to my attention, that [Kaplan] has misrepresented his criminal history to myself and to the Court.” The vice-president and assistant general counsel at the hospital where the child was born submitted a declaration noting that Kaplan’s supporting affidavit claimed he had “never been convicted of a felony or a crime involving moral turpitude,” while publicly available records showed the opposite for a person matching his name and address. According to the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services (DFPS) affidavit in support of removing the child, Kaplan is reported to have acknowledged in Travis County court the eight child-abuse counts and to have described additional uncharged victims. Per the removal affidavit, “When asked if there were other children not identified in previous child abuse allegations, [Kaplan] confirmed that there were additional victims, estimating a total of 17 or 18. Mr. Kaplan described actions including holding some children, suspending them, and blindfolding some of them before engaging in sexual acts.” All of Kaplan’s known prior victims were boys. According to a witness at the court proceeding, Kaplan admitted that he had the opportunity to select the sex of the child ― and chose a boy. Only the Hospital Intervened The surrogacy service that facilitated the arrangement was paid. SM, the “gestational carrier,” received approximately $50,000. Neither party had a financial incentive to scrutinize Kaplan’s background or to halt the process once it was underway. Per court documents, SM later told Texas authorities she had no knowledge of the criminal history, but she wanted “nothing to do with the child or the situation,” and did not want “any backlash.” It was the hospital — Baylor Scott & White Medical Center–Lake Pointe — that intervened on Oct. 31, 2025. The hospital’s standing and jurisdictional arguments were later contested by Kaplan’s counsel as dubious. Nonetheless, the court heard the matter on an emergency basis. On Nov. 12, 2025, a judge canceled the earlier order that approved the surrogacy contract, finding that the supporting sworn statement contained false information. The court barred Kaplan from any possession of, access to, or presence with the child and ordered a home study and psychiatric examination if he continued to pursue the agreement. The child was born the next day. Texas DFPS took emergency custody of the newborn that same week. Genetic testing later confirmed Kaplan as the biological father. Court records show that an August 2026 jury trial resulted in termination of Kaplan’s parental rights on grounds that his conduct endangered the child and that termination was in the child’s best interest, relying in part on the Nebraska convictions. Per court documents, Texas DFPS was given legal custody of the child. The child remains in foster care with documented medical needs. Kaplan filed a notice of appeal on Oct. 5, 2026. He is still fighting to obtain the child. Kaplan on Oct. 6, 2026, one day after filing his notice of appeal, obtained an order from a court in Adams County, Colorado, to discontinue his sex offender registry in that state. Adams County records were not immediately available as of the time of this story, so it is not known whether Kaplan disclosed to the Colorado court that he was actively seeking a male baby in Texas. What This Case Reveals About Surrogacy Groups such as Surrogacy Concern have documented the sharp rise in single men — frequently older — using surrogacy. The Kaplan saga follows a long line of troubling surrogacy incidents, such as 21 children from a single household left parentless after alleged abuse and accused pedophiles who obtained babies via surrogacy. This Texas case shows that even in a jurisdiction with an explicit marriage requirement and a court approval process, legal safeguards can be bypassed. A home-study waiver was granted. The criminal history was not caught until a hospital lawyer checked public records. The financial interests of the surrogacy service and the young woman who carried the child aligned against disclosure. Had the hospital not acted, the approved order would have directed the facility to hand the newborn to Kaplan upon birth, list Kaplan as the father on the birth certificate, and seal the file. The child would have left the hospital with an elderly man then registered as a sex offender whose prior victims were boys and who had specifically chosen a male child. Kaplan testified in Texas court that he is a changed man. The jury nonetheless terminated his parental rights on endangerment grounds. It is troubling, to say the least, to imagine what untold horrors awaited the baby boy if Kaplan behaved as the same man who abused boys in the past. Years of potential abuse. At home. From a “father” who acquired the boy through a neglectful legal system. Texas law should have prevented this at the threshold. It did not. Other states are more permissive still. Whether the remedy is drastic strengthening of eligibility, background, and best-interest requirements — or the elimination of commercial surrogacy altogether — the Kaplan matter demonstrates that the current framework places children at unacceptable risk when adult desire, money, and incomplete information converge. The story is not yet over; Kaplan continues to litigate and seek custody of the child. The author was not involved in the legal proceedings described in this article. Andrew D. Keetch is a Texas attorney and freelance writer. Adams Countychild abuseCriminalDepartment of Family and Protective ServicefelonparentsSanford Kaplansex offendersurrogacySurrogacy ConcernTexasTexas Family CodeTravis CountyUniform Parentage Actvictim
Man Convicted Of Abusing Boys Fights To Obtain Infant Son Born Through Paid Surrogacy
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Thefederalist →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.