Mamdani’s startling omission

Mamdani’s startling omission

Zohran Mamdani is a busy man these days. The socialist mayor of New York City is banning long-standing tourist attractions, demagoguing companies for making customers aware of new government-imposed fees (“affordability!”), and announcing plans to close the city’s central jail while dramatically reducing the incarcerated population. He’s also disbanding an elite New York Police Department unit that he says is unnecessary and abusive. Bill Bratton, the Big Apple’s legendary former police commissioner, formed that unit. In an op-ed published this week, he argued that Mamdani’s takedown of his brainchild is a mistake (emphasis mine):“New York City can reorganize its Police Department, as Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced Monday — but it can’t reorganize away the threats that require a fast, coordinated response. As the commissioner who created the 600-officer Strategic Response Group and the 500-officer Counterterrorism Critical Response Command, I know why we built them — and what they were meant to do. SRG was designed to give the NYPD a trained citywide force that could respond to major incidents, help control crime in troubled areas, support large public events and manage demonstrations that turn into serious disorder. It was also trained to respond to the kind of active-shooter attack that can overwhelm ordinary patrol resources. … New York has learned, often painfully, that crowd management demands preparation, discipline and restraint … [The SRG] gave the department a mobile force that could move quickly across the five boroughs in response to major incidents, crime patterns and civil disorder. Its active-shooter training and equipment were deployed only for the exceptional moment when an armed attacker threatened lives — not as the ordinary tools of protest management.” Recommended Stories “When protests remained peaceful, the SRG’s responsibility was to protect that right and keep the public safe. When unlawful violence or serious disorder emerged, highly trained officers responded with clear command, discipline and the minimum force necessary. SRG officers were very skilled at responding to groups that moved quickly through the city, split into smaller subgroups, or tried to block streets and bridges. … That kind of preparation and training helped the NYPD respond to those intent on vandalism or disruption — without treating every demonstrator as a threat. I cannot overstate the importance of training such a unit together, so that every officer knows and understands which tactics and strategies to use and how to coordinate them. … And it’s not clear that the new structure Mayor Mamdani has announced will preserve the capabilities New York certainly still needs. … Those abilities do not appear simply because an organizational chart changes.” Other experts concur with Bratton’s assessment. Mamdani, whose adult life experience largely amounts to performative activism and dabbling in a rap career, thinks he knows better. The die is now cast, evidently, and thanks to voters, he has the authority to make this consequential decision. As a reminder, the city’s chief executive despises its police department. He repeatedly called for defunding it, referred to its officers as bigots and threats to public safety, and tied the force to another of his obsessive hatreds: Israel’s military. “When the boot of the NYPD is on your neck, it’s been laced by the IDF,” he told a Democratic Socialists of America panel in 2023. (As an aside, he’s still proudly boosting the DSA, an extremist organization that responded to the murderous Hamas massacre that year in a characteristically appalling way.) Mamdani tried to soften his rhetoric closer to the election, but his contempt for the police is very well established. In dismantling the Strategic Response Group, he’s offered a number of justifications, including in one of his signature snappy videos announcing the move. Strangely, he appears to have omitted a bit of personal history that might have factored into his thinking. On a hunch, a solitary journalist went sniffing around and made a remarkable discovery on the subject:“New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani was arrested four times during protests before taking office, including twice by officers from an NYPD unit he now plans to eliminate. … He had previously encountered the unit during protests before becoming mayor. A review of photographs and video footage identified two arrests involving Mamdani and SRG officers, Crain’s New York Business reported Wednesday, November 18. … Mamdani and fellow Assemblymember Marcela Mitaynes were among 17 people arrested during an August 19, 2021, demonstration in downtown Brooklyn calling for an extension of New York’s eviction moratorium, the outlet reported. He was restrained with zip ties and taken into custody by an officer from the NYPD’s SRG. Two months later, Mamdani was arrested outside City Hall during an October 2021 protest demanding debt relief for taxi drivers struggling with loans on their taxi medallions. … At that time, ABC7 footage reviewed by Crain’s New York Business showed SRG officers taking Mamdani into custody.“Yes, you read that correctly. Mamdani is eliminating an NYPD unit that arrested him twice during his various agitations. That seems … rather relevant, does it not? It’s entirely fair to wonder if this policy move is motivated by retribution. It’s certainly a generous gift to left-wing agitators and other non-law-abiding troublemakers. It’s worth noting that those particular arrests do not include the time he was taken into custody outside the home of Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, New York’s powerful U.S. senator, within days of the Oct. 7 terrorist attack that slaughtered dozens of Americans. Mamdani was preemptively opposing the Jewish state’s response to the genocidal attack and chose to do so outside a prominent Jewish leader’s residence. This is the man New Yorkers chose as their mayor, eyes wide open. We’ll all watch with interest to see how this experiment plays out. Speaking of experiments, I’ll leave you with Mamdani being asked about the math — not the feelings or ideology, the math — behind his fixation on government-subsidized grocery stores. Do you hear a math-related answer here? Zohran Mamdani finally got confronted on his city-owned grocery store grift and his response is pure slop."This is an industry that has typically a margin between 1% and 4% and your plan is to sell products at a 30% discount…" pic.twitter.com/oner6IBYWb— George (@BehizyTweets) November 19, 2026 We’ve seen versions of this movie before, in places such as Kansas City and Illinois. Apologies for spoiling the eventual, inevitable ending.

Original Source

Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.