Writer/director David O. Russell’s career has been on the decline in recent years, something truly cemented by the bizarre mess that is Madden, a theoretically heartfelt, NFL-sanctioned look at the life and career of football legend John Madden. Russell can still draw some star power for his productions — Nicolas Cage plays the man in question, and the supporting cast includes Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn, and John Mulaney — but that’s not enough to save this movie. Some straight-to-streaming releases deserve more than being dumped into a New Releases feed. Madden deserves to be a Redbox exclusive, and Redbox died two years ago. Madden begins in the year 1977, as the Madden-led Oakland Raiders set out to play the AFC Championship Game that year — a game that in past seasons they’ve had a bad habit of losing. John’s wife Virginia (Hahn) makes it clear to him what’s at stake: He needs to win that game, then the Super Bowl, so he can finally stop chasing football glory and be more present with his family. Spoiler alert for the 1977 Super Bowl: The Raiders did win it. Spoiler alert for Madden’s life: Football wasn’t done with him yet. As Madden depicts, the years following 1977 find John unable to give up coaching. Egging him on is Al Davis (Bale), the owner of the Raiders and John’s supposed best friend, even though he’s not afraid to manipulate John into continuing to coach at the expense of his health and relationship with his family. When Virginia finally wins and convinces John to retire at last, John quickly finds retirement’s not for him, leading to his second life as a game-changing football commentator, which brought him to national fame. Also, there’s the matter of a very famous video game with his name on it. It’s a man’s life story on the screen, but an overtly goofy one that more often than not makes its central figure the butt of the joke. How much of that is intentional and how much of it is the accidental result of Cage’s performance is unclear: On a physical level, Cage’s Madden resembles John Candy with badly dyed eyebrows, but the actual performance can best be described with words like “incoherent” and “bumbling,” thanks to the way so many of John’s lines and actions feel muddled. Although the movie gives Madden plenty of credit for being a brilliant playmaker and football scholar, there’s something patronizing about Cage’s take; it’s a performance similar in tone and execution to an actor playing George in a community theater’s Of Mice and Men. Meanwhile, Kathryn Hahn’s role as John’s long-suffering wife mostly consists of threatening to leave John for spending too much time on football, then reversing her decision and coming back. It’s an emotional journey that when mapped on the page might best resemble Jeremy Bearimy, and her journey isn’t the only one that makes minimal sense. So much of Madden is executed with the same tone and emotional consistency as a Saturday Night Live cut-for-time sketch, though the blame for that doesn’t fall on the SNL alums in the cast. Well, not entirely. As Electronic Arts founder Trip Hawkins, John Mulaney hams it up big time: For him, every line delivery is a feast, especially when he proclaims to John that those electronic games the kids are playing in arcades will soon be playable at home. Exploring the development and launch of the Madden video games makes sense as a topic considering that it’s how a decent percentage of those under 40 might even know Madden’s name. But while Mulaney often gets laughs, they’re laughs that belong in a totally different movie, adding a whole extra layer of silliness to the proceedings. Madden (Prime Video) Also, Shane Gillis, as John’s neighbor Vince McGary, is clearly meant to be an additional source of comic relief but is more of an annoying cipher — the kind of character who’s so unessential that you totally forget he exists whenever he’s not on screen. Russell and co-writer Cambron Clark perhaps unconsciously sensed this issue, which is why the script calls for Gillis to constantly reintroduce himself as “Vince, I was once John’s neighbor, remember me?” whenever he randomly pops up in another scene. Far more amusing is Marshawn “Beast Mode” Lynch, who has a small role as one of the EA engineers, disguised by goofy glasses and a striped polo. There are scenes in Madden so incoherently written and directed that it’s almost inconceivable to remember that Russell has received five Oscar nominations over the course of his career. At least a half-dozen times, a character expresses feeling one way about a situation, only to later declare that they’ve changed their mind about it. Zero deliberation or character growth is involved in the process. This stands out most egregiously with Bale’s take on Al Davis. The Raiders owner is clearly a fascinating figure that Bale relished playing — Bale being one of those actors who loves an excuse to put on some extreme prosthetics and wig to depict strong personalities — but he’s mostly just mugging for the camera. Most of the movie leans on mockumentary tropes — including direct-to-camera “interviews” with the major characters — but then sometimes Russell abandons the idea completely and goes deep into impressionistic storytelling. A theoretically simple scene, in which a half-dozen people are talking to each other, is filmed in a bizarre series of set-ups so badly edited it’s almost impossible to tell where anyone is standing or who’s talking to who. Despite all of my complaints above, there’s no denying that at the center of this movie is a great deal of affection for the man in question. It’s not a flattering portrait in the slightest, but the affection is still somehow palpable, especially in its depiction of the human touches that made him beloved as a football commentator, like his freewheeling use of the telestrator and tearing apart a turducken with his bare hands on live TV. Ultimately, Madden is successful in making the case for John Madden’s importance to the sport of football. But hopefully the NFL Hall of Fame in the sky — Madden’s vision of what heaven is like — doesn’t subscribe to Prime Video. He shouldn’t have to watch this. Madden kicks off on Prime Video beginning November 18th.
Madden Is a Massive Fumble: Review
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Consequence →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.