Representative Image (AI-generated)A Louisiana couple who paid $429,000 for a house discovered a series of alleged hidden defects after moving in, including a rotted underground air pipe, rodent remains inside the air-conditioning ducts and problems with the swimming pool. They accused the sellers and real estate professionals involved in the transaction of concealing important information about the property's condition and sought damages over what they described as a home that was unfit to live in.In a November 18, 2026, decision available on Justia, the Louisiana Second Circuit Court of Appeal reversed a summary judgment that had dismissed the couple's claims against Group One Realty LLC, doing business as Coldwell Banker Realty One. The court ruled that questions remained about whether the real estate agent who handled the transaction was an independent contractor or an employee of the brokerage, meaning the case could not be dismissed at this stage. It sent the matter back to the district court for further proceedings without deciding whether the brokerage was ultimately liable.Couple discovered alleged defects after purchasing the houseThe case involved Janet Louise Payne Glisson and William Bradley Glisson, who agreed to purchase a property at 126 Llanfair Drive in Ruston, Louisiana, from Edward Jay Ellington and Kathy Riser Ellington. The sellers had signed an exclusive right-to-sell agreement with Group One Realty on May 18, 2021, naming John Christopher Stephenson as their agent. Three days later, the Glissons signed an agreement to purchase the house for $429,000. Stephenson also represented the buyers in the transaction, acting in a dual-agency capacity.The sale was completed on July 22, 2021, and the couple moved into the property on August 7. Before closing, inspections of the house and swimming pool had identified several problems, some of which were reportedly corrected. However, the buyers alleged that they began discovering numerous additional defects after moving in. These included hidden damage to a shed, a crack in the carport's concrete, a leaking sink beneath a cabinet and an underground rotted return-air pipe disconnected from the heating and cooling system.According to their lawsuit, the pipe contained stagnant groundwater and was open to the interior of the house, allowing foul-smelling air, insects and reptiles to enter. They also alleged that the air-conditioning ducts contained dead rodents and rodent droppings, the swimming pool was not functional and the gas supply to the furnace had been disconnected.Lawsuit accused sellers and real estate professionals of concealmentOn August 5, 2022, the Glissons filed a lawsuit seeking damages under Louisiana's redhibition law, along with claims involving breach of contract and fraud. They alleged that the defendants had knowingly misrepresented the property's condition and concealed significant defects before the sale. Group One challenged the claims, arguing that the buyers had waived their rights to seek redhibition damages, that the claims had prescribed and that the allegations against the brokerage were insufficiently specific.The district court initially dismissed the redhibition claims against Group One. The brokerage later sought summary judgment, arguing that Stephenson was an independent contractor rather than an employee and that it could not be held responsible for his alleged misrepresentations. The district court agreed, finding that the buyers had not established that Stephenson was an employee or that anyone associated with Group One knew about the alleged defects. It consequently dismissed the claims against the brokerage with prejudice.Appeals court found a factual dispute over the agent's statusThe Glissons challenged the decision, arguing that the brokerage's relationship with Stephenson required a closer examination before the claims could be dismissed. The appeals court explained that Louisiana law generally treats a sponsored real estate licensee as an independent contractor when certain statutory conditions are satisfied, including a valid written agreement with the sponsoring broker. However, the court noted that the existence of such an agreement does not automatically settle every question about the relationship.Group One had presented an independent agent agreement stating that Stephenson could determine his own working methods and that the brokerage had limited authority to direct his activities. However, the agreement also allowed either party to terminate their relationship at any time without specifying any liability for doing so.The appeals court considered this provision significant. It explained that whether someone is an employee or an independent contractor requires a fact-specific assessment, including the nature of the working relationship and the parties' rights and obligations. The judges concluded that reasonable people could disagree about whether the agreement's termination provision supported treating Stephenson as an employee for purposes of potential vicarious liability. That unresolved factual question made summary judgment inappropriate.Case returns to district courtThe Louisiana Second Circuit reversed the judgment dismissing the Glissons' claims against Group One Realty and remanded the matter for further proceedings. It also assessed the costs of the appeal against the brokerage. The ruling does not establish that the brokerage knew about the alleged defects or that it is liable for the couple's losses. Nor does it decide the underlying claims against the sellers or the agent's estate, which were not at issue in this appeal.Instead, the decision means the couple can continue pursuing their claims against the brokerage, with the disputed employment relationship requiring further consideration rather than being resolved through summary judgment.
Louisiana couple claims dead rodents in ducts of $429k home; court revives suit
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Timesofindia →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.